Hansard·Lords Chamber·Vol. 860

Teaching of Citizenship

Monday, 19 October 2026

22 contributions17 members

Contributions

  1. Question for Short Debate

    View contribution permalink →

  2. Asked by

    View contribution permalink →

  3. Lord Norton of Louth

    To ask His Majesty’s Government what steps they are taking to enhance provision for the teaching of citizenship.

    View contribution permalink →

  4. Lord Norton of Louth (Con)

    My Lords, at the weekend the noble Lord, Ricketts, warned of the threats posed by hybrid attacks on our national infrastructure. The threats are growing and becoming more dangerous. They threaten our very system of government and the values that underpin it. We are vulnerable because of the spread of disinformation and false narratives, not least through social media. Many people, especially young people, lack the critical capacity to interrogate the veracity of what is posted and lack an understanding of how our system works and what it delivers to them and to society as a whole. The pervasive use of social media also serves to undermine community engagement, with people no longer coming together to pursue their interests and engage in social discourse. The dissemination of fake news by malign sources, whether domestic or foreign, serves to undermine trust in our political system and culture. The 2023 ONS Trust in g overnment survey found that a majority of those questioned, 57%, had low or no trust in both government and Parliament. Our system of government, how we choose to govern ourselves and the values that underpin a healthy polity—adherence to the rule of law, justice and tolerance—have built up over the centuries, producing a stable, pluralist society, but its endurance rests on the trust and vigilance of its citizens. As Stanley Baldwin memorably put it: “We have to remember that the price of liberty is eternal vigilance, and, I may add, eternal knowledge, eternal sympathy, and eternal understanding”. My thesis is that we need to act, and to do so as a matter of urgency to enhance knowledge and understanding. That will not happen without action on our part. As the noble Lord, Lord Hodgson of Astley Abbotts, said in opening a debate in 2018 on the report of the Select Committee on Citizenship and Civic Education, “our fellow citizens, of any age, do not learn about how our society works … by magic. It has to be taught, and taught well”. He went on to say: “While our committee heard evidence of some inspiring work going on in schools, too often it appears that schools regard citizenship education as a ‘nice to have’, not a ‘must have’. Surely that needs to be reversed ”.—[ Official Report , 19/11/18; col. 69.] The committee’s report concluded: “The Government has allowed citizenship education in England to degrade to a parlous state. The decline of the subject must be addressed in its totality as a matter of urgency”. The best defence against the attack on our democratic system is a vibrant civic culture. That is what constitutes the basis of this question this evening. The onus is on government to act as a matter of urgency, though we all have a role to play. I welcome changes that the Government have announced to the provision of citizenship teaching. They are necessary but, as I shall argue, not sufficient. The Government have accepted the recommendations of the Curriculum and Assessment Review and are making citizenship teaching compulsory for primary school children. There will be a revised national curriculum for teaching in 2028. Resources are also being made available through the Oak National Academy as well as the Electoral Commission. However, much more needs to be done. There is a problem in teaching citizenship at key stages 3 and 4. Many schools lack a subject specialist. Eight out of 10 teachers who teach citizenship do not have a relevant post-A-level qualification in the subject. I fear that citizenship taught badly may be worse than no teaching at all. Fewer than 5% of pupils opt for GCSE citizenship studies. We know from surveys the value of such education. Exposure to citizenship content is associated with stronger support for democracy, tolerance, confidence in the ability to make a difference, and intention to vote. That is exactly what is needed. To take citizenship seriously, schools need incentives. Ofsted inspections need to give citizenship the same attention as other curriculum subjects and, as recommended by the Association for Citizenship Teaching, assess pupils’ knowledge alongside opportunities for participation. Schools need to demonstrate that pupils have secured the statutory citizenship learning. Incentives need to be matched by serious investment in recruiting and training citizenship teachers, not least through the provision of training bursaries, and in enabling primary schools to deliver on the responsibilities that are being vested in them. That investment must not be seen as some discrete responsibility of the Department for Education and a drain on its budget. It must be embraced by government as an essential tool in the nation’s defence against the threats it faces. Enhancing citizenship education is not among the recommendations of the Rycroft review to tackle foreign interference in UK politics, but it is a logical extension of what is proposed. It should be core to the work of the Government’s Defending Democracy Taskforce. Embedding citizenship teaching in schools is necessary but, even with adequate resourcing, it is not sufficient. We need a politically aware population. Citizenship needs to be embedded in society. I welcome the aspiration of the Association of Colleges for every college to offer students a high-quality political literacy programme. We need to extend such literacy to others in society, utilising any organisation that draws people together. The Electoral Commission may play a valuable role. Its democratic education framework is aimed at young people, but merits being extended to bodies in civil society to reach adults. We need to think what other public bodies can contribute to raising political awareness. Will the Minister confirm that what is needed and what she will pursue is a whole of government strategy to embrace and fund citizenship teaching, along the lines I have outlined, to tackle the ever-growing challenges posed to this nation by disinformation and false narratives? We know young people recognise the need to be better informed and benefit from such education. We need to ensure that they and their elders get that education, for all our sakes.

