Contribution
My Lords, I have tabled Amendment 62A, together with my noble and learned friend Lord Keen of Elie, to bring attention to the varying length of backlogs. This amendment seeks to help the Government in their mission to reduce the backlogs in the Crown Court by proposing a review of criminal court listing practices, with the view that best practice could be used across the system and therefore increase efficiency across the criminal justice system as a whole.
To take one example, given the hour, in Liverpool—I declare the obvious interest—Preston and Cardiff, a number of measures, including active Crown Prosecution Service case ownership and early trial readiness reviews, have enabled the reduction in backlogs. If those measures were rolled out to other courts—that could be identified in the proposed report—that would assist them as well. Equally, there could be an opportunity to use technology, including AI, to improve the efficiency of our court listing system.
I listened with great interest a couple of days ago to the Cabinet Secretary, with her close interest in the efficiency gains made possible by AI, and I am conscious that she is a former Permanent Secretary at the Ministry of Justice; indeed, we were there together. I would therefore be interested if the Minister could help us understand whether officials in his department have looked at proposals to use AI to increase efficiency of listing. This would provide an alternative solution to backlogs without overburdening the magistrates’ courts and simply shifting the backlog.
For future reference, I have another important point on listing that the review could pick up. The Committee will appreciate from earlier groups that I yield to no one in my desire for judicial independence; I made that point very clear in a number of groups. But when it comes to listing, we have to distinguish between two different things. There is the question of whether Crown against A is going to be heard before or after Crown against B. That is obviously a matter for judges. But then there is the question of whether, for example, domestic burglary cases should be given priority over offences against the person cases. If a future government were to campaign on a manifesto commitment that they regard domestic burglary as the worst possible thing and that it should be given precedence in the criminal justice system, should it be right—I ask with due deference and rhetorically—for listings to remain a judicial practice solely and entirely? It is not clear to me that that ought to be so. Clearly, a Minister should not be saying whether Smith gets his trial before Jones gets hers, but it is not clear to me that the categories of cases should always be a judicial function.
It also was not clear to me when I was in the Ministry of Justice how best practice is rolled out across the system, and what mechanisms really exist to make sure that resident judges not only can but do share best practice, and how best practice is actually enforced. Indeed, the data I saw showed that different courts with the very same mix of cases had very different through-puts and efficiencies. Ultimately, as the Minister knows—sometimes to his cost—Ministers are responsible to Parliament for the justice system and have to come here and answer questions on it. It is not clear to me, therefore, that all elements of listing should remain solely a judicial function, but perhaps we need to pick that point up in more detail on a future occasion.