B

Baroness Finn (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 19 October 2026

Debate

Public Office (Accountability) Bill

Contribution

My Lords, Amendment 34 was tabled in the name of my noble friend Lord Keen of Elie. This amendment seeks to probe the level of guidance and support that will be made available to officials for them to navigate the duty of candour set out in Clause 2. The amendment seeks to ensure that the Bill is effective in practice and that civil servants are properly supported with their legal responsibilities. For this legislation to be as effective as the Government intend it to be, it is essential that officials know how to comply with the duty of candour and are given any necessary support in fulfilling that duty. This matters most in the case of more junior officials, who may lack experience engaging in inquiries or other similar affairs. Can the Minister say in his response what assessment has been made of the difficulties that officials at the most junior level may face in complying with Clause 2(3)(a)? Those officials who are more senior, especially those who have experience engaging with investigations and inquiries, will surely be far better equipped to comply with the duty of candour. Will the Government make specific provision for those officials who lack that experience? The Government have chosen to proceed by imposing a broad, disparate duty of candour on all officials. We understand why they have sought to proceed in this way, given the evidence of South Yorkshire Police altering hundreds of police statements and plain paper accounts following the 1989 Hillsborough disaster. A disparate duty removes the role of the central body, preventing that body altering statements and evidence to the inquiry. However, it cannot be right that junior officials and other officials who lack experience of such engagement with inquiries should be left to navigate their legal responsibilities alone. What legal support will officials be able to draw down either from their department directly or from lawyers funded by their department? The Government might, not unreasonably, say that Civil Service trade unions will take on the responsibility of providing officials with legal advice where an inquiry of relevance to their work is established. I cannot imagine that trade unions would want that responsibility, but it is not unreasonable to think that they might be able to provide officials with the support that they need. I would be interested to hear whether the Minister has discussed the duties in this Bill and their consequences for officials with representatives of the trade unions. Can he tell us what role the trade unions intend to play? Having said that, not all public servants are members of a trade union, and it would not be right for the Government to impose legislation that makes it virtually an occupational necessity to join a trade union. In the circumstances where an official is not a member of a union, as many are not, the question remains: what support will their sponsor department provide? Departments may have even more wide-ranging support to offer. With the broad duty of candour, there is a significant risk that a junior or inexperienced employee might want to have their department provide instructions on what they should and should not provide to an inquiry. What assessment have the Government made of the possible greater role that could and should be played by individual departments, or perhaps a central unit in the Cabinet Office, to ensure that our hard-working public officials are not left to navigate what is clearly a complex law alone? I beg to move.

More from Baroness Finn (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.