    View contribution permalink →

  5. Lord Blunkett (Lab)

    My Lords, I thank the noble Lord, Lord Norton, and I agreed with every word he said. I thank him for referring to the 2018 Select Committee on which I served. In the very short time available, I will make just three points. First, it is excellent that the officials from the Department for Education are working extremely well with the Association of Citizenship Teaching, of which I am a long-standing honorary president, to make sure that we get the materials right and that we ensure that the teaching is of the quality that we would wish. Secondly, I welcome the work of the Electoral Commission and the materials that it is putting out over the current year and into 2028, but I ask that it co-ordinates with the work of the department and the revised citizenship curriculum, so that it makes sense not just in schools and colleges but to post-16 young people who are not in those formal settings. Thirdly, we should bring forward the revised citizenship curriculum to 2027. It is possible, speaking as a former Education and Employment Secretary and someone who has taught in further education, to bring forward parts of that revised curriculum to September next year in time to inform, educate and equip young people to take on voting at the ages of 16 and 17. If we do not, it will be a dereliction of duty.

    View contribution permalink →

  6. Lord Wallace of Saltaire (LD)

    My Lords, it is a pleasure to follow the noble Lord, Lord Blunkett, given that the University of Sheffield and Bernard Crick in particular were leaders in talking about citizenship education. Earlier this year, ahead of the Representation of the People Bill reaching our House, I visited a number of secondary schools in London and Yorkshire to ask how they planned to adjust their curriculum to prepare students to exercise their vote from 16. I was shaken by how little time any of them currently had for education about democracy, law and citizenship, including in one of England’s leading independent schools. One hour a week for all aspects of personal development—personal relationships, finance, drugs, online stress, fakes and misinformation, bullying and grooming, health, careers, British values and democracy—is a crazy race through too many important topics. The students I met admitted how little they knew about political issues but were very keen to know more. After the first Reform Act, the Earl of Eldon argued in a debate in this House against educating the working classes as it would give them ideas above their station. A recent Telegraph op-ed argued similarly that political education is dangerous because left-wing teachers will indoctrinate students with subversive ideas. Yes, democracy is about encouraging citizens to think for themselves, to challenge authority and the received wisdom, and to understand the balance between rights and responsibilities that underpins our democratic society. Public trust in our political institutions is lower than in most comparable democratic states. The weakening of our local democracy has made politics more remote; for most citizens, it looks like a distant game played in Westminster. The replacement of newspapers and radio by social media as the primary source of information has left many young people desperately uninformed about the structures and difficult choices that shape our politics. We need cross-party support for better political education and to make more room in our crowded national curriculum for students to learn about how to be active, informed and responsible citizens.

    View contribution permalink →

  7. The Lord Bishop of Peterborough

    My Lords, in our Church of England schools, we are proud of the role we play in preparing young people of all faiths and none to participate thoughtfully, respectfully and confidently in our diverse arena of public life. However, many of our schools serve small, rural communities, and therefore have far less flexibility when it comes to specialist staffing. In light of the Government’s decision to lower the voting age, can the Minister say what steps will be taken to ensure that all schools are adequately resourced to deliver the high-quality citizenship education that young people will need to fulfil this new responsibility? We should also afford sufficient attention to the programme of study for key stage 1. We want our youngest children to recognise the difference between right and wrong, to understand that they belong to various communities and to realise that people and other living things have a responsibility to each other. By grounding early education in these fundamental values, we can foster an environment of fellowship with one another that enables human flourishing and invests in a bright future for our communities. We should not treat early citizenship learning as an afterthought, but as a central pillar of our education that invests in a bright future for our country.

