L

Lord Alton of Liverpool (CB)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 21 October 2026

Debate

Public Office (Accountability) Bill

Contribution

My Lords, it is always a pleasure to join forces with the noble Baronesses, Lady Chakrabarti and Lady Ludford. I want especially to thank the noble Baroness, Lady Goudie, and the noble Lord, Lord Bach, for the way in which they introduced Amendments 102 and 114. The noble Lord, Lord Bach, will recall that we joined forces back in 2012 on the Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Bill, known as LASPO, to challenge the levels of legal aid that were being made available. I was thinking of the sardonic analogy that was drawn during those debates about how justice was open to all—just like the Ritz hotel. In other words, there are people who, because of their resources, get far greater justice than others. I associate myself very much with the remarks that have been made about those who will be subject to the constraints and the opportunities that will be opened as a result of this new Bill, which I reiterate that I totally support. I am glad that the Government have brought it forward. I want to raise a slightly different question about resources—the resources to the coroners’ service itself. I want to follow up the letter which I sent to the Minister, the noble Lord, Lord Lemos, on 6 October, concerning the impact that the Bill will have on coroners and the implications of the funding arrangements to which these amendments and others that we discussed in the previous group will refer. First, I thank the noble Lord, Lord Lemos, for his customary diligence in responding rapidly to that letter; he replied on 12 October. I would be happy for the correspondence to be placed in the Library of the House. In essence, everything in his reply can be summed up in these words that he used: “It is not currently possible to produce a meaningful estimate of the impact on the coroners’ service”. That is asking us to give a green light to this legislation without knowing whether the resources will be there to do the sorts of things that have been referred to in these debates. I asked in the letter that I sent to the Minister what thought had been given to the direct impact that would arise from the provisions creating a power for the coroner or inquiry chair to raise concerns about the conduct of a public authority or their legal representatives during proceedings, and the requirement for those conducting or participating in a statutory inquiry or inquest to have regard to an overriding objective to ensure that affected persons are able to fully and effectively participate in the proceedings. The key question that I posed there, and pose again this evening, is around resources. There is an old saying that you cannot make a silk purse out of a sow’s ear. This is a silk purse of a Bill—it is an excellent Bill—but we have to do better than giving sow’s ear resources to making it work. The key question, as I say, is about resources. I am told that the financial impact assessment for the new legislative burdens makes provision based on assumptions for an average legal aid cost of £65 million to £180 million per annum. However, in paragraphs 43 to 46 of the same impact statement, it states: “These measures may give rise to direct and indirect impacts on the overall resource burden on Local Authority funded coroner services. The potential resource burden identified will largely be driven by those cases which proceed to inquest”, and that the Government have said that they “anticipate these impacts can be broadly absorbed within existing provision”. However, given the extraordinary range in the figures that I have just cited, I do not know how on earth that statement can justifiably be made. Let us contrast that with the report that appeared on 29 July, in the Law Society Gazette—indeed, one of the figures that the noble Baroness, Lady Goudie, gave is referred to in that report. It says: “Firms will shortly be invited to bid for brand new legal aid contracts to do inquest work ahead of an expected surge once the so-called Hillsborough Law comes into force. The government estimates that the Public Office (Accountability) Bill will increase the number of legally aided inquests from the current 200-400 to as many as 11,400”. If that is correct, it will create a significant financial burden on funding to the relevant authorities. That burden is not simply financial. I note that, according to the Judicial Attitude Survey, “Salaried judges and coroners had the highest stress levels. Only 1% of salaried judges, 6% of fee-paid judicial office holders and 0.6% of coroners reported no work-related stress”. That is on the basis of the current caseload. Given the new burdens, from where are the additional coroners to come from and how are they to be funded? I was particularly taken, as always, by what my noble friend Lord Carlile of Berriew said to the Committee a little earlier: inquests are a search for truth, not a contest of resources. We have to get this right. The Minister may suggest a post-implementation review. I do not want to steal his thunder, but I suspect that may be one of the things he will say to the Committee: that they will look at the new burdens on the coroners service. Let us bear in mind the experience of the implementation of the Coroners and Justice Act 2009. I cited that in my letter and, in his response, he said, “I was the Minister at the time and we were not the Government at the time”. That is fair enough, but we can surely learn from the lessons that arose out of that legislation. This time, it will be the families who suffer—those for whom this Bill is supposed to offer remedies. Let us go to the core of what this Bill is supposed to do. It is supposed, not least, to be for “a duty on public authorities and public officials to act with candour, transparency and frankness; to make provision for the enforcement of that duty in their dealings with inquiries and investigations”. It is “to make provision”, so are we going to make provision or not? We must go to the heart of that, because if we do not, we will be held to account later on for raising hopes and aspirations and then not delivering. If there is not to be candour and frankness about how the coroners are to implement the promises of the Bill, we will risk undermining its efficacy and, indeed, trust in Parliament. If the Bill included no new demands, which of course it does, that would beg the question: what was the point of the legislation at all? It does have new demands in it and, clearly, they must be met with resources. The Minister is doing an excellent job in this Committee; I think all of us admire him for his patience and for the granular way he has gone into the detail of this with members of the Committee and listened to our concerns. I hope that he will address some of these questions and allay some of our fears when he comes to respond later.

More from Lord Alton of Liverpool (CB)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.