Contribution
My Lords, the noble Lord, Lord Faulkner of Worcester, and I have Amendments 222 and 225 in this group. The first, Amendment 222, would require Great British Railways
“to include provision for heritage rail operators in its access and use policy”.
As we turn our attention in Committee to that access and use policy, noble Lords may think it eccentric that we start with the implications for heritage rail operators, but this is an instance where the implications for them are much the same as for operators of other kinds, be they freight operators, open access operators or those working in a devolved manner in regions across the UK. This may be so in perhaps a more granular and specific way but, as the Minister knows well, a number of companies operate heritage charter services on the main line. Such companies include Vintage Trains, LSL—Locomotive Services Limited—West Coast Railways, and Belmond, whose British Pullman I had the pleasure of seeing speeding through Denmark Hill station on Friday last week.
All are important parts of the UK’s soft power, as well as engines of our visitor economy. West Coast Railways’ the Jacobite is known better in some quarters as the Hogwarts Express from Harry Potter. It draws tourists from around the world to come and see the Glenfinnan Viaduct, and to visit the Scottish Highlands and west coast. They form memorable occasions for families of all generations, forming the backdrops to significant birthdays, wedding anniversaries and much more.
They are also an important recruiting sergeant for our railways, not just in making rail travel attractive and encouraging people to think about travelling by rail rather than road, but by inspiring the next generation of engineers, drivers and much more. These charter services are also anchor attractions in the areas in which they operate, forming an important spur to hospitality and tourist businesses right across the United Kingdom.
Since 1993, they have operated on the basis of goodwill rather than a statutory guarantee. There is no mention of heritage charter services in the 1993 Act, as the Minister knows, but the direction of travel when that Act of Parliament was passed is very different from the one that we confront today. The whole thrust of the 1993 Act was to open the railways to a series of other operators and providers with common track and infrastructure. The purpose here is to set up a single controlling mind in Great British Railways and, in some ways, puts GBR in the intolerable position of having to decide on the allocation of capacity while being a major operator itself. That is a concern not just for charter and heritage operators but for many others.
In our Amendment 225, the noble Lord, Lord Faulkner of Worcester, and I have suggested some criteria to try to make the decision-making process of GBR a bit clearer, for the sake of better decision-making and to give some certainty and surety to other operators. For instance, we think it should consider
“the period of time a non-GBR operator needs to promote their operation and manage their alterations, … the impact of train cancellations and schedule variations … the commercial interests of non-GBR train operators, … the enhancement of rail travel that non-GBR train operators bring”,
and much besides.
There is some nervousness among heritage operators, and other operators of all forms, about the lack of certainty set out in the Bill as drafted. That is important for the complex routing and planning decisions that have to take place for these services to occur and for those booking and looking forward to journeys, particularly those centred on important occasions. Many of the companies, although commercial operations, operate on tight margins and are connected to charitable trusts that look after heritage locomotives and rolling stock. Therefore, even minor alterations in decision-making have significant implications for their businesses and their viability.
There are no checks and balances written into the Bill. There is an opportunity, as we look at this, for the Committee to decide whether Parliament ought to set these out more clearly in the Bill. As we have touched on in other areas, if we are passing legislation now which lasts as long as the 1993 Act has, while the Minister has a strong reputation for his protection of, championing of and affection for our railway heritage, we want to ensure that the regime that we are bringing about stands the test of time under future Ministers and Governments, too.
Heritage operators, like others, believe that the starting point should be a right of access which might then be subject to operational conditions and decisions. This does not just affect those operating charter services on the main line but has implications for those operating on a mixture of preserved and main lines—for instance the North Yorkshire Moors Railway, the North Norfolk Railway, the Swanage Railway and others—and for those which rely on the main line to move locomotives and others around the country for galas and to reach preserved lines in different parts of the country.
The current model for heritage and charter operations on the national network generally works well at the moment, but it is dependent on the right people in the right places within Network Rail and in government who want to make it happen and who often move heaven and earth to ensure that it does. The Bill and the access and use policy give an opportunity to ensure that this vital part of our heritage railway landscape and, indeed, other operators which rely on our railways have a firmer and more certain footing in the generations to come. I beg to move.