Contribution
My Lords, with enormous respect to my noble and learned friend, whom I respect enormously, I am afraid I disagree with her profoundly on this occasion. I will give your Lordships a little anecdote from my own experience. One day I was appearing in a murder case, and a new High Court judge called me into his room before the case started. He said, “Look, Alex, the only murder case I have ever seen was when I was a judge’s marshal in Mold Crown Court when I was 23 years-old, and I have never actually been in a criminal court since then. So, if during this trial, my first murder trial, I do anything stupid, please would you ask for an adjournment and tell the usher you want to come in and tell me what I have done wrong”.
I need to declare an interest, which has been declared by many others today, which is that I am a member of the Bar. I think I am probably safe to say that I have done more criminal cases than any other Member of this House, with the possible exception of my noble kinswoman who has just moved this amendment. I have seen it all, and I have been involved on both sides of cases and have done lots of criminal appeals.
First of all, we have a situation in which—and I use my old friend who is no longer a judge as my example—not enough people who have made their careers at the criminal Bar are appointed to the High Court Bench. There has been intellectual snobbery against the criminal Bar, and I put it as directly as that, because it has been thought that those who do criminal cases are not as bright as all the others. Well, if noble Lords look at the complexity and changes in the criminal law, as mentioned by my noble kinswoman, they will discover, as she said, that criminal cases being tried today are immensely complex. Almost every criminal case has complicated computer-generated material as part of the evidence. A great number of cases have experts and, as we discussed earlier, not all the experts are as expert as they claim to be, and it needs real criminal experience to sort the wheat from the chaff. The demand that is made upon criminal barristers in terms of engagement with their clients at moments of high tension places a special responsibility on the mental health and the stability of those people who, on the whole, manage being criminal barristers at every level very well.
So far as the arrangement of the courts is concerned, the answer to my noble and learned friend is that of course it can be done by an Order in Council, but it has not been done by an Order in Council, which is why we are having this debate today. If the Minister were to say there will be an Order in Council in the next 28 days appointing a criminal division of the High Court, I suspect that my noble kinswoman would withdraw her amendment with enthusiasm—maybe with a bit less than enthusiasm, judging by her expression, but with satisfaction anyway.
The architecture of the criminal courts is not working properly. The criminal courts are the most public, exposed, dynamic—by force, not by choice—and society-engaged part of our justice system. It seems odd that they should be lumped in—even if a senior judge takes charge of them—with a very large number of civil cases, judicial review and the Administrative Court, and not have their own separate division.
That is not just so that it has the dignity of its own separate division. There are more complaints about criminal cases than any other feature of the law. That is inevitable, because of the human story told in them. There is greater demand for there to be inspections of judges trying criminal cases. For the last 20 years, since I first wrote an article on the subject, I have suggested that there should be a judicial inspectorate particularly aimed at the criminal courts—and not one that sits in an office in London but one that literally goes out and inspects what is happening in courts if it hears that something may be going wrong, whether in a small Crown Court somewhere in the country or in the Old Bailey.
I feel that now is the time for public accountability of this very important part of our justice system to be recognised by creating a criminal division of the High Court for the whole of England and Wales. That would ensure that the quality of justice delivered to the public, which we debate so much at the moment, is publicly accountable and of the highest quality.