L

Lord Jackson of Peterborough (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 20 October 2026

Debate

EU, Euratom and UK Agreement on Gibraltar

Contribution

My Lords, as a member of the European Affairs Committee, it is a pleasure to take part in this debate, and I join in the congratulations to the noble and gallant Lord, Lord Stirrup, the chairman of the committee. The noble Lord, Lord Barrow, who is deputising, made an excellent contribution and adds great heft to work of the committee. I will concentrate substantially on residency and the ramifications for the labour market, but I also want to talk briefly about two much bigger issues. One is the use of the Constitutional Reform and Governance Act 2010 in the scrutiny and oversight of international treaties and agreements. I believe we have a weak treaty scrutiny regime. The 21-day sitting period for ratification does not require Parliament to scrutinise, debate or even vote on treaties and is poor compared with other jurisdictions, notably the United States Senate, where a two-thirds majority is required to push through a treaty. Little time is given to consider the documents in detail, and now we have no European Scrutiny Committee in the other place that omission is compounded. We cannot influence the terms of arrangements or treaties. The implementation of statutory instruments is subject to scrutiny, but that is not the same as influencing the treaties themselves. I also want to talk about Brexit. I hate to do it, but I slightly disagree with my noble friend Lord Tugendhat. I take issue with the idea that Gibraltar’s autonomy and decision-making should be central to this issue. They are important, but they are not the primary issue. Gibraltar has 40,000 people; the ancient county of Rutland has 42,000 people, but we do not build foreign policy around the views of the people of Rutland. The point is that the British Government have a duty and a responsibility to look after the interests of and to observe and respect the democratic will and the parliamentary sovereignty of the United Kingdom, and this treaty, or arrangement, undermines that. Martin Selmayr, then chef de cabinet to Jean-Claude Juncker, famously said in the wake of Brexit in 2016 that the EU had two objectives: first, to make Brexit as difficult as possible—I think it has probably succeeded in that endeavour—and, secondly, to ensure that the UK had no long-term competitive economic advantage over the EU, so we must be unsentimental when we are considering treaties, agreements and arrangements with our friends in the European Union. There is an issue of sovereignty. Notwithstanding the legal advice that has been received on Article 2, which, no doubt, the Minister will pray in aid, the treaty diminishes UK sovereignty by backing Gibraltar into the Schengen regime. The Spanish Government’s summary confirms that Spain will carry out Schengen controls at the airport and port. Spain may object to the issuing or renewal of residency permits on specified grounds, and Gibraltar will be compelled to notify Spain of all current residence permit holders. Also, Spain is authorised on behalf of the EU to issue short-stay visas for individuals wishing to visit Gibraltar. On a related matter, and this has been raised by the noble and learned Baroness, Lady Butler-Sloss, I am concerned at the potential reach of the CJEU and the requirement dynamically to align domestic legislation with the EU as it is developed and updated under Articles 19 and 20 of the treaty—a significant erosion of sovereignty. We know that the EU is always, in terms of dispute resolution mechanisms, jealous of its autonomy and strictly adheres to interpretation of the acquis by the CJEU, often to the disadvantage of the other party. Will the Minister confirm that the Government will take a robust approach on this issue? Similarly, will he reassure us that Articles 22 and 23 of the agreement, in respect of the co-operation council and special committees and their ability to amend the agreement, will not be exercised without good reason and in anything other than exceptional circumstances? On dynamic alignment and the single market, is the Minister in a position to estimate the likely financial obligation that Gibraltar will need to meet by way of financial contributions to the regional cohesion fund? I will leave my noble friends to interrogate the Minister on the customs union and trade implications, but the following are a few of the outstanding unresolved issues that His Majesty’s Government may wish to address. The treaty does not allow the gaming industry in Gibraltar to serve EU customers directly. The costs of transaction and the tax implications of transaction rules and state aid alignment costs, especially in retail and trading firms, is not altogether clear. The treaty ends Gibraltar’s long-standing VAT-free regime in favour of Spain’s tax equalisation policy, and we know that Spain is not a slacker in respect of the collection of taxes that are due. Finally, as I raised it in the committee with Mr Picardo, the Chief Minister, I wish to focus on Gibraltar’s new residency regime and the labour market implications. I interrogated the Chief Minister for very good reasons. To be fair, he was kind enough to write promptly to the committee to address some of the issues that I had raised in the meeting. This is an aspect of the implementation of the new arrangement to which I very much hope the Minister will give careful consideration. Three