Contribution
My Lords, this is probably an appropriate time for me to speak to my Amendment 63A, given that the noble Lord, Lord Marks of Henley-on-Thames, has set out the Lib Dem amendment. In doing so, I am required by the Companion to declare my interest every time I intervene, so I declare my interest as a distinguished fellow of the think tank Policy Exchange. I am informed in the remarks I make by its recent report on the Bill, which is called Legislating for Candour?
My amendment would seek to deal with the effect of obligations imposed by or under Chapter 2. We know that Clause 10 will impose a new general duty on public bodies to promote and take steps to maintain high standards of ethical conduct at all times by people who work for the authority. Clause 10 also imposes a more specific duty to create and publish a new code of ethical conduct for people who work for the public authority. We have been discussing that for the last hour—so far, so good. This amendment aims to address or ameliorate the risk that these duties will expose public bodies to judicial review proceedings, which is likely to prove costly and undermine their ability to discharge their primary functions.
It is not clear whether the Government appreciate the risk that Clause 10 without amendment may give rise to new grounds on which to challenge public action in the courts, enabling the frustration of attempts to address serious policy problems, which is what we are trying to do here, and adding to the cost of doing government business. I say that advisedly at this stage because we know that the ability to crowdfund often vexatious attempts at judicial review is increasing by the day and that they are adding enormously to the cost of doing government business.
Outside the context of the Bill, the Government seem concerned about these risks. On 7 September this year, the Chancellor, the Attorney-General and the First Secretary of State sent a joint letter to Ministers about the simplification and agency of government. In the letter, the Government accept that
“in some instances it has become clear that the system of judicial review is out of balance”
and a disproportionate burden on effective government. The letter announces three changes and frames them in this way:
“We therefore wanted to set out three areas where this Government will act with greater alacrity—on consultations, on legal considerations, and on judicial review—as initial steps in what will be a wider programme of work to pare back counterproductive administrative burdens”.
This is a commendable ambition; I certainly share it. It may be in some tension with the Bill in general, which certainly imposes significant new administrative burdens, as set out in the report from Policy Exchange that I highlighted. That paper notes that, as things stand:
“Every public body in the country, from a government department to a parish council or a further education college, acquires a new set of uncertain legal obligations layered on top of the existing”—
and already extensive and onerous—
“grounds for review”.
In relation to Clause 10 in particular, the Government should make it clear whether they intend the duties in this clause to ground new applications for judicial review of the action of public bodies; that is, new grounds on which a court might block them. If this is the Government’s intention, it seems very hard to justify. Why would one want to empower the courts to police the ethical conduct of public bodies, a task for which they are ill suited? It is true and important that courts protect natural justice, but enforcing a duty to act ethically or policing compliance with a broadly worded code of ethical conduct is much more general; it is an ill-defined task which we should not invite the courts to carry out.
If the Government do not intend Clause 10 to widen the grounds of judicial review, the Bill needs amending. Whenever a public body publishes a code, there may be a risk that third parties will challenge the public body’s actions in court by reference to the code. There are numerous examples of that that I can send to the Minister. The risk is much greater when the code has a statutory footing, especially when, as with Clause 10, the code is intended to be a means to fulfil the more general duty of ensuring that those who work for the public authority act lawfully.