B

Baroness Brinton (LD)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 20 October 2026

Debate

Armed Forces Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I have re-laid my noble friend Lord Thomas of Gresford’s amendment from Committee, because he is still recuperating from his surgery a few weeks ago. We miss him and hope to see him back here very soon. My noble friend is the president of the Association of Military Court Advocates and has repeatedly raised in your Lordships’ House the arrangements for sentencing in a court martial. At Second Reading, he said: “In this country, the sentence is determined by the board sitting with a judge advocate, who advises the members on the law and the scale of sentence recommended by the Sentencing Council for a particular offence. In the event of an equality of votes among the members of the board, the judge advocate has a casting vote. I have argued in the last two Armed Forces Bills that, in the modern era, the judge advocate in the UK system should sentence alone, on the basis that the exercise of sentencing today is highly technical and beyond the competence and experience of members of the board who, unlike magistrates, have no training and have probably never been in court before and are unlikely to be there again”.—[Official Report, 6/7/26; col. 66.] In Committee, I referred to my noble friend’s arguments on this matter. The noble Lord, Lord Coaker, responded to me by saying: “The judge advocate is of course the expert on sentencing. It is true that any sentence passed by the court martial must be determined by a majority vote, meaning that the judge advocate’s voice could, theoretically, be outweighed. However, the judge advocate will give the board the legal framework, identify the relevant sentencing guidelines and set the proper parameters within which the sentence must be considered. Failure to have regard to those guidelines and parameters opens the way to an appeal in the Court Martial Appeal Court”. He added: “It is also important to remember that, while military experience informs sentencing, it does not displace the legal principles governing it. Any mitigation advanced on behalf of an offender—whether arising from previous operational service, commendations, awards or personal circumstances—must be assessed within the sentencing framework directed by the judge advocate and in accordance with applicable sentencing guidelines. To be clear, board members are not free to substitute personal views of military merit for the lawful sentencing exercise, and any sentence that failed properly to reflect the relevant legal principles would be liable to appeal”.—[Official Report, 2/9/26; cols. 228-229.] The problem is that those two paragraphs contradict each other. If the judge advocate advises the other members of the panel to go in one direction, and they choose not to, the judge advocate’s vote is powerless against the majority. Arguing that any such decision could then be liable to appeal demonstrates exactly the argument that the judge advocate is the expert. Can the Minister say whether any data has been collected on the reason for any appeals in a court martial since 2011 so that we can see whether this is actually an issue and not just a matter of principle? As my noble friend Lord Thomas says, this is important and should be considered. If there are any examples, how many relate to a majority decision made against the advice of the judge advocate? That is why Amendment 16 proposes that the judge advocate should make the decision alone. While we will not make progress on this today, my noble friend is undoubtedly an expert in this area; his argument is effective and he aims to strengthen the court martial. I suspect we may return to this in future. I beg to move.

More from Baroness Brinton (LD)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.