L

Lord Harper (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 19 October 2026

Debate

Railways Bill

Contribution

My Lords, the noble Baroness, Lady Jones, was seeking my support for her amendments earlier. Although we fundamentally disagree—and, I suspect, always will—about whether railway services should be provided by private companies, her amendments do the Committee a useful service. I want to reinforce and support what my noble friend Lord Grayling said. I genuinely do not understand two things in the Bill. Amendment 148 in the name of the noble Baroness concerns Clause 25 on the “Designation of services by Secretary of State”. I agree with my noble friend. I thought the whole point of setting up GBR was to get the Secretary of State out of the business of micromanaging services and deciding which services should be provided and which should not. My reading of the Bill and the Explanatory Notes is that this is about deciding which services GBR should provide, but I am not entirely certain. Once you start a Secretary of State doing that process, they will come under an enormous amount of political pressure to start deciding which services are run, rather than GBR doing it at arm’s length. If anything, that will just increase political control of these matters rather than reduce it. I thought that the whole point of this was to get the Secretary of State out of the detail of running the services rather than inserting them back into the picture. I would welcome the Minister explaining the thinking behind that power for the Secretary of State in Clause 25. The linked Clause 31 is about securing those services. I agree with the thrust of the amendments tabled by my noble friend. I happen to be very comfortable with services being provided by private companies under all sorts of models, but even if you think that it is important that the services are specified and tightly managed by a public sector provider, there is no reason why a private company cannot provide the services under a contract, as my noble friend said. We have talked about this in previous debates. The model in London, for example, where TfL sets out in detail the services that should be provided but can award the contracts to provide those services to private companies—it does not have to own all the trains, employ all the staff and run all the services—seems a perfectly sensible option that should be kept on the table rather than ruled out. It may be that GBR finds that there are no attractive companies that offer such services at a competitive price and it ends up awarding those contracts to operate those services to GBR-owned businesses, but ruling out giving it the option to do so seems rather perverse. As my noble friend said, ruling out the option of having a business which is at least partly owned by the employees or fully co-operative also seems overly prescriptive. You can take the Government’s view of not wanting to have the franchising model and you can stick to that, but not allowing yourself to use the model that is used very successfully in London and, as my noble friend said, will still be able to be used in places such as Liverpool seems rather unwise. I do not know why Ministers are not giving GBR the freedom to do that, where that is cost-effective for taxpayers.

More from Lord Harper (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.