B

Baroness Benjamin (LD)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 21 October 2026

Debate

Public Office (Accountability) Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I speak on this group because there is a growing outcry for funded legal support for Windrush victims and survivors, to create a level playing field with other state scandals. For several years now, I have stood in this Chamber and called on this Government—and the previous Government—for legal aid for Windrush victims, but my pleas, and those of others, have fallen on deaf ears. Windrush victims and survivors continue to be desperate for help. They have had to face the hostile environment and have gone through hardship and insecurities, yet are still being treated unfairly. Windrush victims of the Post Office and infected blood scandals can receive funded legal representation. Their schemes provide greater institutional independence, access to legal and expert evidence and routes to independent panels and tribunals capable of making binding decisions. Some Post Office claimants may choose substantial fixed-sum awards, reducing the burden of proving every element of historic loss. Windrush victims and claimants receive none of these safeguards. The Windrush compensation scheme provides no funded legal advice. Claimants must rely on scarce pro bono help, represent themselves or surrender part of their compensation in private fees. Research has found average offers of compensation were £11,400 where people applied without legal advice, compared with £83,200 for some claims following legally represented review. In one case, a claimant initially received nothing but, with pro bono legal help, was ultimately awarded £295,000. The Home Office told the Public Affairs Committee that the Windrush scheme was designed not to have funded legal support to avoid confrontational and retraumatising processes. Yet it contradicted this in explaining why some claims take longer, saying that it was because claimants find the process distressing and retraumatising, and that the department progressed claims only at the pace the victims want. This is a blatant disregard of survivors’ voices, as summarised by the Government’s own independent Windrush Commissioner, Reverend Clive Foster MBE, who, reporting in the same committee, explained that the Windrush compensation scheme is confusing, overwhelming and retraumatising, with limited proactive communication from the Home Office both in terms of case updates and a clear explanation of being eligible and having entitlement to compensation. He has now begun a campaign for legal support for Windrush victims and survivors. This is most telling. Surely if the Government’s own Windrush Commissioner says there is a need for legal aid, then there must be a case to answer. Written evidence submitted by Age UK to the Public Affairs Committee stated that requirements on documents and evidence “should be realistic”, should be designed to minimise further “trauma and distress and should recognise the barriers faced by older people”, to supply historic documents. Without legal aid and expert evidence, these requirements present enormous difficulties, hurdles and adversity for the victims, who have had to endure huge stress and trauma and continue to do so. Support is available through the advocacy fund for victims, but advocates cannot provide specialist legal advice and challenge decisions on what is legal. Legal aid or funded legal support is necessary for those Windrush victims and survivors who desperately need it, because they are expected to navigate a 44-page claim form, 52 pages of compensation scheme rules and over 100 pages of caseworker guidance. As I said, many are elderly and living with poor health. How can this be justified? The Home Office needs to repent and change this policy and the requirements. I ask the Government to consider this plea and show empathy and compassion for these desperate British citizens who have been treated disgracefully and surely have suffered enough.

More from Baroness Benjamin (LD)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.