L

Lord Lemos (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 21 October 2026

Debate

Public Office (Accountability) Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I thank my noble friend Lady Kennedy of The Shaws, and I thank those who have raised awareness of the Hicks family campaign. I knew the sequence of events that led to this amendment, but it is still a harrowing sequence of events, and it is important and difficult for us all to understand how difficult and grieving it must be for the family to hear these events recounted. I agree with the noble Lord, Lord Marks, that part of the grief that surrounds these events is the circumstances that have led to this campaign, so I pay tribute to the family. The Government recognise the profound suffering of the family and absolutely understand the motivation and the heartfelt sincerity behind the amendment. I have great sympathy for the family’s distress, as I have said. We absolutely, openly, clearly and unequivocally acknowledge the findings of the later Hillsborough inquiries and inquests, and the family’s entirely understandable and important wish to ensure that future generations clearly understand the circumstances of Victoria and Sarah’s deaths. Transparency and the pursuit of the truth are, after all, at the heart of the Bill and the endeavour it represents. The Government are committed to working with Peers and indeed the Hicks family on the best way we can make the truth known, not just for this case and not just for the experiences of Victoria and Sarah, but for all those whose lives were lost at Hillsborough. I shall address directly the amendment before us and set out the position of the Government. We have looked at it carefully, and we are not sure that this is the best way of achieving the outcome which my noble friend set out, and for which there has been so much support in the Committee. The intention of this amendment is to allow the public record to be corrected via a new legal avenue of a statement being made in open court. It is important to make clear—this is a really important point—that court judgments do not constitute an official record of historical facts; rather, they represent a court’s determination of the issues before it, on the evidence presented by the parties to a case. Inquests and public inquiries are designed to perform the function of establishing certain facts through an inquisitorial process. It is that which has led to the concerns we are discussing here. Therefore, creating a mechanism to correct facts contained in historic court judgments would, in the Government’s view, likely create risks and have disproportionate implications for established legal and judicial principles, which exist for important reasons. The law has long recognised the importance of finality in litigation. The doctrine of res judicata generally prevents parties relitigating matters once proceedings have been fully concluded. This gives parties the assurance that the matter is settled, providing certainty and stability. It also supports legal certainty, which is a fundamental tenet of the rule of law.

More from Lord Lemos (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.