Contribution
My Lords, as we heard from the noble Baroness, Lady Kramer, I have Amendment 124 in this group. Arguably, it might have been better placed in the next group; if so, I apologise to the Committee for not being more on the ball. I am very grateful for the support of the noble Baroness, Lady Kramer—in fact, she introduced my amendment admirably. It is really about parity and equality of funding of legal representation in these proceedings.
As we know, the Bill seeks to effect cultural change through the general duty of candour, which applies at all times. It introduces a proactive duty of candour and assistance, to require co-operation with inquiries and investigations when things go wrong, and to rebalance representation for state bodies and those affected by state failures and wrongdoing. Clause 20 is about that third pillar, but the success of the first two will have a profound effect on the cost of it.
What do I mean by that? If the general duty truly creates the intended cultural change and narrows the opportunity for obfuscation and cover-up then it will substantially reduce the need—as I think we would all like—for the lengthy and controversial inquiry and investigatory processes of which we are all aware. If the duty of candour and assistance works as intended, where there is need for investigation and inquiry, those processes will be much swifter and more efficient because all involved will be required to provide the key information at the outset. Chairs, coroners and investigators will no longer spend months seeking things which might not exist, chasing evidence which turns out not be disputed and, frankly, looking for needles in haystacks when a snowstorm of paper is eventually produced for them.
That is the context of the new provisions on parity of representation in Clause 26. Although there is an extension of the legal aid scheme to the benefit of bereaved families in cases where the state is a participant, any increased cost should be far outweighed by the savings that I have just attempted to outline: the need for fewer investigatory processes and the vastly improved efficiency brought about by the proactive assistance required by the duty of candour. No one should fear that this Bill will necessarily increase public spending if it is properly implemented. If it is properly implemented, it will do precisely the opposite.
However, there are two important elements, I suggest, missing from Clause 20. First, the matter sought to be rectified by Amendment 102 in the names of my noble friends Lady Goudie and Lord Bach relates to when and, importantly, how early representation for bereaved families should kick in. Secondly, there is the historic incongruity whereby lawyers acting for public bodies are paid a much higher rate than those who act for bereaved families. To make this point clear, this means that lawyers in the same case, at the same level of experience and doing the same work—each paid by the taxpayer—are paid a premium simply if they act for the state rather than for the bereaved citizen. Surely, that is wholly indefensible, and it is easily and appropriately rectified by my simple, straightforward amendment here.
At the Government’s request, the Hillsborough Law Now campaign—I think we have some friends from the campaign with us in the Chamber today, including their counsel, Pete Weatherby KC—has assisted in the crafting of the Bill and continues to meet with colleagues in government. The only arguments advanced against proper parity have been, as I understand it, vague references to market forces and the matter of the Bill applying across a wide range of public bodies. Quite why market forces should apply to one side and not the other has not yet been explained. Lawyers frequently appear for one side or the other, dependent only on where their instructions come from. Allowing taxpayer-funded representation to be set at different, lower rates for families is about the easiest way of improperly interfering with the market.
Margaret Aspinall, whose son was unlawfully killed at Hillsborough, famously said that without parity, the state gets Rolls-Royce lawyers, and the families get the Morris Minor. I mean no disrespect to Morris Minor owners in the Committee, if there are any. The argument that higher rates are justified just because there are a range of state bodies which instruct lawyers is also nonsensical. This is primary legislation. If it requires proper parity of rates, state bodies will know that they are able to instruct lawyers only at the legal aid rate set for families. This is fair, simple to operate and principled. There will be no need to investigate the current legal spending rates of every NHS trust, police force et cetera in the country. Instead, they will have to cap their spending at the prescribed and published legal aid rates.
That is equality of arms; it is not a lawyers’ charter. If the expensive lawyers who normally represent the state, rather than victims of state abuse, do not like it, they will be able to lobby their paymasters to bump up the legal aid rates to the rate that they think is appropriate. That is the point of this amendment. I really hope that my noble friends in government will get behind this key principle of the campaign and accept Amendment 124.