L

Lord Harper (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 19 October 2026

Debate

Railways Bill

Contribution

My noble friend makes a very good point. If you are going to set up GBR and give it the job of doing the detailed day-to-day management, you want to give it the maximum amount of freedom to do so. You can rule out certain models, of course. If you do not want to have the franchising model, for example, you can say that that is not appropriate, but to say that you cannot use the private sector at all seems not to be sensible. That is also not consistent with other decisions that Ministers have taken. For example, they have no plans, as far as I understand it, to get rid of the roscos—the companies that own the rolling stock. Those are private businesses that make profits that will be paid for from funds from both passengers and taxpayers for the rolling stock. Ministers are not getting rid of those, because they cannot—they have no ability to put all that debt on to the public balance sheet, otherwise I suspect that they might be tempted, but they cannot—but ruling out people running services when, as my noble friend said, they might have the rolling stock and the ability to do so misses what the point of GBR is. The point of GBR is to run passenger services, to deliver good services at the lowest possible cost both to passengers directly through ticket prices but also to the taxpayer, and to invest in infrastructure so that other operators, open access operators and rail freight can also operate on the network. Again, the Government say that they support open access. Those are private companies. The Government say that they support rail freight. Those are private companies. Having this blanket ruling out of private companies operating services even under a concession model does not seem enormously sensible. I would welcome the Minister taking us through the thinking about how the Government arrived at that conclusion of ruling out even concessions, for example, whereas they are comfortable with them happening in other parts of the country, such as London.

More from Lord Harper (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.