L

Lord Norton of Louth (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 19 October 2026

Debate

Teaching of Citizenship

Contribution

My Lords, at the weekend the noble Lord, Ricketts, warned of the threats posed by hybrid attacks on our national infrastructure. The threats are growing and becoming more dangerous. They threaten our very system of government and the values that underpin it. We are vulnerable because of the spread of disinformation and false narratives, not least through social media. Many people, especially young people, lack the critical capacity to interrogate the veracity of what is posted and lack an understanding of how our system works and what it delivers to them and to society as a whole. The pervasive use of social media also serves to undermine community engagement, with people no longer coming together to pursue their interests and engage in social discourse. The dissemination of fake news by malign sources, whether domestic or foreign, serves to undermine trust in our political system and culture. The 2023 ONS Trust in government survey found that a majority of those questioned, 57%, had low or no trust in both government and Parliament. Our system of government, how we choose to govern ourselves and the values that underpin a healthy polity—adherence to the rule of law, justice and tolerance—have built up over the centuries, producing a stable, pluralist society, but its endurance rests on the trust and vigilance of its citizens. As Stanley Baldwin memorably put it: “We have to remember that the price of liberty is eternal vigilance, and, I may add, eternal knowledge, eternal sympathy, and eternal understanding”. My thesis is that we need to act, and to do so as a matter of urgency to enhance knowledge and understanding. That will not happen without action on our part. As the noble Lord, Lord Hodgson of Astley Abbotts, said in opening a debate in 2018 on the report of the Select Committee on Citizenship and Civic Education, “our fellow citizens, of any age, do not learn about how our society works … by magic. It has to be taught, and taught well”. He went on to say: “While our committee heard evidence of some inspiring work going on in schools, too often it appears that schools regard citizenship education as a ‘nice to have’, not a ‘must have’. Surely that needs to be reversed”.—[Official Report, 19/11/18; col. 69.] The committee’s report concluded: “The Government has allowed citizenship education in England to degrade to a parlous state. The decline of the subject must be addressed in its totality as a matter of urgency”. The best defence against the attack on our democratic system is a vibrant civic culture. That is what constitutes the basis of this question this evening. The onus is on government to act as a matter of urgency, though we all have a role to play. I welcome changes that the Government have announced to the provision of citizenship teaching. They are necessary but, as I shall argue, not sufficient. The Government have accepted the recommendations of the Curriculum and Assessment Review and are making citizenship teaching compulsory for primary school children. There will be a revised national curriculum for teaching in 2028. Resources are also being made available through the Oak National Academy as well as the Electoral Commission. However, much more needs to be done. There is a problem in teaching citizenship at key stages 3 and 4. Many schools lack a subject specialist. Eight out of 10 teachers who teach citizenship do not have a relevant post-A-level qualification in the subject. I fear that citizenship taught badly may be worse than no teaching at all. Fewer than 5% of pupils opt for GCSE citizenship studies. We know from surveys the value of such education. Exposure to citizenship content is associated with stronger support for democracy, tolerance, confidence in the ability to make a difference, and intention to vote. That is exactly what is needed. To take citizenship seriously, schools need incentives. Ofsted inspections need to give citizenship the same attention as other curriculum subjects and, as recommended by the Association for Citizenship Teaching, assess pupils’ knowledge alongside opportunities for participation. Schools need to demonstrate that pupils have secured the statutory citizenship learning. Incentives need to be matched by serious investment in recruiting and training citizenship teachers, not least through the provision of training bursaries, and in enabling primary schools to deliver on the responsibilities that are being vested in them. That investment must not be seen as some discrete responsibility of the Department for Education and a drain on its budget. It must be embraced by government as an essential tool in the nation’s defence against the threats it faces. Enhancing citizenship education is not among the recommendations of the Rycroft review to tackle foreign interference in UK politics, but it is a logical extension of what is proposed. It should be core to the work of the Government’s Defending Democracy Taskforce. Embedding citizenship teaching in schools is necessary but, even with adequate resourcing, it is not sufficient. We need a politically aware population. Citizenship needs to be embedded in society. I welcome the aspiration of the Association of Colleges for every college to offer students a high-quality political literacy programme. We need to extend such literacy to others in society, utilising any organisation that draws people together. The Electoral Commission may play a valuable role. Its democratic education framework is aimed at young people, but merits being extended to bodies in civil society to reach adults. We need to think what other public bodies can contribute to raising political awareness. Will the Minister confirm that what is needed and what she will pursue is a whole of government strategy to embrace and fund citizenship teaching, along the lines I have outlined, to tackle the ever-growing challenges posed to this nation by disinformation and false narratives? We know young people recognise the need to be better informed and benefit from such education. We need to ensure that they and their elders get that education, for all our sakes.

More from Lord Norton of Louth (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.