    View contribution permalink →

  8. Lord Patten (Con)

    My Lords, I strongly agree with my noble friend Lord Norton of Louth that citizenship education should extend deeply into other bodies engaged in civil society. As we know, all politics is basically local politics, and as a very long-standing local resident in the City of Westminster I am glad to see that Westminster City Council now has a deputy cabinet member designated for civic matters—indeed, for civic pride. That is a very good thing for local authorities to turn their attention to in order to shore up the key values of our British polity. Providentially, this debate comes at a critical time for the peaceful polity of many countries in Europe and beyond, such as India, where in recent weeks we have seen a lot of uncivil youthquakes bursting out all over their societies—tragically, particularly in France. I have seen these maybe harmless student demonstrations being suddenly transmogrified into something very much more serious, with savage assaults on the very ideal of fraternity and the free benefits of education in civil society. Mercifully, we in the UK have been spared this sort of thing, and long may that last. We must spread the message as quickly as possible, starting with schools. If you look at the school record, the number of people studying GCSEs in citizenship has plummeted. The number of people qualified to teach it has plummeted. There are not enough people to take up the challenge to show leadership. It is not only within schools but is critically important there, as the noble Lord, Lord Blunkett, pointed out. What I find very hard to understand is that there is not even a bursary for initial teacher training. Can the Minister say why?

    View contribution permalink →

  9. Baroness Gill (Lab)

    My Lords, the upcoming national curriculum reforms, making citizenship compulsory in primary schools and deepening focus on democracy and media literacy in secondary schools, are an excellent step forward. However, you can teach the mechanics of a democratic system, but you cannot put in a syllabus the courage it takes to step up and use them. True citizenship requires us to step completely out of our comfort zones. When I look back at my own journey, my real integration into society did not just happen in a classroom. It happened when I forced myself into unfamiliar spaces. Joining team sports and the school orchestra taught me how to co-operate with completely different groups of people. Later, the Duke of Edinburgh’s Award pushed me even further. It led me to the doorstep of an elderly lady. Every week, I did her shopping and simply sat and spoke with her. That single step out of my own world gave me a profound, real-world understanding of my local community. It taught me empathy, history and shared responsibility. My deepest concern today is that we are losing these opportunities, as many noble Lords have mentioned. Too many young people are absorbed in social media, simply reinforcing their own narrow subcultures. Even at home, the cultural landscape has fractured. The demise of mainstream terrestrial channels means families no longer gather around a shared cultural touchstone. Instead, individuals are immersed in TikTok or streaming that caters strictly to their existing interests. We have stopped sharing, and that stops us understanding and empathising with the wider fabric of British society. So, while we must applaud the Government’s decisive action to strengthen classroom citizenship, we cannot let the state do all the heavy lifting. Policy alone cannot build a community.

    View contribution permalink →

  10. Lord Carter of Haslemere (CB)

    My Lords, our 16 and 17 year-olds are to be given the vote and there are around 1.5 million of them. This is at a time when our politics have never been so febrile and unpredictable. There is therefore a burning question as to whether our young people are equipped with the knowledge they need to use their vote in an informed way, or even want to vote at all. The good news is that citizenship education is already part of the national curriculum at key stages 3 and 4. This says that pupils “should” be taught about democratic government, the key elements of the UK constitution, human rights, financial matters, a free press, et cetera. But it is one thing to write these things into the national curriculum and quite another to deliver them in practice. Many pupils are not being taught these things at all or there is insufficient attention given to their importance, which explains why Professor Becky Francis’s review of the national curriculum found a less than 5% take-up of citizenship at GCSE, as the noble Lord, Lord Norton, has pointed out. There should be more teachers trained in citizenship issues who can teach the subject in an impartial and engaging way in every school. As the noble Lord, Lord Blunkett, graphically put it in a previous debate on citizenship education, “we must get rid of the Catch-22, which is that if you do not teach children, they will not go forward through the GCSE. If they do not do that”, there will be less government support “to train more teachers—and round we go ”.—[ Official Report , 18/10/24; col. 332.] Can the Minister say how many teachers have been recruited from the money raised from VAT on private schools and how many of these will be trained to teach citizenship? Ideally, there needs to be a teacher trained in citizenship in every school. Only then will it be a part of the national curriculum at key stages 1 to 4 in a meaningful way for teachers and pupils alike, with all the massive benefits this will have for society as a whole.

