L

Lord Lemos (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 19 October 2026

Debate

Public Office (Accountability) Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I do not go to restaurants which do not have the prices on the menu. This has been an important and constructive debate about what we all agree is a very important issue that goes to the heart of what we are trying to achieve here in terms of the culture change that we have talked about throughout these discussions. I begin with the amendment from the noble Lord, Lord Alton, which seeks to introduce one national code of conduct and to prevent authorities adopting their own separate codes. Before I comment on that, I would like to thank the noble Lord for his time in meeting with me—we have now had several discussions on this—and for arranging for me to meet the family of Andrew Devine to discuss the Bill. I very much appreciated that; it was a very moving occasion. I thank the noble Lord for those kind remarks about unfailing courtesy. I am not sure that is a description my family and friends would recognise—but different strokes for different folks. I appreciate that the intention of this amendment is to strengthen the provisions in the Bill on ethical codes by trying to prevent public authorities adopting codes which may risk being watered down. I entirely accept that. I can also understand why some campaigners, bereaved families and victims are keen to strengthen these provisions, given the appalling way, as we have all agreed, that they have been treated by the state in the past. Our intention under the Bill is to ensure that codes of ethical conduct are tailored and accessible to the needs of individual sectors. The noble Lord, Lord Evans of Weardale, gave a very elegant and eloquent description of why that might be important. The Bill covers a broad range of public servants and different working environments where a single code may may be too general. All noble Lords—certainly the noble Lords, Lord Marks and Lord Alton—have accepted that there may be some things which need to be specific, and therefore something too general may not be sufficiently specific to drive meaningful cultural change. The Bill will ensure that every public authority is required to reflect on how to embed a duty of candour within a tailored code of conduct specific to their organisation and sector. The Bill provides clarity on what these codes must contain as a minimum. We will publish statutory guidance after Royal Assent, which will support public authorities to make impactful codes that will drive ethical behaviour throughout the organisation. The Government are keen for the provisions on codes of ethical conduct to be implemented within an optimal period post Royal Assent. However, I can understand the concerns that have been raised and a need to ensure that we are clear on what is expected and required in each code. Therefore, I am very happy to commit to working with noble Lords in this debate, and other Peers, on how best we can achieve this. And, of course, we will talk about the questions about resources which the noble Lord, Lord Wolfson, and others have raised. I cannot promise to write with a detailed assessment, for the reasons that my noble friend gave, but we are obviously mindful of the resources point and we are very happy to debate it. I now turn to the amendment tabled by the noble Lord which would require a consultation on a single national code of conduct, sanctions and enforcement arrangements. It is right, when we are designing what is required in a code of ethical conduct, that we consider the views of those who represent public servants, experts, and those with lived experience of grave injustices at the hands of the state. I am not convinced at this stage that a single code of conduct is the most effective way to achieve the cultural change we are seeking, but I am open to considering how best we can engage with relevant stakeholders when considering how we can strengthen the provisions of the Bill on codes of ethical conduct. I hope noble Lords know that I will continue to work closely with noble Lords on this. In the same vein, turning now to my noble friend Lord Hendy’s amendment, which builds on the proposals of the noble Lord, Lord Alton, I hope the noble Lord will forgive me for not going into too much detail, as we discussed this matter earlier. However, I reassure the noble Lord that the Government consider that existing legal protections already provide safeguards for officials who speak up about alleged wrongdoing, as my noble friend Lady Anderson described earlier. The noble Lord, however, raises an important point regarding engaging with trade unions and relevant stakeholders, including ACAS, to ensure that their codes of ethical conduct were appropriately tailored to their organisation. I will reflect on the comments he has made about today and would, of course, be happy to meet with him to discuss this ahead of Report I now turn to Amendment 36 from the noble Baroness, Lady Hamwee, which builds on the proposal from the noble Lord, Lord Alton. Throughout the passage of the Bill, the Government have worked closely with members of the public who have been victims of major incidents and grave injustices, and we fully intend to continue this approach. I can assure the noble Baroness that there is ongoing policy work taking place around the role of the Independent Public Advocate. I have been in touch with the noble Baronesses, Lady May and Lady Sanderson, about that work. That is a very live discussion. So, we will certainly take into account the spirit of her suggestion in that conversation. But I have made clear from this Dispatch Box before that we see the role of the Independent Public Advocate in victim support and representation as a critical part of the future arrangements that surround major incidents. I will deal with the question about retirement. Two or three noble Lords have raised this from different perspectives—not all in agreement. Current and former employees are covered by the code—the Government are quite clear about this—in an inquiry or investigation into an incident or event when someone was in post, even if they have retired since. We are very clear about that. I hear what the noble Baroness, Lady Falkner, says, but we are clear, for all the reasons that a number of noble Lords made, that people will still be covered by the duty of candour in those circumstances. With regard to the code of ethics, obviously it is more difficult to apply something to people for whom it was not in place at the time they were there—but on the wider duty of candour, which is the principal thing, I think that I have made the position clear. On the Civil Service Code—I responded to the noble Lord, Lord Young, about this—we are very clear that all codes which exist already will have to meet the requirements of the Bill. I would not have the temerity to suggest anything to the Cabinet Secretary, but once the Bill is passed and we know the requirements for the code of ethics and how they will be organised, she will have to ensure that whatever arrangements are in place in the Civil Service meet those requirements. With these reassurances to continue the conversation—and I look forward to that—I ask noble Lords to withdraw their amendments.

More from Lord Lemos (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.