Contribution
My Lords, first, I apologise, if I may, to the noble Baroness, Lady Falkner. Her amendment has moved between groups in the past 24 hours, and that was my error. I apologise.
I thank all noble Lords who contributed to the debate on this group, which includes Amendments 34A, 37A, 40A and 42A, tabled by my noble friend Lord Hendy, and Amendments 41 and 43, tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Featherstone. I want to be clear that the Government agree that, where wrongdoing occurs, public officials should be able to raise concerns in confidence and be protected from retaliation. However, without repeating arguments I made from this Dispatch Box on the first day of Committee, the Government’s view is that existing legal protections already provide safeguards for officials under the Employment Rights Act 1996. This Bill will require public authorities to maintain codes of ethical conduct that must ensure that workers are made aware of their whistleblowing rights. Further, the Government are seeking views on the operation of the whistleblowing framework via a consultation that was launched last week. We have already discussed the details of that consultation in Committee and, in the interest of time I will not repeat those points today.
I recognise the concerns expressed by noble Lords about the time required to move from consultation to reform. However, it is important to be reminded that the scope of this Bill applies only to the public sector, although whistleblowing is not an issue confined to the public sector. We would not want to introduce changes through this legislation that create inconsistencies within the wider whistleblowing framework. For those reasons, we believe it would be premature to legislate in this area before the consultation has concluded and the evidence has been fully considered. However, as I mentioned last week, I am looking forward to meeting noble Lords to discuss how we can use the code of ethical conduct to make clearer existing protections, and I ask that those interested feed into the government consultation. I look forward to that meeting with both my noble friend and the noble Baroness.
I want to provide additional reassurances to my noble friend Lord Hendy regarding his Amendment 43A, which seeks to make clear the definition of a qualifying disclosure. The Bill already provides for this by referring to the definition of protected disclosure in the 1996 Act, which, in turn, defines qualifying disclosure. Therefore, we do not feel this amendment is necessary—although I am very aware that I am having an argument with an employment rights lawyer, so I am sure the conversation will continue.
I fully recognise the intention behind Amendment 147, highlighted by the Opposition Front Bench, and the importance of ensuring that Parliament and the public understand the impact of these measures. However, bereaved families and victims rightly expect the Government to implement the provisions in this Bill promptly and effectively. The Government are therefore keen to maintain momentum towards implementation and are not persuaded that additional measures are necessary to achieve that objective.
As noble Lords will be aware, the Government intend to publish a revised impact assessment following Royal Assent, which will provide an updated assessment of the measures contained in the Bill. In the light of that commitment, the Government do not consider the amendment to be necessary, but, given the questions from the noble Lord, Lord Wolfson, I think it will be helpful if I highlight what the current impact assessment says about the estimated cost to public authorities of delivering Clause 10.
The code of ethical conduct provisions will create new burdens on public authorities, including local authorities. The provisions have deliberately been drafted to allow maximum flexibility in implementation. Given that most, if not all, public bodies will already be covered by a form of code, it is not anticipated that the cost impact will be substantial; some lawyers’ time to assess compliance, management time and training— I am not, however, underestimating the cost of lawyers, given who sits in your Lordships’ House.
The scale of these costs will depend on the number of public bodies within scope and the implementation plans informed by the legislation, the extent of the codes, how much can be standardised and so on, which can be fully determined only after Royal Assent, once Members of your Lordships’ House have done their job of scrutiny. A further assessment of impact will take place alongside the development of our implementation plans and underpinning guidance, and a new burdens assessment will be developed at the appropriate time.
I hope that answers the questions raised by noble Lords. I respectfully ask my noble friend to withdraw his amendment.