provisions seem particularly troubling. First, a new employee seeking residence in Gibraltar must ordinarily earn at least £37,500 per annum. This is a remarkably high threshold for residency. It excludes many junior and early-career jobs as well as a range of perfectly respectable occupations from the normal route to living in Gibraltar. There are exceptions, including arrangements for applicants under 30 and governmental discretion in other cases, but they do not remove the fundamental problem. A British citizen offered a job in Gibraltar paying £30,000 may be perfectly entitled to work in Gibraltar but will not ordinarily qualify to live there. Where is that person expected to live? The answer, of course, is Spain. This creates a potentially extraordinary distortion in the labour market. A Gibraltarian employer wishing to recruit someone already resident across the border in Spain does not face the same practical relocation problem as when recruiting a British citizen from the United Kingdom. There is therefore an obvious incentive to recruit from the existing Spanish-resident cross-border workforce. The long-term political and demographic consequences of such an incentive, quite apart from the economic consequences, deserve serious consideration by the Government. Secondly, there is the age restriction. Under the ordinary eligibility criteria, an applicant must be aged 55 or younger. The Chief Minister has discretion to admit somebody above that age where that is considered to be in Gibraltar’s interest, but that does not remove the fundamental distinction that an otherwise entirely suitable British citizen aged over 55 no longer falls within the ordinary route to residence simply because of his or her age. Indeed, Gibraltar’s own published guidance states: “The purpose of the age requirement is to make sure people contribute to the economy for a significant period before they are entitled to live in Gibraltar longer term”. But the economic consequences begin well before the age of 55. Consider a 49 year-old senior professional with a spouse and children contemplating moving his family to Gibraltar, buying a home and establishing the remainder of his career there. Would he reasonably make that commitment if he was uncertain about his ability to remain after retirement? This brings me to a related and perhaps even more fundamental issue. For a new British resident, the pathway to Gibraltarian status now requires 20 years of residence. Gibraltarian status ultimately provides an unrestricted right to reside in Gibraltar. What, therefore, is the secure, long-term position of a British citizen who moves to Gibraltar, works and pays taxes there for, say, 10 or 15 years and establishes a home and family there but then retires before completing the 20 years necessary to apply for Gibraltarian status? Thirdly, residence permits under the new regime are renewed annually. How is somebody expected to confidently move a family, establish a career, purchase a home or make a substantial long-term investment in Gibraltar when residence is subject to renewal every 12 months? Taken together, these provisions seem capable of producing precisely the opposite result of what one might have expected after such a lengthy negotiation. They have the potential to discourage younger and early-career British workers through the threshold; to discourage older British citizens through the age criteria; to create uncertainty for professionals approaching retirement; to discourage families from making long-term commitments through annual renewals; to incentivise employers to recruit people already resident in Spain rather than British workers who would need to relocate; to transfer residential demand from Gibraltar to Spain; and to weaken both the lower and upper ends of Gibraltar’s residential property market. I have some final questions for the Minister. Are the £37,500 income threshold, the age-55 criteria and the annual residence renewals required directly or indirectly by the agreement, or are they policy choices made by the Government of Gibraltar? What secure route exists for a British citizen admitted under the new regime who establishes his or her life in Gibraltar but retires before completing the 20 years required to apply for Gibraltarian status? Have the Government of Gibraltar assessed whether these rules create an incentive for employers to recruit workers already resident in Spain rather than British citizens from the UK? Have the Government assessed the resulting implications for Gibraltar’s demographics and residential property market and, more broadly, for the maintenance of Gibraltar’s British character? Why is annual renewal considered appropriate for people whom Gibraltar wishes to encourage to make substantial and long-term professional, family and financial commitments to Gibraltar? The central question seems a simple but important one: which of these restrictions were genuinely necessary to implement the treaty and which were decisions taken independently by the Government of Gibraltar? I hope that the Minister will be in a position to answer these questions in lieu of the Chief Minister, who will unfortunately be Trappist-like today, unlike at our committee. This agreement ties up the final post-Brexit loose end, but it is flawed. Once again, it diminishes and undermines the UK’s status as an independent, democratic, sovereign, self-governing nation.

More from Lord Jackson of Peterborough (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.