T

The Earl of Minto (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 20 October 2026

Debate

Armed Forces Bill

Contribution

My Lords, the House will not be surprised that my noble friend Lady Goldie and I have re-tabled our amendments from Committee to remove Clause 39 and Schedule 6 from the Bill. As a short reminder, these provisions abolish the reserve forces and cadets associations as currently constituted and replace them with a single non-departmental public body—a quango—with a far greater degree of control exercised directly by the Ministry of Defence. I was buoyed by the widespread support from around the House that this amendment received in Committee, in particular from the noble and gallant Lords, Lord Craig of Radley and Lord Stirrup; the noble Lords, Lord Dannatt, Lord Moore of Etchingham and Lord Faulks; and my noble friends Lord Swire, Lord Howe, Lady Fraser of Craigmaddie, and, of course, Lord De Mauley. May I also say to the noble Baroness, Lady Smith of Newnham, that her support and that of her party are extremely welcome? I even detected a hint of scepticism about the Government’s proposal from their own Benches, and I thank the noble Viscount, Lord Stansgate, for his intervention. This support from diverse corners was indeed indicative of both how strongly noble Lords felt about the value of reserves and cadet organisations and their commitment to the value of a of level of self-determination. It is clear from the strength of feeling in the House that the Government have got this wrong. I am in no doubt that the Minister has only good intentions, but I am afraid that he is pursuing, whether at his own behest or that of the Civil Service, a course of action which will change the RFCAs for the worse and risks causing lasting damage to a system that works so well. The source of my ire is the Government’s insistence that they must seize control over the associations for the sake of accountability. I am fully aware that the Sullivan review identified weaknesses in the governance of the RFCAs, but an enormous amount of work has already been done to rectify those problems; yet the Government still intend to pursue reorganisation. It is as if the MoD is searching for a problem to justify its desire to exercise ultimate control over the associations. The Government speak of accountability, but accountability to whom? Is it the accountability of the membership of the associations that the Government are concerned about? Is it for those volunteers, cadet leaders, reservists and staff who make the RFCAs the enormous success that they are—or is it to further the MoD’s interests that the Government seek these reforms? If anyone thinks that creating yet another quango is going to improve accountability, either to those who really matter—the reserves, the cadets and the membership —or, indeed, to the Government themselves, I fear they may have spent the last few decades with their head buried fairly deep in the sand. If it is financial probity and governance that the Government are concerned about, they have little to fear from retaining the current arrangements. For example—this is quite a good example—the Yorkshire and Humberside association managed to negotiate the purchase of a new location for York Officer Training Corps for £2.85 million, down from the quoted price of £3 million. By contrast, the anticipated cost for the Ministry of Defence’s plan for the relocation was £10 million. Because of the local connections and autonomy of the current arrangements, the Yorkshire and Humberside RFCA was able to save the public purse £7 million. The Government say they are worried about financial responsibility and accountability, but, as this simple example demonstrates, the RFCAs are clearly more responsible and accountable than the Ministry of Defence could be. I know if I was still in the commercial sector who I would want on my side in the negotiation. However, I appreciate the efforts that the Minister has gone to in trying to address some of the issues raised by my noble friend Lord De Mauley in Committee. Particularly welcome is Amendment 39, which places the role of the lord-lieutenant into primary legislation, as opposed to the Government’s previous position of leaving governance arrangements solely to secondary legislation.

More from The Earl of Minto (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.