L

Lord Marks of Henley-on-Thames (LD)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 19 October 2026

Debate

Public Office (Accountability) Bill

Contribution

It is the DPP at the moment but the Conservative amendment is trying to make it the Attorney-General. For my part, either consent is a serious safeguard. I do not believe it is likely that the Bill will ever be used in a case that is frivolous or a case that is simply trying to stifle free speech. I do, however, agree with the noble Lord, Lord Anderson, that the inclusion of “obfuscation” as an indication of serious impropriety is bordering on the absurd, not simply because it is not easy to avoid obfuscating the meaning of the word obfuscation but because it is not a very serious test. There is much of what the noble Lord, Lord Young, said that I cannot agree with. Nevertheless, he was speaking to Amendment 76. The drafting of the amendment is very specific and, I suggest, not offensive. The amendment could act as a serious protection of the right to free speech and journalism. It says: “An act is not seriously improper for the purposes of this section if it consists of … the expression of an opinion, or … a contribution made in good faith to debate on a matter of public interest, unless it involves the knowing assertion of a statement of fact which the person knows to be false”. For my part, I could not object to the inclusion of those words in this Bill, even though I disagreed with the general tenor of some of what the noble Lord said. As to the amendments from the noble Baroness, Lady Levitt, I was persuaded by her that a public interest defence would probably work better and more effectively, and be more readily understood, than the reasonable excuse defence, which is the catch-all in the present drafting of the Bill. I also believe that the burden of proof being put on the defence in cases such as this is not remotely unusual, and that that would be acceptable. I turn now to Amendment 75, in my name, to which the noble Baroness, Lady Brinton, has added her name. That would make it an offence for a person to encourage, directly or indirectly, or through a third party, a public officeholder to commit an offence of misleading the public. I will deal with this in some detail, because ancillary liability is often misunderstood and it generally follows a principal offence. It is necessary for ancillary liability for there to be a principal offence. This is not simple ancillary liability that would be added by this amendment. It is not ancillary liability for the encouragement or instigation of an offence. This offence would be committed even if there were no principal offence. The point of it is that an attempt to get a public officeholder to commit an offence of misleading the public under Clause 12 would be an offence even if the public officeholder resisted that attempt, so that there was no principal offence. This is important. The anomaly has been highlighted by Spotlight on Corruption, and I am grateful for its briefings. Normal ancillary liability of a secondary offender requires that a principal offender commit the offence, but this would be committed by anyone who attempted to get a public officeholder to mislead the public in a criminal way within subsection (1), for whatever purpose, even if the attempt were unsuccessful. In that sense, the ancillary would be suborning, or attempting to suborn, the public officeholder. I suggest that that should be an offence of misleading the public or of inciting the misleading of the public. The attempt to undermine the probity of a public officeholder by attempting to persuade him or her to commit an offence justifies criminal sanction. For that reason, because of the suborning nature of the offence, it is unsurprising that Spotlight on Corruption has shown that interest, as it is a form of corruption that should be subject to sanction.

More from Lord Marks of Henley-on-Thames (LD)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.