T

The Minister of State, Department for Education and Department for Work and Pensions (Baroness Smith of Malvern) (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 19 October 2026

Debate

Teaching of Citizenship

Contribution

My Lords, as others have, I thank the noble Lord, Lord Norton, for securing this important debate on citizenship education. The noble Lord is a leading expert on Parliament and I know that citizenship is very close to his heart. As many noble Lords have said during this short debate, citizenship matters because it is important that young people understand our democratic institutions, their rights and responsibilities and the part they can play in shaping our country— a point emphasised by the noble Lady Baroness, Lady Porter. Citizenship education gives young people the knowledge and confidence to become active, informed and responsible members of society. Citizenship is, of course, already a national curriculum subject, having been introduced under the previous Labour Government when my noble friend Lord Blunkett was the Secretary of State and I was a lowly foot-soldier Minister in helping him to introduce that subject. The statutory content already covers democracy and government, the law and rights, financial education and participation in society, as well as critical thinking and mutual respect. However, that does not mean that we think the status quo is good enough. The Curriculum and Assessment Review from late 2025 pointed to an out-of-date curriculum, as have noble Lords this evening. My noble friend Lord Doyle rightly argued that we need to position citizenship within an understanding of what and how we teach across the whole of the curriculum. But the review did call for explicit content on the life skills that young people need: oracy, or as I like to think of it, speaking and listening skills; financial education, as identified by the noble Lord, Lord Elliott; and digital and media literacy. Here in particular I think my noble friend Lady Paul and the noble Baroness, Lady Helic, are absolutely right to emphasise that the ability of young people to recognise disinformation and think clearly are a key element of national resilience. The review was clear that students need to be clear-sighted, questioning and sceptical, and that needs to be a particularly important development, given some of the other issues that noble Lords have raised. The Curriculum and Assessment Review also argued for climate-change education. The review said that curriculum content should be more specific and that it should build progressively through each age group. It also said that citizenship should become statutory in primary schools. The Government agree that no child should miss out, although I cannot promise my noble friend Lord Sikka that Galbraith will be on the curriculum for primary school pupils. The Government intend to consult this year on a refreshed curriculum which will achieve those review aims. I hope that noble Lords will engage with that consultation, and I know that some are already working hard alongside the department to make sure that that curriculum is right. The noble Lord, Lord Wallace, suggested that there was scepticism reported in the Daily Telegraph about the place of citizenship. Of course, it was not just in the Telegraph: it was also from members of the party opposite, although I note a considerably more positive approach to citizenship from the noble Baroness, Lady Cash, than we heard from some of her colleagues from the other end of the building. During their conference, they argued that teaching children how to engage with our democracy is somehow politicising the classroom. They argued that they did not want primary pupils to have the statutory content that we believe that they should have. The noble Baroness, Lady Spielman, is not here for the debate this evening, but she has argued in particular for more focus on British identity, but what makes us British—and proud to be—is our democracy, our rights, the rule of law and our tolerance and belief in strong communities built on respect, rejecting the divisiveness of much political discourse today. The noble Lord, Lord Patten, and others, in pointing to events in France recently, identified some of the divisiveness that happens, not just there, that all of us have to respond to. Removing children’s ability to explore those things through citizenship education does not protect our children: it leaves them open to misinformation and the forces that want to divide, not unite, our country. By the way, I think the noble Lord, Lord Norton, was right to say that it was not solely the responsibility of schools and that adults and other public bodies, including the work of the Government through the Defending Democracy Taskforce, need to make sure that that approach is taken throughout people’s lives as well. As many have argued—including the right Reverend Prelate the Bishop of Peterborough, among others—while we know that many schools already teach the subject well in ways that are engaging and meaningful for their pupils, we need to think more carefully and take action on how we implement the change in curriculum. Even an improved statutory curriculum does not give schools everything they need. The consultation will ask people to tell us what is needed to enable effective implementation. This could include expert resources or subject-specific support, not least as citizenship includes sensitive and fast-changing topics. On that, I recognise that it is important for schools to be aware of their legal duties regarding impartiality and balanced treatment of political issues in the classroom. The existing non-statutory guidance on political impartiality provides clear and comprehensive guidance to help those working with and in schools better to understand these duties, how to strengthen their processes both in teaching about political issues and beyond the curriculum, and to give teachers the confidence to cover these topics effectively and appropriately. However, we will update this guidance if we have evidence that it is not sufficiently enabling this. Importantly, we will continue to work with the sector, including the Association for Citizenship Teaching, the Electoral Commission, wider government departments and the range of organisations deeply committed to citizenship, to consider the best possible package of support. We will welcome pilots to test and learn what works best. We will also provide adaptable free digital lesson resources through Oak National Academy and support will be available before first teaching begins. Here, I come to the point made by my noble friend Lord Blunkett, who pushes us to introduce this more quickly. He will know that the changes to the citizenship curriculum sit within the much wider change to the national curriculum that we are intending to bring in in 2028. That will enable citizenship to fit within what we hope will be increased opportunities for this type of learning as we streamline other elements of the curriculum as well. He is right that the important resources created by the Electoral Commission and, in fact, the existing curriculum already provide important opportunities for schools to prepare young people for a lower voting age. Like my noble friends Lady Gill and Lady Paul, I believe that activity and civic engagement are important, which is why they will be an important element of our enrichment framework. Having enough well-trained schoolteachers is fundamental to the citizenship reforms. That is why our curriculum plans represent a new citizenship requirement for primary schools. It is positive that last year we achieved 128% of the overall postgraduate training target in primary. We know that citizenship is taught by a variety of secondary school teachers, but there are more than 3,000 additional teachers in secondary and special schools now compared to the 2024 data. I appreciate that we would benefit from a greater number of specialist citizenship teachers. The department reviews bursaries annually to take account of things such as recruitment to date, forecast economic conditions and teacher need, and we will be announcing a new package this autumn. Several noble Lords, including the noble Baroness, Lady Barker, raised Ofsted’s inspection framework, which now has a focus on ensuring that schools provide a high-quality ambitious curriculum for all pupils. Ofsted evaluates citizenship largely within the personal development and well-being area, but its toolkit now explicitly recognises the importance of pupils developing detailed knowledge in citizenship. The strong standard for this area explicitly recognises the importance of pupils developing detailed knowledge in citizenship. In closing this debate, I thank the noble Lord, Lord Norton, and other speakers for their thoughtful and well-informed contributions. This is a pivotal moment for citizenship education. We must seize the opportunity to strengthen the subject’s content and status so that it inspires people’s curiosity about our changing society and equips them with the skills and knowledge to contribute to democracy as critical, informed and active citizens. The importance of the subject demands that we work closely with experts to ensure that it is taught to the highest standards and that teachers have ongoing support and confidence to bring the subject to life in a meaningful and lasting way. I welcome noble Lords’ insights into how we can do that well and look forward to further discussions in this House as that work continues.

More from The Minister of State, Department for Education and Department for Work and Pensions (Baroness Smith of Malvern) (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.