Contribution
My Lords, the noble Lord, Lord Frost, is overpessimistic. This is a treaty that Gibraltar has studied with great care, and it wants it. I am a member of the parliamentary group and have been going to Gibraltar for many years. In May, I went with Martin Vickers MP; we went as individuals without any remit except what we wanted to do, which was to make a short fact-finding tour to find out what people in Gibraltar thought about what was then, and still is, the draft treaty. We went at our own expense, not as guests of the Gibraltar Government. We met the governor; we then went to the airport, where the Chief Minister took a great deal of trouble to take us through the new double system of entry.
On my later visit in September to Gibraltar, I experienced it as somebody entering. The new system is slow and rather cumbersome, and it takes a very long time to get through. One has to walk miles—I actually said to the Chief Minister that he ought to put some travelators in, but I suspect the passages may not be wide enough. What I understand is that continental and other foreign flights will now be able to take off and land in Gibraltar, which has not been the case in the past. As I understand it, there have not been any alerts yet—and as I also understand it, if somebody is refused entry by Schengen, by the Spanish, they can enter and work and live in Gibraltar, if that is the decision of the Gibraltarians. Although it is a system for two, it works first for Spain and the rest of the EU, and quite separately for Gibraltar. That is what I understand, and I find it difficult to see why people think that this may be a matter of some controversy.
After visiting the airport, we met the commissioner of the British base. We were assured, as is absolutely clear, that the treaty has no effect on the sovereignty and working of the base. But there is co-operation with the Spanish in the provision of a Spanish military liaison officer with very limited remit. We were told that an American nuclear submarine had visited the previous day. I also understand that Americans visit the base regularly and frequently. It is clear that the Americans recognise the importance of the base, its role and its strategic position in NATO. We talked to retailers on Main Street who, like those in many other countries including our own, are having problems. They had reservations about the impact on them of the treaty, but no one opposed it. They looked at the good of Gibraltar as more important, as one particular retailer said, than the fact that he might have to close down.
We visited the commissioner of police, who has many internal problems that clearly need to be sorted. The Chief Minister very kindly gave us lunch, and we met other Ministers. We also met the leader of the opposition, who understandably raised issues and some objections. However, it is noticeable that in the Gibraltar Parliament, the opposition supported the treaty. We went to the hospital, which had practical problems in moving a patient to a Spanish hospital, having to either transfer the patient at the frontier and put the patient into a Spanish ambulance or use a Spanish ambulance in Gibraltar. That problem is now sorted, and it can use their own ambulance drivers.
We discussed the implication of the treaty on the university with the vice-chancellor. She referred to the new immigration rules, and we noted in our report that the university would closely assess the import on its attractiveness to prospective students from around the world. Research funding has been difficult since Brexit, and the vice-chancellor hoped that it might be eased with the conclusion of the treaty.
We had an interesting discussion with the CEO of the very large Morrisons superstore. She was clear that Brexit was a disaster, particularly for the store, and that the treaty was not much better. It might have to reduce the products it offered, perhaps from 20,000 to 19,000 or 18,000. I rather wonder whether the customers will notice much difference. She was hopeful that customers would come across the frontier as they already do, but in greater numbers. I gather that buses are now provided in Spain that bring people over to shop in Morrisons. She said that Morrisons would do as it had always done: it would cope.
The conclusions of our report are contained in the written evidence of the APPG to the European Affairs Committee. I particularly thank the Chief Minister and his team, particularly the UK representative, for their great help in helping our trip. It was extremely interesting and most instructive.
The first and most important element of the treaty is the retention of the sovereignty of Gibraltar to retain its position with the UK and make its own decisions. As we know, the British base is outside the treaty. I learned a word that I do not think I have ever previously used: fluidity. It seems to be the basis of the treaty that flows from these 1,000 pages. It means that 15,000-plus people cross the frontier every day without going through entry and exit requirements, at least half of whom work in Gibraltar. This is crucial to Gibraltar, as the workers from the small town La Línea on the other side of the frontier are a huge part of the Gibraltar workforce. It is also crucial for La Línea, as it is a poor town, and the main part of its workforce crosses the frontier every day. Fluidity means that Gibraltar has freedom to cross the frontier under a special arrangement without joining the EU—a bespoke arrangement with the EU and, I believe, probably the only one of its kind.
As we know, Brexit had an adverse effect on Gibraltar. It has had six years of uncertainty and can now move forward, knowing where it stands and with great prospects ahead. The treaty does not cost the UK a single penny —that is to say, other than the hours, days, weeks, months and years of the hard work and perseverance of Foreign Office officials and Ministers of the Governments here and in Gibraltar. All our Ministers, especially Stephen Doughty and the noble Lord, Lord Wood, are to be congratulated for holding the line, engaging and ending with a workable treaty. Even more to be congratulated are the Chief Minister, the Deputy Chief Minister—both here—and the Attorney-General. I must say that all participants have worked with tenacity, huge patience and ultimate success in creating a treaty, which the Chief Minister has said is not perfect, but is good enough and hugely to be welcomed. Gibraltar is understandably very pleased with it.
I want to make a comment about the European Court of Justice, which was referred to earlier. When I was a judge, I visited Luxembourg, met the judges and sat in the court many times. I listened to the arguments and the judgments. I find it difficult to understand the noted lack of enthusiasm for the court in this country. It made a number of extremely sensible judgments needed, if not wanted, by the UK. It has only an advisory role, which I am sure it will carry out extremely well.
I would also like to say something brief about the concordat between the United Kingdom and Gibraltar. It is a very sensible agreement which answers many of the points of concern which have been raised, notably in the debate in the other place and by two noble Lords today. It sets out how both Governments give effect to the obligations under the treaty, including how the committees created under the treaty will work. I have to say, and it has already been referred to, that I worry a bit about the impending Spanish elections in November. The treaty will be completed in Brussels in December before a new Spanish Government are likely to be in place. The treaty is between the EU and the UK, not Spain and Gibraltar, and seems to be sufficiently robust to withstand criticism, but Gibraltarians may need in the future to ignore hostile rhetoric. All of us who care about Gibraltar ought to be very glad about the new treaty and welcome it. I wish Gibraltar a happy and prosperous future.