B

Baroness Chakrabarti (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 21 October 2026

Debate

Public Office (Accountability) Bill

Contribution

My Lords, it is very hard to talk about things such as that, so I give enormous credit to the noble Baroness, Lady Ludford, for speaking personally; it really added to our deliberations. I expressly support Amendments 102 and 114, in the names of my noble friends. On Amendment 102, as my noble friend Lord Bach put so eloquently, parity is about rates but also timing, for the reasons echoed by the noble Baroness, Lady Ludford. If the public authority that may be responsible for scandalous behaviour, negligence or whatever it is gets a head start—on top of its higher rates, in-house lawyers and all the other things my noble friend mentioned—then the bereaved family will be even further reduced and even further behind. My noble friend put that so well. That is why my noble friend Lady Goudie was so right to home in on the issue of early timing for legal advice. It is incredibly important. I will say a couple of words about Amendment 114 because my amendment should have been in this group. We agree that we are trying to achieve equality of funding for legal representation. I picked the ceiling, not the floor, for two reasons. One may make me look like an idiot, but others can decide that. The first reason was that I was wary of the argument we have now had from the Government that there is a range of public authorities: police forces, NHS trusts, quangos—the list goes on—so how do we know exactly what that rate is? I was right to predict that argument because it was in my noble friend the Minister’s speaking notes from his colleagues. The second reason was that I was courting Conservative support. This is where my idiocy kicks in. I thought that Conservative colleagues in the Committee would prefer the cap, that we would not be bumping up spending and that it was not a lawyers’ charter—all the rhetoric about the Human Rights Act, the ECHR and all these terrible things. That was what I predicted. Instead, I got the inspirational comment from the noble and learned Lord, Lord Keen of Elie, that he would rather lift the rates than reduce them. In which case, there is all the more reason to support my noble friend Lord Bach. That leaves us only with this difficulty; I am saying this only because my noble friend the Minister has said that he is open to engaging with this and getting it right before Report. How are we going to deal with all the different potential rates in every police force and NHS trust in the country, as well as the easier to predict Government Legal Department and Treasury Solicitor rates? I am sure that we can come up with a mechanism. I am convinced that there are any number of possible approaches to this. With good advice from government lawyers, we can come up with something. It could be a negotiation between the Legal Aid Agency and the public authority in an individual case. Where negotiation fails, it could be that the adjudicator, the coroner, or whoever is doing the inquiry makes a decision on it. It is possible to achieve this. It is really not that difficult. Pre-emptive cost orders are made in other cases. That is a different regime, but things can be done by agreement or order, or they can be prescribed. We can do this in order to achieve the wish of the noble and learned Lord, Lord Keen of Elie, for parity, but by raising and not capping. I hope that this can be considered. I put it on the record now so that, in response to the Minister’s invitation to have further detailed engagement before Report, his colleagues in the department can do some thinking about this and come up with a range of mechanisms for achieving the understanding of what the public authority rate is likely to be and ensuring that we have real parity—not the wink and the nudge towards it that we have currently in Clause 20, but an absolute parity on both timing and funding rates.

More from Baroness Chakrabarti (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.