Contribution
I also thank the Minister and his officials for the meeting that we had last week—or the week before; I lose track of time with this Bill—and for the conversation in which we established that we would not meet about this specific group but we perhaps will between the end of Committee and the start of Report. I am very grateful to him for that suggestion; it is helpful given how many amendments there are here.
If noble Lords will allow me, I will use the noble Baroness’s excellent Amendment 198A, which summarises most of the issues that she, the noble Lord, Lord Holmes, and I would like the Government to consider through amendments in this group. In the previous group, I raised the issue of an effective and properly staffed service for people with mobility reductions—not all of whom are disabled; I say that because we have to recognise that, with our changing demographics, there will be elderly people who would not describe themselves as disabled. Amendment 198A specifies nine areas that need addressing, and I will use the noble Baroness’s notes to guide us through them and the other amendments in this group.
The first areas are easy-to-access stations, platforms and trains, and I start with level boarding. Tyne and Wear Metro, Greater Anglia and Merseyrail have started to move towards level boarding, which is encouraging. I have used level boarding and exiting at St Pancras on Greater Anglia and at Heathrow on the Heathrow Express. It is transformative for a wheelchair user, as it makes you completely independent—but not if it works for only part of your journey. In the previous group, the noble Lord, Lord Evans of Guisborough, talked about good lines and bad lines; the difficulty is that, when one bit of your journey goes, it does not matter whether the line is good or bad, your day becomes a bad day. A disabled passenger needs only one element of the journey to go wrong to lose their independence and, frankly, often their confidence—that is also me speaking personally.
We know that, over the past decade, a number of train companies have bought new rolling stock that will require ramps on those lines for many years to come. I think it was the noble Baroness, Lady Grey-Thompson, who said, about four or five years ago, that, when she and I first came into the House almost within weeks of each other in 2011, the target for level boarding was in the late 2020s or possibly the early 2030s. However, much of this decade’s new rolling stock is not suitable for level boarding, and it will have a working lifespan of probably about 30 to 40 years based on the previous ones. Therefore, our grandchildren will be approaching old age before there is universal level boarding across the UK. That is ridiculous.
I hope that one of the aspirations of GBR is that we move away from the idea of each area having completely different rolling stock, which means level boarding is impossible. Instead, level boarding should be a goal for all trains, which in turn would reduce the need for some staffing. It would also reduce lawsuits when passengers end up stranded with no help. Even better, a smooth level service would encourage more disabled people to use the trains even more regularly. Frankly, given what the noble Lord, Lord Holmes, said in the previous group, it will open opportunities for them to have regular employment too. Many do not do that now because of the risks of problematic journeys, so more passengers will bring good economic benefits to GBR, too.
Shockingly, new stations are still being opened at the moment when they are not accessible because they are not step-free. The data is depressing: up to 1,001 stations—39%—are not listed as fully step-free. This is not acceptable, and it needs to change fast. Looking at the type of station, as you would expect, category A—national hubs—is 100% step-free. Category B—regional interchanges—is 97% step-free and category C is 80% step-free. However, categories D, E and F are all between 54% and 57%. Interestingly, small unstaffed category F stations are 60% step-free, which is an increase on the previous groupings. There are also variations by region. What are the Government’s plans to improve the number of step-free stations and regularise issues over regions?
Lifts at stations are a thorny issue. Even if a station has lifts, reliability has plummeted in the past decade, as I know the Minister is well aware because he has heard this from a number of us on a regular basis. The key data is that 57% of lift faults are due to wear and tear. When spare parts are needed, the lifts can be out of order for months on end because the lift suppliers are not based in the UK. St Pancras is a regular case in point—but I get ahead of myself.
GBR must ensure that there is a proper assessment of lift life and build lift repairs and replacements into regular maintenance, rather than waiting for things to go wrong. That really does not happen consistently at the moment. Far too many lifts are failing repeatedly and then are out of service as spare parts have to be made abroad. The Thameslink lifts at St Pancras have been a nightmare for years. The consequence of them not working is as follows. You have to stay on the train and get off at Farringdon, assuming that the lifts there work. Assistance staff will help you leave the rail station. You cross the road, go into the Farringdon Underground station, get a lift down to the platform and wait for assistants to join you to get you on the Tube, which takes you back to St Pancras. I am not alone in having nearly missed a connecting train because of this nonsense. We can all tolerate the occasional problem, but this is so frequent that the service is now unreliable and I try to avoid it.
In my hometown of Watford, all the lifts had to be replaced recently—within the past five years. They did them in pairs, and each took the best part of a year, with absolute chaos. Last year, the new two year-old lift on the island platform had a major part fail. For three months, that lift was out, so, instead of commuting home late at night after leaving your Lordships’ House on a 20-minute journey from Euston, I faced either an Overground that took well over 55 minutes—but at that hour of the night there were not many of them—or trains that had to be diverted to the down line, causing chaos to the scheduled services. Believe me, people did not shy away from voicing their irritation to fellow passengers. They were not cross with me; they were cross with the network.
The UK rail network has 1,403 lifts. That should give us some purchasing power in the matter of lifts and lift spares. I just do not understand why spare parts are not planned for and kept in the UK. Can the Minister provide reassurance that the purchase and maintenance of lifts will be improved? Again, this is not just for people in wheelchairs; it is for many passengers, especially those with large cases.
The space in trains for wheelchairs and other mobility aids has not caught up with current practice. Specifications for the future should include enough space for both larger wheelchairs and wheelchair scooters—you can no longer just say “scooters”, which means something different—as many people now use them. With an ageing demographic using wheelchair scooters by preference and expecting to travel, this will only increase and get worse. So changing the reference-size wheelchair is important when new rolling stock is designed and ordered. More irritatingly, all the rolling stock has different sizes of wheelchair space, some with very limited turning or manoeuvring space.
Secondly, please will train designers ensure that there are places for other passengers to store their damned suitcases? Even with the new rolling stock on LNER, it is a problem. If there are staff handy, they are really good at shouting down the carriage, but if there are not, the person in the wheelchair has to shout for themselves, and sometimes people deliberately do not answer and we cannot get further down to start to find out where people might be.