    View contribution permalink →

  11. Baroness Berridge (Con)

    My Lords, the lack of specialist teachers for citizenship, as my noble friend Lord Norton outlined, means that schools have had to be super-flexible in how they teach this subject. In some schools, it is a stand-alone, with a few going on to GCSE; in some, it is taught across the curriculum in history, RE and politics; in some, it is merged with PHSE; in some, it is part of the pastoral curriculum taught first thing in the morning in forms; and in some, it is taught as part of fundamental British values. Such flexibility is not necessarily a bad thing. When the charity Freedom Declared Foundation, of which I am a trustee, together with Regent’s Park College in Oxford—in which I must declare an interest—sought to create secondary school resources on freedom of religion or belief in the UK with RE teachers, the teachers arrived equipped with the exam board curriculums in citizenship and neatly slotted it in. My main question to His Majesty’s Government is this: how much emphasis is there, whether at primary or at secondary, on why we are a democracy? Encouraging young people to vote and volunteer is necessary, but when algorithms are sending mainly boys to the glorification of the strong-man view of government, along with some far-right streams of thought, for how long will they be able to make the distinction between the strong man and the dictator? Are teachers being equipped with this information about the algorithms? This month, America—the so-called leader of the free world—was classified by the academics Levitsky and Way as a competitive authoritarian state, in which: “Elections remained real, but incumbents systematically abused state institutions to tilt the playing field against opponents”. The context in which citizenship is being taught is very different from when any noble Lord was at school. Why we are a democracy is seriously under challenge. Flexibility needs to be supplemented by specialist training to keep apace with such algorithms.

    View contribution permalink →

  12. Lord Doyle (Non-Afl)

    My Lords, I thank the noble Lord, Lord Norton of Louth, for securing this debate and for his excellent speech. It is a great pleasure to follow my former boss and noble friend Lord Blunkett, who has been such a great advocate on this topic. I speak as a passionate advocate myself for citizenship education and its role in building the resilient, informed and engaged citizens of the future. So how do we get from good intentions to good implementation? First, we must acknowledge some of the problems with the habit of suggesting simply that adding something to the national curriculum solves a problem. We have a smorgasbord of RHSE, PHSE, financial and digital literacy, enterprise education, and so on. While all these demands are perfectly reasonable, the curriculum cannot simply be an ever-growing list of things that politicians and campaigners think are important. There are, therefore, four things I believe we need to do. The first is to understand what is already being taught rather than simply trying to add more and more obligations. The second is to bring these subjects together. What do we want our young people to know and be able to do when they leave school, and why? Let us create one coherent curriculum with clear priorities and carefully sequenced content. Thirdly, we need to give it the right time. Head teachers are already having to make choices and cannot keep absorbing new demands, especially for non-examined subjects. We already have a model in PE: schools widely provide two hours a week without making it an examined subject. Let us establish one hour a week for this new combined curriculum, with a clear national expectation, including Ofsted inspection. Fourthly, let us support teachers. We need excellent curriculum materials through organisations such as the Association for Citizenship Teaching and the Oak National Academy, so that teachers can deliver these lessons confidently and effectively. This way, we can have a coherent, stable and deliverable approach to preparing our young people for life.

