Contribution
My Lords, this has been an important and interesting debate on the first of two groups on legal aid. Before I speak to the specific amendments, I wish to turn to a modest collection of government amendments tabled in my name.
Government Amendments 136A, 136B and 137B clarify changes to the regulations governing the provision of non-means tested legal aid in relation to inquests. Amendment 137 serves to tidy up the regulations on the provision of non-means tested legal aid for legal help work, which includes preparatory work ahead of an inquest hearing. The amendment removes a sub-paragraph of the Civil Legal Aid (Financial Resources and Payment for Services) Regulations 2013. This sub-paragraph currently ensures that where an applicant is receiving legal aid for “other legal services” at an inquest through exceptional case funding, legal help in relation to that inquest will be non-means tested. Exceptional case funding is available for inquests without a means test where a failure to provide legal aid would breach, or likely risk a breach of, an individual’s human rights.
We previously amended the Bill to expand the definition of what work is covered by “other legal services”, and this now includes legal help work. Therefore, in cases where an applicant is receiving exceptional case funding for other legal services at an inquest, they would also receive non-means-tested legal help services. The sub-paragraph of the regulation which removes the requirement for a means test for legal help in these cases is therefore no longer required, and Amendment 137 removes this.
Government Amendments 136A and 136B clarify the circumstances in which legal aid in relation to an inquest is available without a means test. Amendment 136A replaces the provision that non-means tested legal help is available at an inquest, with the provision that it is available “in relation to” an inquest. This ensures that non-means tested legal help is available to support a bereaved family member’s preparation for an inquest, as well as the inquest hearing itself.
Amendment 136B ensures that non-means-tested legal help will be available where either a public authority, or a relevant public official who represents that public authority, is an interested person. The relevant officials are listed in paragraph 4(3) of Part 4 of Schedule 6 to the Bill. This ensures that both legal help and advocacy services brought in scope of the Bill will be provided where either a public authority, or the specified public official who represents a public authority at an inquest, is an interested person. Together, these amendments ensure that the legislation clearly and consistently describes the circumstances in which non-means tested legal aid is available and removes a provision which is no longer required.
I now turn to the non-government amendments in this group. I say to the noble Baroness, Lady Benjamin, that a number of points about Windrush will come up in the next group. My noble friend Lady Anderson will respond to them, and she will reply to the noble Baroness’s points about legal aid as part of that.
On Amendment 95, tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Kramer, the Government recognise the important role that whistleblowers can play in bringing wrongdoing to light and promoting accountability. I know that this is a long-standing concern and interest of the noble Baroness, and we have discussed it. The statutory framework for civil legal aid is set out in the Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Act 2012. The availability of legal aid depends on whether a matter falls within the scope set by Parliament. Eligibility depends on the underlying legal issue and the nature of the proceedings, together with the applicable means and merits requirements. Some whistleblowing-related matters may already qualify for legal aid under existing provisions; for example, legal aid may be available in cases involving an alleged deliberate or dishonest abuse of position or power by a public authority. In addition, legal aid is available for certain discrimination matters falling within the existing scope of the scheme.
Where a matter falls outside the normal scope of legal aid, individuals may apply for exceptional case funding. Such funding may be granted where a failure to provide legal aid would create a risk of a breach of the applicant’s human rights or assimilated rights. Applications are considered on a case-by-case basis. Separate to legal aid, wider issues relating to whistleblowing protections are being considered by the Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade, which has published a consultation, as the noble Baroness knows and as we have previously discussed in Committee. Additionally, most of the employees covered by this amendment would have access to trade unions—a point made by the noble Baroness, Lady Kramer—through which legal support could also be obtained. Therefore, the Government do not consider that a bespoke legal aid package for whistleblowers is necessary, and I ask the noble Baroness to withdraw her amendment.
I turn now to the other amendments discussed in this debate. On Amendment 117, tabled by my noble friend Lord Wills, I recognise that criminal proceedings can be very difficult for victims—of course the Government are aware of that. We are keen to ensure that the court experience is as smooth as possible for victims and that, if they wish to receive it, they can access emotional and practical support throughout. However, we do not believe that introducing legal representation for victims would be the right way forward. Criminal proceedings are between the state and the defendant—