L

Lord Harper (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 19 October 2026

Debate

Railways Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I just want to ask the Minister some questions about Amendment 311, which is obviously linked to the Government’s announcements today. The Minister will know that there has been a considerable amount of cross-party support for the announcements regarding both buses and trains. My party last year and, in the spirit of sharing the benefit, the Liberal Democrats have both campaigned for these measures, so in principle I support them. I am a rail user and if I ever use my devices for sound, I always use my headphones, which I think is appropriate. Just last week, I was using the train, and I politely asked somebody who was scrolling through her phone and giving snippets of every little video she found, if she could possibly not do that. That polite injunction did the trick, but it does not always and some of the worst offenders are the sort of people you probably would not want to speak to directly for fear of what might happen. Given that there have been laws, regulations or rules in place for a considerable time that say people should not play music or other noise loudly, this is primarily a question of culture or enforcement. If you raise the profile of this issue and have more signage and more announcements, how does that shift the culture? I do not want too many announcements because, frankly, lots of announcements are just as bad as people playing devices. Announcements about your journey are very useful but lots of other stuff is not really very helpful at all and is annoying. Secondly, to what extent is the annoyance caused by a relatively small number of hardcore offenders? I do not know the answer to those questions and do not know whether there is any good data on this. How do you enforce it? It is not always reasonable for train managers to do this. They can have a go but, if somebody refuses to take any notice or behaves aggressively or violently towards them, that is a bit of a problem. Given the discussion last week about the limited resources of the British Transport Police, they may have to do it in extremis, but I am not sure I want them to be the first port of call to enforce noise regulations. We had the conversation last week about the very important job they do, for example, combating violence against women and girls and, in my book, that would be higher up the list of things for BTP to be focusing on than noise, important though that is. I suppose my question is: on both buses and trains—and obviously we will keep it train-focused here— how do the Government see this working in practice? I think pretty much everybody would agree with the announcement; I do not think anybody will disagree with it. I think I saw some polling that said 100% of people agreed with it. If you talk about things that we think are desirable but do not have any specific, concrete plans to make them happen, all you do is increase cynicism and make people even unhappier than they were in the first place. This is primarily an enforcement question. In response to Amendment 311, and no doubt the Government will look forward to the opportunity to comment on their announcements today, I want to hear some very specific practical steps that Ministers are going to take on trains to improve the passenger experience as far as unwanted noise is concerned. I think specifics will be very helpful indeed.

More from Lord Harper (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.