Contribution
My Lords, it is a pleasure to follow the noble Baroness, but I am afraid that not even her advocacy could persuade me that a failure by a public official or public authority to have regard to the requirements of a code or of guidance should be left entirely out of account by any court which might be called on to decide whether that conduct was improper, irrational, negligent or unlawful. Others, I am sure, will make the point more eloquently than I, but I wanted to record that before speaking, perhaps more prosaically, to my probing Amendments 60 and 62, which I have tabled with the support of the noble and learned Lord, Lord Leveson, and the noble Lords, Lord Carlile and Lord Evans of Weardale, who was—as mentioned earlier—chair of the Committee on Standards in Public Life until 2023.
The CSPL was replaced after the election by the Ethics and Integrity Commission, whose purpose, as billed in the Labour manifesto, is
“to ensure probity in government”.
The EIC’s terms of reference, published in October 2025, make specific reference to this Bill. They state under the heading “Responsibilities” that the EIC will:
“Advise public authorities on the development of clear codes of conduct with effective oversight arrangements, in line with the planned forthcoming obligations of the Public Office (Accountability) Bill”.
Yet the Bill makes no reference to the EIC. It is given no formal role in the formulation of the codes—or code, as it may be—of ethical conduct under Clause 10, even as a consultee. The guidance issued under Clause 11 is to be issued by the central and devolved Governments, again without any involvement from the EIC.
The Minister told us at Second Reading—I am grateful to him for engaging on this—that the EIC would
“research and develop guidance … that will be published on its website”.—[Official Report, 1/9/26; col. 111.]
However, given its intended status as the centre of excellence on public codes of ethical conduct, at least for England, I am mystified as to why the Bill does not give the EIC a leading role in formulating at least the statutory guidance provided for in Clause 11. That is the defect that Amendment 60 is intended to probe and, should it go further, to correct.
Amendment 62 raises a broader point. In its 2021 report, Upholding Standards in Public Life, the CSPL, under the leadership of the noble Lord, Lord Evans of Weardale, recommended placing a number of constitutional watchdogs on a statutory footing to give them at least the protections of Parliament. Bodies such as the independent Commissioner for Public Appointments, the Independent Adviser on Ministerial Standards and the Advisory Committee on Business Appointments have important constitutional functions, hard won over successive Administrations, in proofing our system against abuse of power, favouritism and corruption. Yet it would be the easiest thing in the world for a future Government impatient of such liberal notions to sweep them all away in a first-day bonfire of the quangos without the need even to justify their decision to Parliament. Until such time as it is placed on a statutory footing, the same will be true of the EIC. Amendment 62 would place a parliamentary lock on the abolition of the EIC in much the same way that my Private Member’s Bill, the Public Service (Ethics, Integrity and Independence) Bill, introduced last Session, would have done for the other bodies I have mentioned.
The EIC’s implementation plan of October 2025 warns that
“it will take time to develop and implement the EIC’s new responsibilities”
and sets out an 18 to 24-month plan for the transition of the Committee on Standards in Public Life into the Ethics and Integrity Commission, subject to the necessary resources being in place. But there is no obstacle to the EIC being recognised in statute even before that transition is complete. I hope the Minister will agree that such recognition is desirable in principle and I look forward to his comments on how and when we might expect to see it.