Contribution
My Lords, as my noble friend Lord Coaker set out in Committee, and as he explained in some detail previously, the Government do not consider it appropriate to tie single living accommodation to the decent homes standard. I will address as many of the points on SLA as I can.
The review on single living accommodation, to which the noble Earl, Lord Minto, referred, is ongoing. It was launched in 2026. It is examining and developing recommendations on standards, including how they were modelled and monitored. I am told it is due to be published very shortly, and I look forward to discussing and debating the outcomes of that review as soon as it comes out.
I say to the noble Baroness, Lady Smith of Newnham, that we do not consider the decent homes standard to be the appropriate mechanism for assessing single living accommodation due to the nature of having shared facilities, as she alluded to in discussing student accommodation. Clearly, we all have varied experience of student accommodation. I certainly would want it to be of a higher standard than some of mine, but that was some time ago.
I also take the point made by the noble and gallant Lord, Lord Craig, about the state of service single living accommodation and the importance of improving it. I absolutely agree; indeed, I have stayed in single living accommodation over the last few years myself and I know that it needs improvement. I have also taught non-commissioned officers and know the problems that they have with their accommodation at RAF Halton, some of which are still to be resolved.
The noble Earl, Lord Minto, asked me about the spending and the results of the defence investment plan. We are going to be deferring £950 million this Parliament. Under current planning assumptions, approximately 10,100 single living accommodation bed spaces will have been impacted by the DIP. Despite that deferral, though, there is substantial investment in SLA still programmed, including more than £1.4 billion of direct investment in new-build SLA planned before 2030—so, in the first four years of the defence investment plan.
Government Amendments 4 and 5 are clarifying amendments to ensure that the legislation is clear that the defence housing service will benefit from Crown immunity for the transaction of acquiring property as well as when it holds the property. That is the current situation with the Ministry of Defence, and the amendment seeks to maintain the status quo in the management of defence property.
The Government welcome the intent behind Amendments 6 and 7 and confirm that we entirely share the objective. The Government are fully committed to ensuring that the voice of service families is at the heart of the new organisation. I will set out briefly how that objective will be achieved.
First, the independent board which will hold the DHS to account will include a dedicated non-executive member with service family insight. By that, I mean someone with in-depth experience of service family accommodation. The recruitment for that crucial board member has already been launched, reflecting the priority the Government place on this position. A representative from the Army Families Federation will be involved in the selection of this candidate.
Secondly, a governance framework has already been set up, in advance of the DHS being formally established, which will ensure that service family voices are heard in the day-to-day running of the organisation. A new customer committee has already been established, featuring representatives from the Armed Forces families federations. In addition, new regional customer experience committees will be established, recognising that the views of personnel and their families will differ across different nations and regions.
Thirdly, one of the benefits of the DHS being set up as a public-purpose, public sector organisation within the MoD family is that it will include military personnel on its staff. I asked for clarification on that; by staff, I mean the broader staff in the defence housing service, not the members of the board. This includes a new DHS chief of staff military position, which has already been filled. As I alluded to just now, that post will sit alongside a number of other military personnel working within the DHS, ensuring that the voices of service personnel are at the heart of the organisation.
Fourthly, the Government are determined that the DHS empowers service personnel and their families to hold it to account directly. In this spirit, the Secretary of State recently launched an initiative to pilot the sign-off of repairs by families, alongside a red tape challenge for Armed Forces families to propose rules and processes that can be simplified or removed entirely. I can give an example that was recently introduced, as some may be aware: the default right to have a pet in a service family home. That is just an obvious thing to make the default position. We in the MoD look forward to working with forces families to find out what other areas we could easily change that will make life so much better for them on a day-to-day basis and less burdensome and bureaucratic. I could talk on the Haythornthwaite review all day, but I am not going to get started on that right now.
Parliamentarians as well as Ministers will be able to hold the DHS to account via its reporting to Parliament, not just on the outcomes it achieves but on its responsiveness to the needs of service personnel and their families. Satisfaction with military homes has increased by 12% over the past year—2025-26—with 75% of families now saying they are satisfied, higher than the 71.3% national average for civilian landlords. That is a quite a considerable achievement, considering the challenge that has been faced by the Ministry of Defence and this Government with the state of accommodation.
I hope I have provided the necessary assurance for the noble Baroness, Lady Smith, and that she can withdraw her amendment.