L

Lord Katz (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 20 October 2026

Debate

Armed Forces Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Brinton, for moving Amendment 16 on behalf of the noble Lord, Lord Thomas of Gresford. I join her in wishing him a very speedy recuperation; we all join her in hoping to see him back in his place as soon as possible. As the Government set out in Committee—which I will not quote as extensively as the noble Baroness did—the judge advocate and the service members of the board discussing and deciding on sentence together is not an anomaly or a weakness of the court martial; it is one of its strengths. I acknowledge the noble Lord’s concerns that lay board members have not had the training in and exposure to matters of sentencing that judge advocates and magistrates have had, while the board members exercise unrestricted sentencing powers. The judge advocate, in any case, is the expert on sentencing, as my noble friend Lord Coaker said in Committee. They give the board the legal framework, identify the relevant sentencing guidelines and set the proper parameters within which the sentence must be considered. The discussions of the board, like the deliberations of a Crown Court jury, are confidential and should never be disclosed or discussed outside the board itself. No formal records are kept of individual views expressed during board deliberations. Failure to have regard to the relevant guidelines and parameters in sentencing would open the way to appeal in the Court Martial Appeal Court. In response to the noble Baroness’s question, in 2025, 20 appeal notifications were submitted to the Court Martial Appeal Court; 12 were related to the conviction, seven to the sentence and one to both conviction and sentence. These eight are just over 3% of all the court martial sentences in 2025. No information is recorded about whether a majority decision was made against the advice of a judge advocate for the reasons I have already set out. This amendment would reduce the board’s role from one of equal participation to one of consultation only. As such, the board’s understanding of modern service life, operational pressures, values and standards, and current military capability and technology could be consulted but ultimately rejected. The current position, whereby the judge advocate and the military members of the board discuss and decide the sentence together, is one of the strengths of the court martial system. The Government contend that the balance is the right one. The judge advocate provides the legal expertise and safeguards, and the lay board members provide current military experience and judgment. The recent Court Martial Appeal Court judgment in the case of R v Barton-Kennedy acknowledged the value of this collective military expertise in applying sentencing guidance to reach the appropriate sentence. I hope I have provided at least some assurance to the noble Baroness and, in absentia, the noble Lord, Lord Thomas of Gresford. I suspect from her comments that we may revisit this at a future date. For the meantime, I hope that she is content to withdraw her amendment.

More from Lord Katz (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.