Contribution
If the noble Baroness quite rightly is not going to speak to her amendment, I will speak to mine, which is in this group. First, I will address Amendment 147 in the name of my noble and learned friend Lord Keen of Elie, to which I have added my name. It seeks to require an impact assessment of the cost of implementing the policy outlined in Clause 10: a policy that would require public authorities to publish a code of ethical conduct.
The reason for this probing amendment is that the existing impact assessments for the Bill do not make any mention of the expected cost of implementation of these proposed measures. It seems to us that there must be a cost of drafting and publishing such a code, so this does seem to be an omission. If, of course, the data exists and just did not make it into the impact assessment, we would of course be very happy to withdraw the amendment. Can the Minister share that cost with the House? If it has not yet been calculated, why has it not, and can it please be calculated and then shared?
More generally, there is limited evidence in fact to indicate that the existence of codes of conduct is sufficient to prevent scandals occurring. There are numerous scandals in recent history that have happened within institutions that already have codes of conduct, such as the NHS. The underlying issue is really conduct, not codes of conduct, and it is not clear to many of us that you change the former by instituting the latter. As it stands, there is every possibility that the cost could be considerable, with every public authority expected to draft their own individual code. How have the Government come to the conclusion that Clause 10 is the right way forward without, it seems, having undertaken an impact assessment on the costs of this new duty? I appreciate here that we start to touch on the points made by the noble Lord, Lord Alton, that call for a single code. I will deal with those in the next group, although of course the points overlap to an extent.
On the other amendments in this group, those in the name of the noble Lord, Lord Hendy, broadly seek to protect those who raise concerns, but we on these Benches would be wary of amendments that seek to add unnecessary consultation burdens, which would be costly and would also delay implementation, as we think Amendment 37A does. On Amendment 34A, which seeks to require public authorities to take all reasonable steps to promote ethical conduct, we understand where the wording has come from, as the Explanatory Note indicates, but the context is vastly different from the specific offence in Clause 2, so it seems to us a little clunky to use that drafting in this case as well.
Amendment 40A seeks to create protection for employees, but we wonder whether that is not already covered sufficiently in the existing Employment Rights Act 1996. Amendment 42A would require a public authority to explain the protection it provides, which would again take more time and money to implement. We already have a huge amount of regulation in this country. Generally, on these Benches, we think we need less rather than more regulation.
I turn to Amendments 41 and 43 from the noble Baroness, Lady Featherstone. Although she is, with respect, right to probe how organisations will in fact undertake their responsibilities to behave ethically, we are concerned that these amendments risk being somewhat overly prescriptive, and we already have concerns, as I have said, about the cost of the implementation of Clause 10. That said, I hope that the Minister will be able to give the noble Baroness some more clarity on what the Government in fact expect of organisations that will be subject to the duties set out in the Bill.