T

The Earl of Minto (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 20 October 2026

Debate

Armed Forces Bill

Contribution

My Lords, in Committee my noble friend Lady Goldie and I tabled amendments on the new defence housing service and we opposed Clause 3 standing part of the Bill. As my noble friend said then, I appreciate that the establishment of the DHS as a non-departmental public body is a settled position of the Government as a result of their defence housing strategy. We did not sense sufficient support from around your Lordships’ House for removing that clause; for that reason, we have not re-tabled such an amendment on Report. Although I remain critical of the form in which this new body is to be constituted, if it is to exist we must make every effort to ensure that it works for those whom it is intended to serve—our valued Armed Forces personnel. That is why we have tabled Amendments 6 and 7. These amendments are a simplified version of that which we tabled in Committee and would require the board of the defence housing service to have three representatives of the Armed Forces with recent experience of living in service family accommodation. The intent here is to ensure that truth is spoken to power, giving service personnel direct involvement in the operations of the new body and a realisation that the remaining members of the board have lived experience among their number. I am extremely grateful that the Minister took the time, alongside his officials, for a briefing before the Recess. I was reassured at the level of service engagement in the defence housing strategy and the fact that the Government envisage ongoing involvement in this new service. As such, I will not seek to divide the House on these amendments. I offer my support to Amendment 3 from the noble Baroness, Lady Smith of Newnham. At that same briefing I previously mentioned, I noted that the Government intend to run a second review to look at single living accommodation and produce yet another strategy. I have to confess to being dubious about this proposal. Would it not have made much more sense for the previous strategy to address all aspects of military housing, as opposed to focusing only on family accommodation and leaving those in single living accommodation potentially in the lurch? While we are discussing such a key issue as defence housing, I must say that it is of grave concern to these Benches, and I am sure others, that the Government have reduced the budget for repairs to military housing in this Parliament, particularly given the absolute assurances made by Ministers during the Public Bill Committee in the other place. On 18 March, then Minister Al Carns said to the Select Committee on the Bill that “£9 billion has been ringfenced”. On 26 March, he further clarified that the “£9 billion will be allocated to the Defence Housing Service”.—[Official Report, Commons, Armed Forces Bill Committee, 26/3/26; col. 61.] On 25 June, the Minister for Defence Readiness and Industry, Luke Pollard, stated in a Written Answer that £4 billion of that money will be spent in this Parliament and £5 billion will be spent in the next Parliament. However, when the defence investment plan was published a mere five days later, it allocated only £2.7 billion for upgrades to service family accommodation over the entire period from 2026-30. Even this commitment has not been endorsed. In a letter to the chair of the Public Accounts Committee in September, the department confirmed that £800 million of the investment into the service family accommodation had been deferred to the next Parliament. Perhaps more worryingly, that letter also confirmed a further £950 million deferral of investment into single living accommodation. Could the Minister please confirm with a simple yes or no whether the department stands by those last two stated figures? Will there be a £950 million deferral of investment into single living accommodation? This is highly regrettable and undermines the delivery of the Government’s previous commitment. Could the Minister confirm whether the Government believe that this new funding profile is sufficient to deliver the full planned upgrade? Rather neatly, the combined value of these two deferred investments is precisely equivalent to the amount of shortfall over which the then Secretary of State for Defence, and current Chancellor, resigned. How will the Ministry of Defence find this money from its already overstretched resources when the Treasury is still refusing to commit to a date when defence spending will increase to 3% of gross domestic product?

More from The Earl of Minto (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.