L

Lord Alton of Liverpool (CB)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 21 October 2026

Debate

Public Office (Accountability) Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I am a signatory to Amendment 106 along with the noble Lord, Lord Wills, and the noble Baroness, Lady May of Maidenhead. It is always a pleasure to support my friend the noble Baroness, Lady Kennedy of The Shaws, and to make common cause with her on this, as on so many other things. On Monday last, during the second day of Committee, we spent a lot of time considering the ways in which a farrago of self-serving deceptions had been allowed to replace the truth. During our debates, I referred to the 1989 inquiry established by the Government and chaired by Lord Justice Taylor, which was established to find out what were the facts and what had actually happened and occurred at Hillsborough. In reality, though, as we heard on Monday, facts were superseded by fictitious and misleading accounts. My noble and learned friend Lady Butler-Sloss intervened to say that “if … you are given a whole lot of false information or not given the relevant information, the report you make will not be correct. That happened to the late Lord Taylor, who was later Lord Chief Justice of this country. Just think how he would have felt if he was alive today to find that he had written a completely useless report”.—[Official Report, 19/10/26; col. 476.] As is so often the case, my noble and learned friend went to the heart of the matter. This amendment today builds on that and invites your Lordships to consider how a mother and a father would feel if they knew that a wholly inaccurate account had been given about the deaths of their two daughters—if they knew it had been a completely wrong and useless report. That is the situation in which the parents of Victoria and Sarah Hicks, those two teenage sisters who died at Hillsborough, have had to endure for these subsequent decades. The 1992 Hicks judgment, Hicks v Chief Constable of South Yorkshire Police, referred to by the noble Baroness, Lady Kennedy of The Shaws, was brought by the parents of Sarah and Victoria. We heard how that judgment had been given here in the House. At that time, the Appellate Lords sat in Committee Room 1, which was where my noble friend chaired the meeting to which she referred, on 9 February this year, which I attended and participated in, along with Andy Burnham, then the Mayor of Manchester. We heard from Jenni and Trevor, and, as we have heard, from their lawyer, Caoilfhionn Gallagher KC, their plea for the correction of the original court record, which had not been able to happen without the agreement of South Yorkshire Police. As we heard in the two quotations from the noble Baroness, Lady Kennedy, which I will not repeat, this is not about those children alone; this is about other people’s children as well. This is about the common good and ensuring, as they put it, similar families do not find themselves facing similar injustices and incorrect legal records. This is about a wider public interest, which is why I so admired their tenacity, courage and dignity when they came to speak at this meeting. This amendment is not just about setting the record straight; it is about people in similar circumstances being able more easily to correct the official record when necessary. The high threshold set out in subsection (2) would prevent its abuse in frivolous applications. It is very important for the Committee to note that this cannot just be used by anybody to reopen any case where they may feel some grievance, for whatever the reasons may be. There is a high threshold that would have to be met. The amendment sits well with the duties in the Bill to search for truth, candour and transparency. I hope it will commend itself to the Minister, the noble Lord, Lord Lemos, and to the Government, and that we will be able to incorporate it or something like it when we get back here on Report.

More from Lord Alton of Liverpool (CB)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.