B

Baroness Kennedy of The Shaws (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 21 October 2026

Debate

Public Office (Accountability) Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I apologise for not participating in the Second Reading of this Bill. I am afraid that I had caring responsibilities which made my presence impossible. The Bill is very close to my heart and I endorse many of the things already discussed about legal aid and participation in inquests. This particular amendment, if I might explain, seeks to grant individuals affected by public authority failures in court the right to make a court application to correct the public record. The idea stems from the experience of those who lost family members in the terrible Hillsborough disaster. Amendment 106 was developed to address the injustices suffered, and I am here speaking particularly for the Hicks family. That is why we refer to this as the Hicks amendment. The amendment is named after Victoria and Sarah Hicks, two teenage sisters who were killed in the Hillsborough disaster. Victoria and Sarah were among the 97 Liverpool supporters unlawfully killed at Hillsborough in 1989, as this Committee knows only too well. Earlier this year, their parents, Jenni Hicks, who is sitting behind the Bar, and Trevor Hicks, launched a campaign seeking formal recognition that their daughters did not lose consciousness within 30 seconds and die shortly thereafter, as South Yorkshire Police claimed for years, but actually suffered for significantly longer than the narrative that was produced and promulgated by the police. Indeed, the official court records stated that Victoria and Sarah were unconscious within seconds and died within minutes during the disaster, despite overwhelming evidence from subsequent inquiries showing this was untrue. Victoria, aged 15, was the only female child victim of the crush. Multiple witnesses reported that she was crying and in distress for some time. Her sister, Sarah, aged 19, was seen by numerous witnesses who described her as being intensely distressed and panicked about the fate of her sister, and calling out for assistance. She was even seen desperately trying to hold her sister up in the surging crowd. This was not a matter of just seconds. It is now known that Victoria and Sarah may have survived for some time, up to an hour after the fatal crush started. The 30-second rule was relied upon in civil litigation following Hillsborough to argue that victims lost consciousness almost immediately and therefore did not suffer, and so their families did not need compensation. The argument was relied upon in the early 1990s, when Jenni Hicks and Trevor Hicks brought a test case against South Yorkshire Police for the pain and suffering their daughters endured as they were dying. This was the lead case, intended as a test case to help all the victims of the Hillsborough disaster. That case was dismissed throughout court proceedings and came all the way up to this very building, to the Appellate Committee of the House of Lords, which at the time was our highest court. It was brought here on the basis that the girls were assumed to have lost consciousness almost immediately. That was the position that the police vehemently put forward, relying on rather inadequate medical evidence that they had “swift and sudden” deaths. However, the Hillsborough Independent Panel of 2012 and the fresh Hillsborough inquests from 2014 to 2016 have since made it clear that this assumption was fundamentally flawed. Medical and expert evidence of a superior kind demonstrated that many victims remained conscious for up to an hour and possibly even longer. The medical evidence heard by the fresh inquests was that those who died from asphyxia at Hillsborough were likely to have been subjected to pressure that waxed and waned, and were likely to have suffered physical injuries and fluctuating levels of consciousness over extended periods of time. It is clear that this is what happened to both girls. I know it is painful for their mother to hear me describe it in this way. Despite those findings, the original court rulings and the legal record they created have never been formally corrected, and there is no way, currently, for Jenni and Trevor Hicks to have the correction made without South Yorkshire Police’s agreement. With the new campaign, Jenni and Trevor have been calling for the record to be set straight and for a “Hicks Rule” to be introduced, so that people in similar circumstances are able to easily correct the official legal record where it is wrong, and that that should be possible in future. Jenni Hicks, from Liverpool, said: “For more than three decades, the law has recorded something about” her daughters “that we now know simply isn’t true”. This is not about compensation. It should be known that the legal efforts followed an out-of-court settlement from South Yorkshire Police relating to historic claims brought by the family, so there has been compensation, but it was a settlement reached without any admission of liability and without any formal public correction of the earlier court finding. As Jenni Hicks said: “This is not just about correcting it for our beautiful daughters, it’s for everyone who died that day, and for other families that find themselves facing similar injustices and incorrect legal records”. History should record what really happened. “The injustice here”, says Trevor, “is not abstract. Because the courts accepted the police version of events, we were told our daughters didn’t suffer. We were told the law could do nothing more for them. That was wrong then, and it’s wrong now”. In February this year, I hosted a parliamentary session featuring Jenni and Trevor Hicks. Among the speakers was their lawyer, Caoilfhionn Gallagher, an eminent King’s Counsel—who is also here, sitting behind the Bar—and her team from Doughty Street Chambers who supported her in the legal work during the inquiries. They were all there—as indeed was Andy Burnham, before he became the Prime Minister—to speak about the importance of this change in law. The implementation of the Hicks amendment in legislation would allow victims of injustice to apply for the correction of the record by this very simple legal procedure. It is not as though there is not precedent: there is a similar use of corrective mechanisms in defamation and family law proceedings regularly.

More from Baroness Kennedy of The Shaws (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.