L

Lord De Mauley (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 20 October 2026

Debate

Armed Forces Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I was sorry to hear that the noble Lord, Lord Coaker, was unwell, and I was very grateful to him for his letter of 13 October in which he set out a number of government amendments to the Bill, including several on the RFCA element in Clause 39 and Schedule 6. I should mention my interest as chairman of the Council of Reserve Forces and Cadets Associations. I thank the noble Lord, Lord Coaker, in particular, in his absence, as did my noble friend Lord Minto, for agreeing to bring the lords-lieutenant back into primary legislation and for the establishment of a national council. He also said that arrangements would be made for up to six regional council chairs to be appointed as members of the RFCA board and that they would be able to participate and vote, maintaining the historic links between defence and the regions. I am grateful that they will be able to participate fully and to vote. My issue is with the little words “up to” in the context of the number of regional chairs to be appointed to the board. My noble friend Lord Minto referred to the importance of having six regional chairs out of the total of 13 regions represented on the board to represent the nationwide RFCAs. That is because it would allow representation of each of the devolved Administrations—Scotland, Northern Ireland, and Wales—and would provide three representatives for England. That is three out of its nine regional chairs, while Northern Ireland and Wales each would have its only chair permanently on the board, and Scotland would have one of its two. England is by far the most populous of the four countries, being home, according to Google, to 85% of the population of the United Kingdom, so it would be ridiculous to suggest that England should not have half of all the regional chair element of the board. That inevitably leads to a need for not fewer than six representatives of the regional chairs on the board. The nub of the issue I have with the Government’s amendments, therefore—the Minister must not think me ungrateful, because I appreciate that they have come a long way—is in government Amendment 28, the effect of which is to make paragraph 2(2) of new Schedule 4A read: “The number of executive members and representative members must be less than the number of non-executive members”. My noble friend Lord Minto has explained how the MoD could arrange that, in reality, therefore, no representative members sit on the board. Although the Government have allowed themselves through Amendment 26 to appoint up to 10 non-executives, this is discretionary and it seems to me unlikely to happen, both because it would create a large board, which I cannot think any of us would find very attractive, and because the Treasury would surely question payment to so many non-executives, because the Bill still insists that they be paid. Compounding this, new paragraph (4A) in government Amendment 39 says “but there are to be no more than six representative members at any time”. This has all come about because of a concern among officials that the regional chairs might somehow outvote the other board members and expose the organisation to unacceptable risk—something, of course, that none of us wants. There are, however, so many reasons why this is unthinkable. Of the RFCAs’ total annual spending of £120 million, for example, more than 95% is tied down in payments for leases, rent, rates, people costs, fixed contracts for IT, property maintenance and so on, and in projects for which the business cases have the approval of one of the single services. There is therefore literally no latitude for spending outside the set parameters. Furthermore, the chief executive being appointed by the department as the accounting officer can exercise his or her veto if any board member is to propose any inappropriate action, as set out in His Majesty’s Treasury’s own publication, Managing Public Money. That brings me to what is perhaps an even more important point. Amendment 28, by suggesting that the executives, including the chief executive and the finance director, would gang up against the chairman and non-executives, is completely absurd. You would be placing your entire trust in the non-executives, who, albeit appointed through the OCPA process, are paid some but by no means all of their income by you, but you will not trust the executives, who are also appointed by you, who are even more heavily vetted, and who are entirely reliant on you for their pay packet. This could have arisen only out of the thought process of a mad conspiracy theorist. I would be keen to see the back of Amendment 28, while I warmly welcome Amendment 39A from my noble friends Lord Howe and Lord Minto. Let us focus on the big picture. We are attempting either to create an effective NDPB or to strengthen further the current model, as in fact was suggested by the National Audit Office. In a national organisation which stretches from the outer isles, Shetland and Orkney, to Land’s End and the Channel Islands, one that embraces the rich regional heritage of the United Kingdom, why would not one wish for appropriate regional representation on the board to provide that vital link between national strategies and policies and their implementation at local level, rather than dancing on a pinhead about some theoretical perception of risk? To put that regional representation in doubt, as these government amendments do, flies in the face of Prime Minister Burnham’s stated aim to push power down to the regions of the UK. Giving members the impression that they might have only minimal representation on the national board because it is not in accordance with Cabinet Office and Treasury guidelines, as it might create financial and government risk, is frankly nonsense. It is an insult to volunteers, who readily give up their time at no cost to the taxpayer because they understand the importance of the reserves and cadets to the national effort, to resilience and to defence of the homeland, and who wish to serve and support. They should be applauded, not treated as high-risk vigilantes. Furthermore, there are plenty of checks and balances in the Treasury’s own guidance, Managing Public Money, chapter 3, and Defence Council letters of delegation to regional chairs, to ensure that board members carry out the duties assigned to them in accordance with government guidelines. A further matter that I have not today pressed by way of amendment is my suggestion made in Committee that the detail of how the membership of the RFCA is to be selected should be set out in primary legislation. Can the Minister assure me that the draft regulation that the noble Lord, Lord Coaker, showed us, which did set out the detail, will indeed be brought before Parliament in substantially the form we have been shown?

More from Lord De Mauley (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.