T

The Earl of Minto (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 20 October 2026

Debate

Armed Forces Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I set out in Committee why these Benches cannot support the amendments from the noble Baronesses, Lady Brinton and Lady Bennett. As this is Report, I have no further comments to add. My noble friend Lady Goldie and I have retabled our Amendment 56 as it is the firm view of our party that the ECHR, however well intended, has, through the ever-expansive jurisprudence of the Strasbourg court, mutated into an instrument that is actively opposed to our national interest. At a time when it is widely acknowledged that Britain faces the most significant threats to our security and safety in decades, and where politicians of all parties are frequently repeating the phrase, “National security is the first duty of government”, how can it be right that those who we ask to serve and face up to real danger on behalf of us all continue to face the possibility of being hauled before courts for simply doing their job? None of us has an issue with the words as written down in the convention all those years ago. The issue lies with the application of the convention and the expansion of its interpretation. My noble friend Lady Goldie mentioned in Committee the Al-Skeini ruling in 2011, which is just one such example of this ever more expansive application. Noble Lords will be aware of lots of other such vexatious examples. In Committee, the noble Lord, Lord Coaker, said: “The argument the Government put forward is that the disapplication of the Human Rights Act does not prevent the application of the ECHR”.—[Official Report, 8/9/26; col. 689.] I appreciate that, and indeed I agree: I know that, so long as we remain a party to the European convention, domestic legislation cannot remove the application of the convention. However, that is not what I am arguing here. What I am saying, and the noble Lord, Lord Faulks, expressed this point with customary clarity in Committee and indeed today, is that the Human Rights Act permits a person to bring proceedings against our Armed Forces relating to an overseas operation, in reliance upon the convention rights in our domestic courts. This is a situation that my amendment attempts to rectify by removing the domestic remedy of the Human Rights Act but, most importantly, only in connection with the actions of our Armed Forces personnel when deployed by the Government on overseas operations. That would not solve the whole problem, and I do not claim it to be a silver bullet. However, short of leaving the ECHR entirely—which will be the ultimate preference from these Benches—the solution offered by Amendment 56 must be seen as the next best option. I reiterate, because this is an important point, that I do not wish to give our Armed Forces blanket immunity. None of us wishes to see British soldiers engage in looting, the deliberate mistreatment of prisoners of war or sexual violence. Those remain crimes and they must be prosecuted. Importantly, our Armed Forces would not want complete immunity either; they are taught to hold themselves to the highest standards and they would expect us to continue to do so. That is why we have included in this amendment a declaratory subsection explicitly stating that British troops deployed on overseas operations remain bound by the law of armed conflict. I appreciate that that has no legal effect because they remain bound by that law regardless, but it is there to ensure that the fact is put beyond any doubt. There is a problem here, as I note even the noble Baroness, Lady Brinton, acknowledged to some extent in Committee, and we are offering the Government a way to rectify it. I hope the Government will soon see sound sense and understand that we cannot, in reality, be seen to ask our Armed Forces to serve, fight and potentially make the ultimate sacrifice while we permit the possibility of future persecution in our courts. That just cannot be right. Therefore, when Amendment 56 is called, I will seek to test the opinion of this House.

More from The Earl of Minto (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.