    View contribution permalink →

  13. Lord Elliott of Mickle Fell (Con)

    My Lords, I would like to talk about the financial education aspect of citizenship education, which I know the Government are committed to improving. It is imperative that children learn the necessary financial skills for their future. To quote the money-saving expert Martin Lewis, “our children are sent out into a world of scams, dodgy deals and debt, without the tools to cope”. The useful Library briefing for this debate tells us that parents, carers and students are dissatisfied with “the present level of attention on this topic in the curriculum” and that there is “a strong appetite for more”. I draw the attention of the House to a recent report titled Jobs and Investment , published by the Jobs Foundation—a charity of which I am proud to be president, as declared in the register. This included the recommendation for the teaching of basic investment in schools. Teaching practical skills on rates of return, basic portfolio principles and retirement planning would set children up for life—a life of financial stability. We should also teach the power of compound interest, the importance of delayed gratification to future well-being and—dare I say it?—why capital gains have always been taxed at a lower rate than salaried income, whereas economic growth requires entrepreneurship and risk-taking to be encouraged. When the Minister responds to this debate, I would be grateful if the House could have more detail on the Government’s plans for financial education and whether the principles of investment might be included as part of them. I hope teenagers still learn in their English lessons from reading Mr Micawber’s words in David Copperfield : “Annual income twenty pounds, annual expenditure nineteen pounds nineteen and six, result happiness. Annual income twenty pounds, annual expenditure twenty pounds nought and six, result misery”. Micawber’s principle is correct and a neat encapsulation of why financial education is a must.

    View contribution permalink →

  14. Baroness Paul of Shepherd’s Bush (Lab)

    My Lords, my commitment to citizenship education was cemented during my time working for the National Citizen Service—NCS—which brought together young people from different backgrounds to help build confidence, forge lasting relationships, and develop a sense of shared purpose, primarily through volunteering in their local communities. NCS often changed young people’s lives and demonstrated to me that citizenship should be an activity and not a subject. We might bear that in mind when we think about future provision. Like the noble Lord, Lord Norton, I will focus on the potential of citizenship education to strengthen our national resilience. Members of this House are acutely aware of the challenges that our country faces and the resulting sense of uncertainty and threat. In that climate, resilience depends on whether people feel that they belong, trust one another and, significantly, trust the institutions that govern them. I worry that we have too little understanding of what many young people are exposed to online and of the malign influences seeking to undermine our values and institutions. Looking at France over the weekend, I refuse to believe that, among the chaos, there is not some co-ordinated agitation and provocation by those who wish to undermine our values. In the UK in 2025, counterterrorism police arrested 39 children and young people under 17 under terrorism laws. That means that one in six of all those arrested last year by counterterrorism police were children. Of those arrested, 92% were boys or young men. Those figures add to my sense that we are just not paying enough attention to who is targeting our young men and what dreadful ends they are working towards. To my mind, the boys deserve a bit more of our support, our attention and—dare I say it?—our love. Citizenship education cannot solve every problem but, done well, it can help equip young people with the skills to think critically, challenge misinformation, understand our collective values and engage constructively with people whose views differ from their own. Given the challenges that we face as a country and what lies ahead, this seems an important and worthwhile investment.

    View contribution permalink →

  15. Baroness Helic (Con)

    My Lords, I welcome this debate and congratulate my noble friend on his tireless work on citizenship education over the years and on his speech today. I serve on your Lordships’ National Resilience Committee and much of our work concerns how the country can withstand threats to its institutions and security. However, national resilience cannot be secured by the state alone; it also depends on the judgment and conduct of citizens. Last week, Sir Ken McCallum urged us to be “clear-eyed about the more contested world we now live in”. This is absolutely right, but being clear-eyed requires more than a recognition of the external threats; it requires the ability to distinguish between credible information and manipulation, and between disagreement and enmity. Citizenship education must therefore go beyond teaching how Parliament and elections work. Young people should understand why the rule of law matters, how to assess evidence and how to disagree without treating others as enemies. These are essential disciplines of democratic life and national resilience. I welcome the Government’s plans to extend compulsory citizenship education to primary schools in England from 2028 and to strengthen media literacy, but policy commitments alone are not enough. Provision remains uneven, and schools need the time, expertise and support to teach these subjects effectively. Will the Minister tell the House how the Department for Education and the Cabinet Office are working together to make civic resilience, including political literacy and the ability to recognise manipulation, an explicit part of national resilience planning? How will the Government assess whether these efforts are succeeding? When a crisis comes, the question will be not only whether the Government are ready but whether citizens can exercise judgment, resist manipulation and act with a sense of responsibility towards one another. We cannot assume that they will, but we must prepare them for that.

