L

Lord Carlile of Berriew (CB)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 21 October 2026

Debate

Public Office (Accountability) Bill

Contribution

My Lords, inquests are mostly very straightforward and do not raise many contentious issues, but from time to time inquests can be incredibly complicated and can raise large numbers of serious issues arising from the conduct or misconduct of those who work for public authorities. For me, the principle of the proposed amendments to Clause 20 and Schedule 6 is that, when the state is represented at public expense, bereaved families should not be placed at a disadvantage because of their means. I shall give the Committee two examples of real cases. Some noble Lords may be old enough to remember a character in “Coronation Street” called Jerry Booth, who died in his bed at home in his 30s. My noble kinswoman was but a child at the time—I see her shaking her head. Jerry Booth’s death was from a not very well-explained cause, and the local health board, or whatever it was in those days, relied upon the evidence of a particular pathologist. Counsel who was instructed on behalf of Jerry Booth’s wife, at private expense, smelled a rat and had another pathologist carry out a post-mortem. It was discovered that the way in which the post-mortem of the body had originally been carried out was extremely dubious, not least because when the second pathologist opened the body he found the sternum—the chest bone—not only of Jerry Booth but of another person inside the body. That is an absolute fact from the case. I turn to a much more recent case, that of the distinguished consultant medical specialist Dr Kim Harrison. He died in south Wales as a result of being killed by his own son, who suffered from a serious mental health condition. Eventually, after a terrible inquiry by the local health authority, from which large quantities of documentation were concealed, there was an inquest before deputy coroner Kirsten Heaven. Among the things she found were that: the son had been wrongly removed from specialist mental health care; when a consultant had left, proper follow-up arrangements were not put in place; the family’s repeated warnings about their son’s health condition were ignored; security at the psychiatric unit was so inadequate that the son was able to just walk out; and a series of care failings contributed to the circumstances leading to his father’s death. None of that would have been revealed without careful analysis carried out for the family at their expense—a family which, by the way, still loves and has contact with the boy who killed his father, the son being in a mental health institution. These two cases come from one counsel, and in both cases that was me. There are 18,491 barristers in this country, never mind the number of solicitors. These cases represent just two from a much larger pool of experience throughout my career as a barrister, and they indicate to me how important equality of opportunity is, though not necessarily in precise equality of arms. We are not talking about equal fees, but equality of opportunity to be represented properly at the cost of the state, where there might otherwise be a disadvantage against the public authority due to means. Justice demands equality of arms, or at least of opportunity. An inquest is a search for truth, not a contest of resources, and funding disparities distort that search. Public confidence depends on visible, accountable fairness. The appearance of institutional advantage undermines trust in the outcome. Families are not ordinary litigants; they are grieving citizens seeking answers following a death for which the state might bear responsibility, and they want to know. There should be a level playing field on rights, which are of little value if they cannot be exercised in practice, including during an inquest. Proper scrutiny improves public service for the future. The Harrison inquest to which I referred has left lessons for eternity—certainly in south Wales—as to how mental health services should be run and not neglected. Competent representation for families guarantees transparency and candour, and no public authority should fear equality. In this House, as we speak, there are about 10 members of the Bar, though I have not done an exact count. There are at least three in this row. Below the Gallery, we have the pleasure of welcoming Pete Weatherby KC, who has played such a significant part in the Hillsborough case which gave rise to this legislation. I urge your Lordships to take into account that a glib answer—“We’ll see what we can do about inquests” —will not be persuasive. If we do not have clear answers to the questions so ably raised by my noble friend Lady Chakrabarti, and by my noble friend Lord Bach, we will come back and we will win on Report if we must. It is essential that there should be fairness in this crucial sector.

More from Lord Carlile of Berriew (CB)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.