L

Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 19 October 2026

Debate

Railways Bill

Contribution

Let me answer that in correspondence, because it deserves a careful response. It is worth clarifying what this designation issue is all about and what the designation of passenger services by the Secretary of State is for. It is designed to set the limits of the services that may be delivered by GBR: in other words, the services that the Secretary of State has not devolved to mayors. The designation of passenger services will not be a detailed document like a timetable. Instead, it will broadly set out the responsibilities for the running of services between relevant authorities. For example, exemption from the Secretary of State’s designation is the method by which passenger services were devolved to Transport for London. A draft Secretary of State designation was published on GOV.UK on 20 January, which helps to demonstrate what it would look like. If noble Lords would like to see a copy, I will send it to them after this debate. It is the public service contract that the Secretary of State will issue to GBR under Clause 31 that will require passenger services to be provided and through which those services will be funded. The contract will define the services in more detail for the purposes of describing what is being funded. That is a separate process to designation, which is really all about devolution. This is relevant to the point made by the noble Lord, Lord Lansley, the other day about how passenger services are funded, and I thank him for a productive conversation on that during the recess. There is nothing in these clauses that can be used as a backdoor for the privatisation of passenger services, nor does designation affect open access or freight services. I hope that this reassures the Committee that this is what it is, and no more, and that the noble Baroness can withdraw her amendment. On Amendments 149 to 151 from the noble Lord, Lord Grayling, I agree with the first part of his speech. I hope that he is already reassured by the explanation that I have just been through, but let me be clear: designation is not a detailed service specification, nor does it determine network access or capacity allocation. It does not interact at all with the question of whether freight or open access services can run on the network and it does not prevent any of those services from securing access, which is a separate process. Ministers’ designation powers do not override or conflict with GBR’s role in making access decisions and do not interact with, conflict with or undermine the safeguards for freight or other operators. Designation powers are simply a method to demonstrate where devolution to local authorities such as TfL has occurred and that is all. To move to the topic of public service contracts, as in Amendments 157 and 158, the Government are required to transparently publish relevant information about the contract, such as contract dates and the parameters of financial compensation, within two months of entering into it. Publishing pre-award information for a public service contract a year in advance would be unnecessary and impractical. In fact, this requirement was already disapplied in the public ownership Act of 2024, as it is no longer appropriate to the new model. In the old system, publishing such information in advance provided transparency, allowing prospective operators to challenge a proposed direct award and argue that a competition should be held instead. In the new system, such challenges would serve no purpose, as the Secretary of State is required only to award the service contract directly to a public operator. The focus for public service operators should be on delivering for passengers with efficient and clear reporting, not building in unnecessary delays. GBR’s business plan will ensure transparency, as it will describe its intentions on passenger services and this will be consulted on before it is funded and implemented. The public and industry will have ample time to review it, and the ORR will be able to provide comments on it, before it is signed off by the Secretary of State. As I explained during debate on the funding groups, the business plan is the method through which GBR activities are made transparent and it is held accountable for them. This ensures appropriate scrutiny can take place ahead of the contractual process. I turn to—

More from Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.