    View contribution permalink →

  16. Baroness Porter of Fulwood (Con)

    My Lords, when, in a recent poll, UK adults were asked to identify approximate annual government spending, only 16% selected the correct answer. In another poll, when people were asked about their understanding of how laws were made, 49% said they knew not very much about, knew nothing about or had never heard of the process. These figures raise an important question: how can we expect people to participate meaningfully in our democracy if they do not understand how it works? As citizenship education is expanded, particularly into primary schools, we should focus not simply on what children will be taught but on how they are taught it. The ability to think critically, weigh competing arguments and understand their responsibility to the communities in which they live should run throughout the entire curriculum. Those of us who have spent our lives in public policy know that politics is fundamentally about trade-offs, balancing competing priorities and considering unintended consequences. We should equip children with the skills to navigate these choices thoughtfully. How they apply what they know is just as important as what they know. Citizenship education must be more than a box-ticking exercise. It must be taught in such a way that it shapes how people think, how they engage with others, and how they act in their everyday lives. Will the Minister commit to ensuring that the new curriculum, when it is introduced, will have as its core objectives developing citizens who can think critically and understand their obligations to the wider community they live in? Can the Minister explain how the Government will ensure that these objectives translate into meaningful teaching and learning in the classroom?

    View contribution permalink →

  17. Lord Sikka (Lab)

    My Lords, to be effective, education must go beyond mere description of a sociopolitical system and include critique. Young people must be shown that democracy is preferable to plutocracy and that it must be protected from the power of corporations and the super-rich who buy the political system and hire legislators. The syllabus must encourage students to design community-based projects and see for themselves the effects of inequalities which deprive millions of nutritious food, good housing, health care, education and pensions. Such projects must consider why elected Governments are content with 1% of the population owning more wealth than 70% of the population combined; why the state forces the poorest 20% to pay a higher proportion of their income in direct and indirect taxes than the richest 20%; and why our Government are content with fiscal rules which send 300,000 people a year to premature death due to lack of timely hospital appointments. J. K. Galbraith’s book, The Culture of Contentment , ought to be essential reading, as it explains how the rising affluence of the few has shaped the politics of selfishness and hypocrisy and the hollowing out of economies and democracies. Education that does not reconstruct common sense and foment possibilities of emancipatory change is not really education.

    View contribution permalink →

  18. Baroness Barker (LD)

    My Lords, it was a pleasure to be part of the 2018 committee that looked at citizenship under the chairmanship of Lord Hodgson of Astley Abbotts. Although it has taken nearly 10 years, it is pleasing to see that the Government are finally getting around to responding positively to some of the suggestions we made then. I should also say that I spend a lot of time talking to schoolchildren in our education centre, and I very much welcome the move to extend citizenship education to primary schools, because the level of engagement, interest and desire for further knowledge from very young children is a constant surprise and delight to me. Going back to the committee, one of the biggest disappointments we had was Ofsted’s then lack of interest in citizenship teaching: it really was not interested in seeing that schools were being assessed on the level or quality of their teaching, and teachers were having to make up curricula in their own time and with their own resources. I am really glad that we are going to move away from that and towards proper standardisation. I am also pleased that we are going to stop mixing up citizenship with PSHE and a whole gaggle of other things. I was critical of the national citizen service from its inception, and I am glad that the Government were brave enough to close it down, because I think it was ill-targeted, expensive and, by and large, not worth the money that was being paid for it. I have a question for the Minister. At its height, it was paid £150 million a year, and that was a very big investment in a voluntary organisation. What has happened to the money? That is a sizeable slice of resources that could be given over to the development and implementation of new resources. By the way, if those resources are going to reach young people, they have to be online at some stage, because that will be the way young people get on to this agenda and find the information that they need.

