L

Lord Stevens of Birmingham (CB)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 20 October 2026

Debate

Armed Forces Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I too support Amendment 2 in this group from the noble Lord, Lord Harlech, which proposes a modest enhancement of the support that the NHS offers reservists. In looking at the redraft that the noble Lord has produced since Committee, I applied three short tests: is it workable, would it be beneficial and is it fair? I think the answer to all three is yes. It is workable because, as he says, essentially there are no additional costs associated with this. The people who would be eligible have already been deemed to have a clinical need for some sort of procedure or support from the NHS; it is not expanding eligibility above and beyond what is already there. In fact, I think we have an easier mechanism on offer that would mean individuals are not repeatedly being asked the same question. If we look at the debate that is happening on the Health Bill in parallel, we see that we are set to have a single patient record, which in fact will answer a lot of the administrative complexity that otherwise would have arisen were this amendment implemented, absent what the Health Bill is likely to bring about. Therefore, it is certainly workable. Is it likely to be beneficial? It is a very modest measure —perhaps too modest. It places additional duties on local hospitals and community services. It does not place duties on general dentistry, for example. It may well be, frankly, that more help would be of benefit. However, it is certainly likely, in its own modest way, to make a difference, for the reasons that were articulated in Committee. The third question is: is it fair? Is it displacing large numbers of other people from their place in the waiting list? Doing a bit of back-of-the-envelope maths on that, I think the answer is: clearly not. We have 6.25 million unique individuals waiting in England for some form of routine care. Even if every reservist in the country were on the waiting list, we would be talking about under 2% of the slots. The differential impact on everybody else is minimal. In fact, this is not a new principle. Those who are students of the National Health Service will know that between 1953 and at least 1997, the principle was well established that certain classes of veterans from the First and Second World Wars received priority treatment for certain conditions, and even today, rightly, merchant seafarers receive fast-track access for routine care under the Dreadnought Medical Service on offer at St Thomas’ Hospital so they can get back to sea as fast as possible. This principle is well understood and has been in place for many decades across the health service; we are just looking to apply it in this particular case. My conclusion is that, yes, this is workable, beneficial and fair. We will be having a debate in the next 12 to 18 months on the defence readiness and national resilience Bill, and we will need to have a lot more of this kind of national conversation. If we cannot even get this modest measure over the line, I hesitate to think about what the bigger debate will yield.

More from Lord Stevens of Birmingham (CB)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.