Contribution
My Lords, when I saw that my Amendment 52 had been grouped this way, in a group titled by the Government Whips’ Office as “service personnel welfare”, I wondered whether it sat easily with some of the other issues that we will touch on in this debate. On reflection, I think it does, because the huge debt of gratitude that we owe to our service men and women lasts long beyond their time on active service. In the case of those who have, very sadly, laid down their lives in the service of our nation, it lasts forever.
I should say, as I did in Committee, that I support the aims of Clause 49 and the changes His Majesty’s Government seek to make to speed up the processes and broaden the remit of the Protection of Military Remains Act 1986. As we touched on in our earlier debates, I think that might benefit from greater precision about the term “in military service” in new paragraph (b) in Clause 49(2)(b). Does that, in the case of vessels, relate solely to those that have been formally commissioned or requisitioned, or is it to be assessed by reference to the functions and activities they were carrying out? If the Minister can say more about that, it may be helpful.
The Minister will be aware of the concerns I raised in Committee about a specific but consequential area of law relating to military shipwrecks. It was informed by research conducted by a team of academics at the University of Plymouth, led by Associate Professor Jason Lowther, and brought to my attention by the Joint Nautical Archaeology Policy Committee, which I know from my time at DCMS as Heritage Minister. In brief, these academics’ research has led them to the conclusion that the UK has inadvertently removed, or at least weakened, the protection of sovereign immunity afforded to Royal Navy wrecks and other Crown vessels. That long-standing principle is used to protect some 5,000 British vessels which lie at the bottom of seas and oceans across the globe. Quite apart from the heritage and historical significance of those vessels, many of them constitute the last-known resting place of UK military personnel who have given their lives in the service of this country.
The removal of the protection afforded through sovereign immunity places these vessels at risk of salvage by foreign nations or other actors, such as has most regrettably occurred in the recent cases of HMS “Prince of Wales” and HMS “Repulse” off the coast of Malaysia, and HMS “Exeter” and HMS “Encounter” in the Java Sea. We should be clear what that means: it is the graves of British service personnel being looted for scrap metal.
The academics who conducted this research were naturally concerned at their finding and have taken great pains to raise it with the Ministry of Defence and others before they are compelled to publish the research that has been publicly funded. I am very grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Coaker, for taking the time to meet me and Professor Mike Williams from that research team, along with officials and lawyers from the Ministry of Defence, to discuss this matter. Like others, I wish the noble Lord a speedy recovery. Although it was a helpful meeting, there is still a point of law that is at least debatable, and this is a matter where clarity is certainly needed. I have retabled the amendment which I brought before your Lordships in Committee. It is, as I said, not an elegant or complete solution—not least because of the problems of scope in this Bill.
I hope the Minister will be able to say a bit more about the Government’s thinking in relation to the question of law that the academics have raised. Can she confirm whether it is still the position of the Ministry of Defence that Section 230(1) of the Merchant Shipping Act 1995 applies only in UK territorial waters, and that sunken state wrecks beyond our territorial waters remain protected from unauthorised salvage under the principle of sovereign immunity? Is she confident that a salvage claim by a foreign nation or vessel could be resisted by a reasonable prohibition under Article 19 of the International Convention on Salvage? Above all, will His Majesty’s Government act with some urgency to ensure that the legal position, which offers protection to the remains of military vessels and the war graves of British service personnel, is clearly understood not just in our courts but around the world? I beg to move.