L

Lord Harper (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 19 October 2026

Debate

Railways Bill

Contribution

I take the noble Baroness’s point, but my point was not about removing the ability of staff to sell tickets; it was to enable them to be more flexibly deployed. For example, one of the things that staff would have been able to do is exactly that transaction—but they would not have had to sit in a specific place, unable to interact with passengers. I absolutely accept the noble Baroness’s point that some people still either prefer to—that is their absolute right—or have to, in the cases that she set out, purchase a physical ticket, and we should make sure that they are able to do so. But, in many stations, you literally have staff who sit there for an entire shift, interacting with almost nobody. Frankly, that is not a very good job either—it is not a satisfying job—and they could be better deployed. The noble Baroness’s amendment sets out how you could better deploy staff to serve disabled passengers in particular, and it is therefore worthy of support. Amendment 204 in the names of my noble friend Lord Holmes and the noble Baroness, Lady Brinton, is about accessibility improvement notices. I am not sure whether that is the correct solution, but I support the thrust of the amendment. I have sat in a number of debates, both on this Bill and on other occasions, where I have completely seen the frustration that lots of things are set out as objectives but they do not happen in practice. The real challenge, not just for passengers but for Ministers and operators, is: how do you make sure that the things that are required and that are the responsibilities of these operators are actually delivered in practice? Lots of these things are delivered in theory, but as both of my noble friends— I think I can call the noble Baroness, Lady Brinton, one of my noble friends on this occasion—set out, they do not always happen in practice. Getting them fixed should not depend on the noble Baroness, Lady Grey-Thompson, having the telephone number of the person in charge of an operator; that is a very effective solution, but it should not be the way that we make sure these services are delivered. So where the passengers’ council finds that there is a systematic failure—not just a failure in a specific circumstance but a systematic failure, where there are not the staffing, policies or processes to deliver this—being able to direct that something happens as a result is valuable. The excellent Amendment 330JA from the noble Baroness, Lady Jones of Moulsecoomb, is one of those relatively rare occasions where I cannot fail to agree with her, since it broadly replicates what was in the draft rail reform Bill, which I was responsible for. It does not go as far as our draft Bill, but it would do half of it. It would do one very important thing: as she said, it would make the Disabled Persons Transport Advisory Committee not just a statutory adviser to the Secretary of State. I say in passing that I found its work extremely helpful, both its direct advice and the work that it and its chair did in the department in ensuring that parts of the department were listening properly to the experience of disabled people and reflecting that in the policy and operations of the department. The noble Baroness’s amendment would make the Disabled Persons Transport Advisory Committee an advisor to GBR as well as the Secretary of State. I thought that was clearly the right thing to do, and it was in the draft legislation for which I was responsible. I think it is the right decision; given that it was in that draft legislation, I am interested to know why someone has, effectively, decided to take it out, thinking it was not helpful. I remind Ministers that having the committee provide advice to GBR would be helpful not only to GBR in ensuring it delivers a better service for disabled people but to Ministers to stop them from, in effect, being a conduit. What happens now is that advice will be provided by the transport advisory committee to Ministers, who will then have to issue directions to GBR. It would be much better if the transport advisory committee advised GBR directly. The second thing, which is not in the amendment from the noble Baroness, Lady Jones, is that the draft Bill that I was responsible for contained collaborative enforcement. It specifically gave the Disabled Persons Transport Advisory Committee the ability to work alongside the passenger watchdog to safeguard the rights and interests of disabled rail passengers and directly influence GBR’s licensing agreement and accessibility standards. It would perhaps have been an alternative mechanism to the amendment put forward by my noble friend Lord Holmes and the noble Baroness, Lady Brinton, or perhaps an adjunct to it. It would have meant that the Disabled Persons Transport Advisory Committee could have taken evidence and listened to some first-hand testimony from disabled passengers who had poor experiences, and they would have had a direct role in working with the passenger watchdog—Transport Focus—on GBR’s licensing conditions. That would have been very helpful. Again, I would like to hear why Ministers decided to take that aspect of the draft legislation out as well. I look forward to hearing the Minister’s reply.

More from Lord Harper (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.