Contribution
My Lords, I should make it clear that we do not intend by the detailed amendments in this group to undermine our support for the establishment of a core code, for all the reasons that we and others have outlined in the last group. Our amendments in this group are directed to amending the Bill as drafted, but I should stress, as we stressed in the last group, that they are applicable to a single core code, taken together with any supplementary codes adopted by particular public bodies or authorities. However, all are directed to giving the codes teeth requiring compliance and strengthening enforcement.
Amendment 37 would strengthen Clause 10(3)(b), which requires a public authority to take steps to make people who work for the authority
“aware of the code and the consequences for failing to act in accordance with it”.
Amendment 37 substitutes a much stronger position, which requires the authority to
“take all reasonable steps to ensure that those people … are aware of the code and the consequences of failing to act in accordance with it, and … comply with the code fully”.
Amendment 39
“would require a public authority’s code of ethical conduct to specify when a failure to comply with the standards of conduct must be referred for investigation as a potential criminal offence, in addition to setting out disciplinary consequences for breaches”.
That ties in with what I said in the previous group about the importance of linking serious breaches of the code with criminal sanctions.
Amendment 44 would allow a public authority to
“adopt another document as its code of ethical conduct”.
In a sense, that is applicable to the Bill as drafted rather than to when there is a core code, but it would provide, importantly, which would be consistent with a core code, that the document must not be modified
“in a way which reduces the standards of ethical conduct contained in it”.
Amendments 46 and 47 would mandate consistency between codes and demand an explanation of how consistency should be achieved. That would be relevant to consistency between supplementary codes and a core code.
Amendment 55 would require a set of minimum requirements that any code must meet, including arrangements made to ensure compliance, which would have to be specified, and procedures which would have to be followed in the case of non-compliance.
From our point of view, the most important of the amendments in this group is the introduction of a provision for a new criminal offence of a serious breach of a code of ethical conduct. That is designed to supplement the offences of misconduct in public office and misleading the public which are already in the Bill. It is part of the business of giving teeth to the imposition of ethical standards, which we regard as so necessary. The codes are here to be obeyed.
The problem with the Nolan standards and with provision for ethical standards in authorities in the past is that there has been no criminal sanction and only moderate and ill-matched sanction by disciplinary proceedings—ill-matched in the sense that different public authorities have been free to use different sanctions. We regard it as very important that, ultimately, there should be recourse to the criminal law, where failure is knowing or reckless and where that failure is serious.
The amendment defines “serious”. It has to be a failure which
“causes, or creates a significant risk of, serious harm to another person … involves dishonesty, corruption or abuse of public office”,
which involves a “serious breach” of the Nolan principles, or which
“seriously undermines … confidence in the public authority or the proper exercise of its functions”.
That would be punishable on summary conviction by 12 months’ imprisonment or a fine or both, and on indictment by two years’ imprisonment or a fine or both. It is a central feature of our suite of amendments and gives meaning to the imposition of compulsory standards.
We would not expect a vast number of prosecutions, but if we are serious about wanting a change of culture, we have to move from extolling standards to enforcing those standards. If serious breaches of the code lead to criminal proceedings, that best serves the aims of showing the public that we are serious about enforcing standards, for reasons of deterrence, to ensure that officials know that there will be serious consequences if they are guilty of a serious breach of the code, and a punishment which is a part of the process of penalties in the criminal courts.
We believe that serious cases of failure to comply with the code must be prosecuted. That is at the heart of our approach to accountability. It is backed up by a duty on public authorities to take all reasonable steps to prevent, detect and respond to possible offences, and by regulations governing the enforcement of the provisions of a code. Again, we say that it should be a common core code, supplemented by others. Criminal sanctions would apply whether or not disciplinary proceedings were brought. The minimum standards would have to reflect the Nolan principles. Under Amendment 58, there would be a periodic review of codes by the Ethics and Integrity Commission.
Together, this suite of amendments, we say, would make the enforcement of ethical standards a reality. We are very concerned that the Bill, as drafted, without those backstop provisions, would not do that. I beg to move.