L

Lord Harper (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 19 October 2026

Debate

Railways Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I will make a couple of brief interventions. My noble friend Lord Evans’s Amendment 183 seeks to set up clear purposes for the Passengers’ Council. I am sure that the Minister will argue that, because the Passengers’ Council—its operating name is Transport Focus—has been set up under statute and then amended by a number of other statutes, it has clear purposes to advocate for passengers. But there may be an argument for bringing it up to date, setting it all out and balancing those needs, because the remit of Transport Focus—or the Passengers’ Council, depending on how we want to refer to it—is now quite broad; not only does it cover rail but it encompasses multimodal travel and roads. There is an argument for being clear about what we want it to do. That is the first point. The second point is that I am afraid I cannot support Amendment 184A, which would remove the Passengers’ Council’s responsibilities to take into account costs and make efficient use of them. The reason why I cannot support it is that the council is given two important statutory roles in this legislation; one is on setting standards that have to be complied with and the other concerns improvement plans. I do not think you can have a body setting standards that have to be complied with by rail passenger services and station service providers since, because of other legislation, it would basically mean a body that is entirely funded by the taxpayer and improvement plans that effectively have to be delivered by a body funded by the taxpayer. I do not think that the Passengers’ Council should be able to set such standards and improvement plans with no regard at all for how much those things will cost. If you do not need to have regard for cost you will specify a massively expensive gold-plated service, which might be lovely and we might all want to see, but the cost would be sufficient to drive people off the railways. These things are always a balance. You have to look at the services that you want and the services that may be required by passengers, but you also have to look at the cost of providing them, and there is a balance there to be struck. Also, once you specify the cost, you also have to look at whether it is the fare payer or the taxpayer who is paying it, or a balance of the two. It is important that the Passengers’ Council has to look at the cost of these things when exercising its statutory responsibilities. That does not mean that the council cannot say, “Here are the standards, the improvement plans, all the things we want to see. We recognise that they are going to have a significant cost to them”. There are some provisions in the legislation which require the Secretary of State to sign these things off, so it may be that there is a choice to be made and that there is a choice to improve the services at a significant cost, but the Passengers’ Council cannot just make these decisions with no insight or thinking into how much the costs are going to be. That does not make any sense at all; in fact, it will likely be self-defeating, because it will drive up the cost of delivering rail services, which will actually price people off them. My final point is on my noble friend Lord Moylan’s Amendment 333A, which says that the Secretary of State would not be able to appoint a person as chairman of the Passengers’ Council—not all the members but the chairman—without pre-appointment scrutiny by the Transport Committee of the House of Commons and that having been put forward to the Secretary of State. As with all these things, that does not mean that the Secretary of State cannot go ahead and make an appointment, even if the House of Commons Transport Committee says it is not a very good idea. It is always open to the Government not to take any notice of the committee and bear the political consequences, but the amendment says that it cannot make the appointment without that process having taken place. Given the importance of the role—given that, under this legislation, it will have some extra powers to make some significant recommendations—having pre-appointment scrutiny of the person who will lead the council seems a very sensible idea. The amendment would not tie the Secretary of State’s hands excessively. It does not say that they cannot appoint their preferred candidate, even if the House of Commons disagrees. It just says that there has to be a process. As a final point, something we found from the pre-appointment scrutiny processes that have already taken place, sometimes with Ministers following the recommendations and sometimes not, is that the transparency, the scrutiny and the ability for questioning to take place about the candidate’s priorities—what it is they want to do with the job—is an unalloyed good thing. I do not see why Ministers would not be able either to support this amendment or, if they think there is something defective in my noble friend Lord Moylan’s drafting, to bring back one of their own. This would be an important improvement to scrutiny in the operation of the Passengers’ Council and I certainly give it my support.

More from Lord Harper (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.