L

Lord Wills (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 21 October 2026

Debate

Public Office (Accountability) Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I will speak to Amendments 117 and 120, in my name. Before I do so, I associate myself with the remarks of the noble Baroness, Lady Kramer, and strongly support what she has just said. I am quite sure that we will be returning to these issues of whistleblowing at some length on Report. Amendment 117 is born out of the experiences of the Hillsborough families. When, finally, the Hillsborough Independent Panel established the truth of what happened on that tragic day, and, eventually, criminal prosecutions followed, the families believed that, after decades, some measure of justice might finally be done. In the event, many felt let down by the way the prosecution presented its case. Once again, they were excluded from the processes of the state addressing failures by the state. The central provisions in this Bill—the so-called parity of arms in legal representation—would not have secured those families legal representation, which could, for example, have advised them on what was going on, communicated with the CPS and advocated for them outside the court proceedings. This amendment seeks to rectify that omission. On a linked issue, I would be grateful if my noble friend the Minister could explain why the Bill contains no provision for legal aid support for victims of state failure to bring criminal prosecutions against those responsible for such failures. I stress that this need be available only when there was a reasonable chance of success and when it might be reasonably thought to be in the public interest. Those are the tests that the CPS applies in deciding whether to bring a prosecution, but the CPS is not infallible. In particular, its assessment of the public interest might be different from that of members of the public who have been most grievously affected by the state failure in question. Therefore, the question must arise: why should victims of state failure, and those bereaved by it, be denied support to take action in the event of the CPS, for whatever reason, taking a different view of the public interest? Amendment 120 seeks to address the widespread concerns that, however admirable the Bill’s intention to secure parity of arms in legal representation when state failure occurs, the legal profession, at the moment, is not sufficiently funded and equipped to deliver those admirable intentions. Amendments tabled by other noble Lords seek to address in different ways these fundamental problems directly. Amendment 120 has a more modest aim. It simply asks the Government to recognise that there might be problems in this respect that the Bill does not envisage and, at an appropriate time, to review what is happening in practice to determine whether there is in fact a problem or problems; and if that review determines that there are such problems, to then take action to address them so that the admirable intentions of this Bill do not turn out to be paper promises. If the Minister is minded to resist what I feel is a modest and constructive amendment, I would be grateful if he can explain why to the Committee.

More from Lord Wills (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.