Contribution
My Lords, I will speak to Amendments 214, 215 and 216 in my name, which are signed by the noble Baroness, Lady Brinton—we will come to them. It is a pleasure to follow the noble Baroness, who set out all the issues in this group.
As I said in the previous group, planning should be experiential, not operational. It is about a passenger journey right from the point that she or he leaves their home or even before that point, when she or he decides to try to purchase a ticket online. If you plan operationally, it is never going to work for the passenger, and it will certainly never work for the disabled passenger.
It is worth reminding the Committee, at this stage of the Bill, what we are talking about when we talk about accessibility. Accessibility is not for disabled people; it is for all people. Inclusive by design is not for disabled people; it is for all people. One would imagine that this is self-evident, but seemingly it needs restating. If you make a change purportedly for disabled people, everybody benefits: those with suitcases, those with toddlers in pushchairs, older people and younger people—all people. Accessibility is for all people, and inclusive by design is for all people. The passenger experience needs to be planned and thought through in a co-produced, co-creative way first and only then can you move into the operational.
What is extraordinary in some of the testimony from the noble Baroness, Lady Brinton, is that even when a railway plans operationally it is not even planning operationally. If it were, the issues we have heard about, not least around lift provision, would not happen—and yet they do, blighting lives. To re-rehearse the statistics I set out on the previous group in terms of employment, only 41% of disabled people of working age are in employment, set against 83% of the broader population. That is hardly surprising if you take the examples that the noble Baroness, Lady Brinton, set out. Going through all that—exhausted before you have even got to work and before you have even begun the first minute of your working day—is it any wonder that 41% of disabled people and 27% of those who are blind and partially sighted are in employment?
My Amendments 214 through 216 do some of that experiential thinking. I must, as others in previous groups have done, commend the Minister, the noble Lord, Lord Hendy, for all the work that he has done while being in post as Minister and, before that, all the work he did as commissioner across London. He showed what is possible and never took no for an answer, never accepted the status quo and never accepted that, just because you cannot make 100% of something accessible, you should not make part of it accessible. By doing that, you have made an accessible service.
This goes to the heart of Amendment 214 around level boarding. He, I and others were told that it was impossible to make the London Underground accessible for wheelchair users. How is that doable? He and others worked on the whole concept of platform humps. It did not need to be every door of every train at every station. It was a practical, effective, accessible and inclusive solution. The trains could pull up and the disabled passenger would know from information from the station they were coming from that they would arrive where the platform hump was. Not only could they access and egress the train; they could do it independently and with dignity like any other passenger. Why was that possible? It was because we had the most immovable of deadlines. Nobody would have said, “What a great accessible Olympic and Paralympic Games I had in 2013”. Having a target, having that vision and putting it into a mission is the way to get things to happen. That is why I suggest the end of 2036 for level boarding. What a phenomenal celebration that would be. It is achievable if the same logic and approach is taken as in that London 2012 planning—not every door of every station of every platform, but every station in a way that would be accessible for disabled passengers.
It is achievable. London 2012 showed what could be done. We had fewer than seven years to achieve that; this amendment suggests over 10 years. No matter how good the celebrations were in 2012—sport is fantastic—what a celebration it would be to have a level, accessible rail network across the whole country, enabling, empowering and creating possibilities not for disabled people but for all people.
My amendment on the accessibility of the rolling stock follows a similar logic. As the noble Baroness, Lady Grey-Thompson, rightly highlighted last week, why should it be that, if you are a wheelchair user and you are fortunate enough to be able to get on the train, you cannot sit with your friends, family or colleagues, with access to the buffet and toilet facilities? It is extraordinary that this has to be asked for in 2026. It is basic and fundamental, yet disabled people still cannot rely on this on the rail network.
My final amendment goes to the question of staffing, which the noble Baroness, Lady Brinton, has already touched on. This is about enabling, empowering, training and supporting all the fabulous staff across our rail network so that they have the comfort and confidence to act, to provide support and assistance to disabled people, and to be there on the station in operating hours. Again, this is not about making a change for disabled people; it is making a change for all people. It goes to the heart of demonstrating how this change would of course benefit disabled people but would also have benefits in terms of the safety of all passengers on a station by dint of having staff—humans—present at all times during the operating hours of that station. Again, this is basic stuff, but it is not currently the case.
Finally, if we do not plan experientially and continue to so chronically insufficiently plan operationally, we will get results such as the following, which has been the case, and I will ask the Minister whether it is still the case. We had stations on the network that were described as fully accessible and, indeed, they were fully accessible. The wheelchair user could enter the station, take the lift down to the platform and position themself by the train, with no hope whatever of being able to get on that train because there was no accessibility at that point. Can the Minister confirm that there is no station at all on the network that describes itself as accessible but where it is not actually possible, throughout all the hours of the operation of that station, for disabled passengers and indeed all passengers to board, access and egress the train service itself? I look forward to the Minister’s response.