B

Baroness Kennedy of The Shaws (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 27 October 2026

Debate

Courts and Tribunals Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I too welcome the noble Lord, Lord Stace, and thank him for his fascinating speech, which was about his family, varied career and public service. I know he will bring a great deal of that to good effect in this House. I expressed wholehearted delight that the Government’s original plan to severely limit jury trials had been abandoned—little did I know. It would have been a grievous mistake and not the solution to the problems facing the criminal justice system. I am all too aware of just how terrible the situation now is. I have a great fondness for the noble and learned Lord, Lord Leveson. I count him as an inspiration and a friend. While his analysis of the problems facing the system was more or less right, his central recommendation was utterly wrong. The justice system of this nation is greatly enriched by the role played by juries. The central argument for them is the participation of ordinary folk—the people—in these processes. It is so rare that the people, who do not feel listened to, get the opportunity to participate in something so serious. It feels like déjà vu standing here talking about this because, in my early years in this House—now 30 years ago—I had great battles with the then Labour Government, who wanted to damage the jury system. Fortunately, they did not succeed, but I made myself rather difficult to my party by resisting the changes it sought. Now here we are doing it again. This is one place where people have an opportunity to legitimise a vital part of our system. This proposal is a great mistake. This is about democracy and something that is almost intangible. We all tell stories about taxi drivers. A taxi driver, when taking me home from here one night, said to me: “Do you know that I have sat on a jury three times? It has been the most important thing in my life. I just drive cabs, but here I am making a decision that affects the lives of other people. I’ve acquitted and I’ve convicted, but to be in that position makes me feel that I have played an important part in something real and vital in our world”. I do not think we should underestimate that. As the noble Baroness, Lady Chakrabarti, mentioned, judges do not understand just how much a jury is a guardrail for the judiciary. In the end, there is a division between the jury, which decides on the facts, and the judge, who guides and makes decisions on the law. That severance, whereby the ultimate decision is in the hands of the peers of the person in the dock, protects judges from ignominy, attack, reprisals and, nowadays, doxing—judges’ addresses can be found, which makes them more at risk than they ever were in the past. It is important that we think about the position of judges. I do not support removing juries from complex trials and fraud trials. The idea of a Secretary of State being able to decide whether to open the expansion up is shocking. Judge Rivlin, who sits at Southwark Crown Court and has probably tried more fraud cases than any other living judge, made a very strong argument that juries are perfectly competent to judge such cases. You do not have to have a maths degree to judge when people are being dishonest, and that is what fraud trials are all about. The Government should think again about removing the defendant’s right to elect trial by jury in “both way” cases, and about this idea that you can appeal from the magistrates’ courts. I would add to the description given by the noble Lord, Lord Macdonald, about the chaos in magistrates’ courts because of the shortage of magistrates. I hope we have had conversations with magistrates to find out whether they welcome the surge of new cases that will come their way. This has not been thought through well enough. I remind everybody that the huge backlog of cases did not come from nowhere; it is the result of cavalier and reckless cuts—closing courts, decreasing court sitting days and the ruthless savaging of legal aid. Young professionals, who have spent years training, now cannot afford to practise at the criminal Bar and are having to find other, more lucrative ways of making a living, so days are lost because of the shortage of barristers to conduct cases. Noble Lords have heard all about the disarray of courts, the dereliction of the buildings and the failure to get people to court in time because of the other areas of crisis in our system. The prison system is underfunded, so transport is not available. This is not, as the noble and learned Lord, Lord Leveson, described, just because of the remand system somehow, but is due to the whole chaos of underfunding in the Prison and Probation Service—you cannot think of alternatives to prison, so recidivism rises. There are serious issues here. I endorse the recommendations set out by the noble Baroness, Lady Mallalieu. I urge the Government to reclassify assaults on emergency workers as summary. A huge amount of the cases bunging up the courts apparently concern low-level assaults and unpleasant behaviour towards emergency workers. Cases can be removed from the backlog. A good sifting could involve removing some of the cases that would not need to proceed at all. I have made the suggestion, and I make it again, of introducing suspended prosecutions, where you do not prosecute at all in some cases but give a warning that, if you offend in the next two years, that prosecution will go ahead along with any others. We could do that. We could make use of the noble Baroness, Lady Mallalieu. She has retired from practice, but she knows how to meet thresholds and would be of great value. There must be many people like her. We should be offering a 40% reduction in sentencing for guilty pleas; that would induce many people to plead guilty at an early stage. We could divert cases into community responses if we have a better Probation Service and recruit and train people well. As someone who has spent their life arguing for better justice for women, I welcome the fact that there should be specialist courts. It is wrong for victims to have to wait years for a case to start, but we can deal with that by creating specialist courts for sexual offences, as we seek to do for domestic violence. There are many other things that can be done. The Bar Council has come up with suggestions and so has Justice—I am president of its council. There are many things that can be done, but getting rid of juries and interfering with the jury system is not the way to go.

More from Baroness Kennedy of The Shaws (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.