    View contribution permalink →

  19. Baroness Cash (Con)

    My Lords, I thank the noble Lord, Lord Norton of Louth, for securing this debate. It was really terrible to see France burning this weekend and watch Limoges Hall fall, with at least two dead so far. It began with rioting schoolchildren. Here in the UK, we have recent polling showing that less than half of young Britons support our democratic system. It is a natural reflex to say, “teach citizenship”, but how and what we teach under this subject is of vital importance, because it has gone so badly wrong elsewhere. There is no time to discuss this tonight, but do look at what has happened in Illinois, Massachusetts and Quebec; it has been devastating. Children should be taught our history, our constitution, and equality before the law. Of course they should be taught how to participate; but the content being written by staff in the Department for Education, taught by teachers who are untrained, as we have heard tonight, and without any supervision or oversight as yet known to us by Ofsted or elsewhere, is simply not going to be adequate. We have heard from the noble Baroness, Lady Paul, that about one in six people arrested for counter-terrorism in the UK are children. The noble Baroness, Lady Casey, warned us 10 years ago that there were whole communities living parallel lives, and so very little has been done; so how are we going to ensure that those among us who see citizenship of this country as a very different thing, are trustworthy in their roles in schools to teach it in the same way? There is another place where the teaching of citizenship has failed. France has required moral and civic education in every school year since 2015. The generation that sat through those lessons set fire to their country at the weekend. The Secretary of State said recently in a speech that she wished to look again at the curriculum and I hope very much that she will look again at some of this.

    View contribution permalink →

  20. The Minister of State, Department for Education and Department for Work and Pensions (Baroness Smith of Malvern) (Lab)

