Contribution
I accept the apology.
I remind the Committee of my registered interests and I warmly thank the three noble Lords who put their names to my amendment: the noble Lords, Lord Carlile of Berriew and Lord Marks of Henley-on-Thames, and my noble friend Lord Wills. So much has been taken. I will come to my Amendment 114 in due course.
I want to add just a couple of things to what my noble friend Lady Goudie said. She referred to an easily stated problem. State bodies have lawyers in house. They can instruct lawyers as soon as disaster or scandal happens and, of course, they do. On the current wording of Clause 20, the affected families are able to instruct lawyers only months or years down the line—not even when the inquest has been opened, but when the coroner designates interested person status. A current case that has come to my attention about interested person designation has not been finalised two years after the deaths.
In cases where there may be IOPC or prison ombudsman reports or other serious incident reports, long delays may and do occur. In the vast majority of cases the ultimate position will not be in doubt, but funding will still not be available. The police force will be an interested person in every controversial custody death, similarly the Prison Service, the Probation Service and the health service in respect of deaths in their domains.
The common-sense answer is surely to provide funding to families where it is likely—this is what my noble friend Lady Goudie’s amendment says—that a state body will be designated and to have provisions to ensure that the position is clarified at the earliest possible moment. The importance of this amendment is that families may need legal advice immediately with respect, for example, to post-mortems and to assist them in navigating the post-death process and inquest proceedings at a time when they are at their most traumatised and vulnerable. It is unfair if the families of those who died cannot get legal aid at an early moment, leaving those who will clearly become interested persons in an advantageous position. I very much hope that the Government will consider that amendment with care. It leaves them some scope to decide on it. It is not absolute but it says as soon as possible when it is likely. It is normally pretty clear when it is likely, if not just obvious.
What is left for me to say on the amendment tabled by my noble friend Lady Chakrabarti? I am in the interesting position of the Minister having answered her amendment, which gives me the chance to say that I do not think that the Government feel in a very comfortable position about this amendment. I am very grateful to the Minister, who has been trying hard to make sure that some justice can be done in this area.
If there is a difference between the amendment by the noble Baroness, Lady Chakrabarti, and mine—Amendments 124 and 114—it is perhaps that mine allows slightly wider scope for the Government to come to a view, and does not necessarily always link it with legal aid; it has to be minimal legal aid, obviously, but not always with legal aid. I do not always agree with the noble and learned Lord, Lord Keen of Elie, whose modest support for this was very much noted by me and other noble Lords, but this should be a question of moving up rather than moving down, and that is a principle that we want to establish.
I cannot emphasise enough that, if this does not happen, if the position remains as it is now, then there really will not be parity between the parties—and if the Bill is not, among many other things, about parity, then that would be a huge lacuna in the Bill, and it might be so serious as to make sure that this Bill, which the Government support so much and I think the House largely supports, might fail. It would be utterly unfair if this particular issue was not sorted out.
This is about rates, not actual costs. That is all that is being asked. In the field of equality and equity generally, it would be absurd, if I may say so, if the Government stuck to their position and did not allow that this is a proper and sensible amendment that fits in with the philosophy and the thinking behind the Bill. I am grateful to the Minister for seeing me and for all the work that he has done, but there is lots more work to be done on this before we reach a satisfactory conclusion.