    My Lords, as others have, I thank the noble Lord, Lord Norton, for securing this important debate on citizenship education. The noble Lord is a leading expert on Parliament and I know that citizenship is very close to his heart. As many noble Lords have said during this short debate, citizenship matters because it is important that young people understand our democratic institutions, their rights and responsibilities and the part they can play in shaping our country— a point emphasised by the noble Lady Baroness, Lady Porter. Citizenship education gives young people the knowledge and confidence to become active, informed and responsible members of society. Citizenship is, of course, already a national curriculum subject, having been introduced under the previous Labour Government when my noble friend Lord Blunkett was the Secretary of State and I was a lowly foot-soldier Minister in helping him to introduce that subject. The statutory content already covers democracy and government, the law and rights, financial education and participation in society, as well as critical thinking and mutual respect. However, that does not mean that we think the status quo is good enough. The Curriculum and Assessment Review from late 2025 pointed to an out-of-date curriculum, as have noble Lords this evening. My noble friend Lord Doyle rightly argued that we need to position citizenship within an understanding of what and how we teach across the whole of the curriculum. But the review did call for explicit content on the life skills that young people need: oracy, or as I like to think of it, speaking and listening skills; financial education, as identified by the noble Lord, Lord Elliott; and digital and media literacy. Here in particular I think my noble friend Lady Paul and the noble Baroness, Lady Helic, are absolutely right to emphasise that the ability of young people to recognise disinformation and think clearly are a key element of national resilience. The review was clear that students need to be clear-sighted, questioning and sceptical, and that needs to be a particularly important development, given some of the other issues that noble Lords have raised. The Curriculum and Assessment Review also argued for climate-change education. The review said that curriculum content should be more specific and that it should build progressively through each age group. It also said that citizenship should become statutory in primary schools. The Government agree that no child should miss out, although I cannot promise my noble friend Lord Sikka that Galbraith will be on the curriculum for primary school pupils. The Government intend to consult this year on a refreshed curriculum which will achieve those review aims. I hope that noble Lords will engage with that consultation, and I know that some are already working hard alongside the department to make sure that that curriculum is right. The noble Lord, Lord Wallace, suggested that there was scepticism reported in the Daily Telegraph about the place of citizenship. Of course, it was not just in the Telegraph : it was also from members of the party opposite, although I note a considerably more positive approach to citizenship from the noble Baroness, Lady Cash, than we heard from some of her colleagues from the other end of the building. During their conference, they argued that teaching children how to engage with our democracy is somehow politicising the classroom. They argued that they did not want primary pupils to have the statutory content that we believe that they should have. The noble Baroness, Lady Spielman, is not here for the debate this evening, but she has argued in particular for more focus on British identity, but what makes us British—and proud to be—is our democracy, our rights, the rule of law and our tolerance and belief in strong communities built on respect, rejecting the divisiveness of much political discourse today. The noble Lord, Lord Patten, and others, in pointing to events in France recently, identified some of the divisiveness that happens, not just there, that all of us have to respond to. Removing children’s ability to explore those things through citizenship education does not protect our children: it leaves them open to misinformation and the forces that want to divide, not unite, our country. By the way, I think the noble Lord, Lord Norton, was right to say that it was not solely the responsibility of schools and that adults and other public bodies, including the work of the Government through the Defending Democracy Taskforce, need to make sure that that approach is taken throughout people’s lives as well. As many have argued—including the right Reverend Prelate the Bishop of Peterborough, among others—while we know that many schools already teach the subject well in ways that are engaging and meaningful for their pupils, we need to think more carefully and take action on how we implement the change in curriculum. Even an improved statutory curriculum does not give schools everything they need. The consultation will ask people to tell us what is needed to enable effective implementation. This could include expert resources or subject-specific support, not least as citizenship includes sensitive and fast-changing topics. On that, I recognise that it is important for schools to be aware of their legal duties regarding impartiality and balanced treatment of political issues in the classroom. The existing non-statutory guidance on political impartiality provides clear and comprehensive guidance to help those working with and in schools better to understand these duties, how to strengthen their processes both in teaching about political issues and beyond the curriculum, and to give teachers the confidence to cover these topics effectively and appropriately. However, we will update this guidance if we have evidence that it is not sufficiently enabling this. Importantly, we will continue to work with the sector, including the Association for Citizenship Teaching, the Electoral Commission, wider government departments and the range of organisations deeply committed to citizenship, to consider the best possible package of support. We will welcome pilots to test and learn what works best. We will also provide adaptable free digital lesson resources through Oak National Academy and support will be available before first teaching begins. Here, I come to the point made by my noble friend Lord Blunkett, who pushes us to introduce this more quickly. He will know that the changes to the citizenship curriculum sit within the much wider change to the national curriculum that we are intending to bring in in 2028. That will enable citizenship to fit within what we hope will be increased opportunities for this type of learning as we streamline other elements of the curriculum as well. He is right that the important resources created by the Electoral Commission and, in fact, the existing curriculum already provide important opportunities for schools to prepare young people for a lower voting age. Like my noble friends Lady Gill and Lady Paul, I believe that activity and civic engagement are important, which is why they will be an important element of our enrichment framework. Having enough well-trained schoolteachers is fundamental to the citizenship reforms. That is why our curriculum plans represent a new citizenship requirement for primary schools. It is positive that last year we achieved 128% of the overall postgraduate training target in primary. We know that citizenship is taught by a variety of secondary school teachers, but there are more than 3,000 additional teachers in secondary and special schools now compared to the 2024 data. I appreciate that we would benefit from a greater number of specialist citizenship teachers. The department reviews bursaries annually to take account of things such as recruitment to date, forecast economic conditions and teacher need, and we will be announcing a new package this autumn. Several noble Lords, including the noble Baroness, Lady Barker, raised Ofsted’s inspection framework, which now has a focus on ensuring that schools provide a high-quality ambitious curriculum for all pupils. Ofsted evaluates citizenship largely within the personal development and well-being area, but its toolkit now explicitly recognises the importance of pupils developing detailed knowledge in citizenship. The strong standard for this area explicitly recognises the importance of pupils developing detailed knowledge in citizenship. In closing this debate, I thank the noble Lord, Lord Norton, and other speakers for their thoughtful and well-informed contributions. This is a pivotal moment for citizenship education. We must seize the opportunity to strengthen the subject’s content and status so that it inspires people’s curiosity about our changing society and equips them with the skills and knowledge to contribute to democracy as critical, informed and active citizens. The importance of the subject demands that we work closely with experts to ensure that it is taught to the highest standards and that teachers have ongoing support and confidence to bring the subject to life in a meaningful and lasting way. I welcome noble Lords’ insights into how we can do that well and look forward to further discussions in this House as that work continues.

    View contribution permalink →

  21. Sitting suspended.

    View contribution permalink →

Source: UK Parliament Hansard API. Debate ID: 5419458.