B

Baroness Brinton (LD)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 21 October 2026

Debate

Public Office (Accountability) Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I have in this group Amendment 115, also signed by the noble Baronesses, Lady Benjamin and Lady D’Souza, Amendment 123, also signed by the noble Baronesses, Lady Ludford and Lady D’Souza, and Amendment 146, also signed by the noble Baroness, Lady Ludford. I have signed Amendment 121, tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Benjamin. During the passage of this Bill, we have spoken of many tragedies and disasters that have had inquiries, inquests and/or compensation schemes. These include Hillsborough, which we were just speaking about, Post Office Horizon, Grenfell, Windrush and the Manchester bombings, as well as the atomic war veterans, sometimes known as the nuclear war veterans, who rightly feel that they are struggling to be heard, despite the atomic tests taking place up to 70 years ago. This week, we have heard moving accounts from survivors of the Aberfan disaster, 60 years ago this week, who say they have not even got to first base on being heard. Across all of these and other tragedies, victims tell us that their experiences of compensation schemes were extremely difficult and often retraumatising. Often, they had thought that it was just their scheme—indeed, I have sat in this House while one Peer after another has said, “Well, it is all right for that scheme, but our scheme is a disaster”. That is not the case. The problems are common and consistent. It is helpful that, on 5 July 2024, the National Audit Office published an excellent report, Lessons Learned: Government Compensation Schemes. This report was published just after the infected blood compensation scheme came into being in the Victims and Prisoners Act 2024. The IBCA started the latest stage of inquiries, investigations and compensation, which had all started in the late 1970s and 1980s. The infected victims were assured that, where medical information had been lost, there would be a simple mechanism used that would assume when, for example, a victim had been infected. Two years on, processes have quietly changed, and this promise, as far as the victims are concerned, has been broken. Many are being asked to find bits of paper that they did not have originally in order to prove when they got infected. Compensation arrangements also needed to be changed where somebody had died, which caused a lot of distress—then IBCA and the Government are surprised that people feel retraumatised. All the officials I have met who are involved with either IBCA or the Cabinet Office and other departments have genuinely tried to work to the best of their ability. I am not trying to be rude about them. However, there is something in the system of compensation schemes that is problematic. The NAO report sets out clearly what has gone wrong over the years in many schemes. Its Appendix Two sets out a total of 15 schemes, from the Armed Forces compensation scheme to the Windrush scheme. The NAO also assessed the structures and processes for each of these schemes. It is noticeable that they are all different from each other, and the NAO has drawn conclusions. It is important to note, as the Haemophilia Society briefing said, that uniquely among the dozens of government compensation schemes that have been established over the years, the infected blood compensation scheme is delivered by an independent body, IBCA. While it is welcome in principle, the establishment of a large new organisation has led to teething problems, including technical and operational issues, delays to compensation, and unclear accountability and feedback mechanisms. It says that the experience of the infected blood community points towards the need for a permanent, independent compensation body. Such a body would retain institutional memory, expertise and experience, save time and money when a scheme is set up, and be capable of ramping up and down according to need. With the best will in the world, that is not really part of the Cabinet Office’s brief; it is often dealing with other crises on a day-to-day basis. The Haemophilia Society goes on to say that we also need to consider a national oversight mechanism to really ensure that lessons are learned. That is because there were early missteps in the Government’s handling of the most recent case after the Victims and Prisoners Act came into force—I will not relitigate that. A national oversight mechanism should be established to monitor and scrutinise the implementation of the recommendations from all public inquiries and to hold the Government to account. That is why my Amendment 115 sets out how we might come to a body that both combines the oversight mechanism and holds within it the power to deliver some of the compensation body. At this point, I must confess that I had both a Private Member’s Bill and amendments to the then Victims and Prisoners Bill to set up a single compensation body. I listened to the points that were made by both the previous Government and the current Government. My amendment says that it should not be IBCA that does everything; let us make sure that, if it is part of an oversight body, it could also supervise other schemes that are set up, using the knowledge and understanding that it has. The NAO report gives a couple of examples that might help us understand what the issues are. It states that stakeholders have been alienated by the initial response of the government bodies—the same bodies that are now involved in delivering the compensation scheme. That is why we need IBCA, not government departments or arm’s-length government departments, running the compensation scheme. The NAO is very clear on retraumatisation. It quotes from five different examples, including one from the vCJD compensation scheme: “A scheme to be regarded as acceptable should provide an appropriate payment with the minimum of delay and without the need for repeated and painful persistent inquiries”. Ever since then, all the compensation schemes have had that problem. Sir Robert Francis’s infected blood compensation study recommended that the application process for the scheme should be “as simple, sensitive, ‘trauma-informed’ and undemanding as possible”. I have to say that that is not the view of the victims at the moment; with the best will in the world, it just has not worked like that. On the Post Office Horizon scheme, the report quotes “the importance of establishing a clear position on evidential thresholds which acknowledges the trauma experienced by claimants early on in the process”. In response to all that, the NAO states: “It is important that scheme designers and administrators work to minimise any re-traumatising effects of the process on claimants”. Other parts of this amendment set out how things will happen and who should do it. I will not go through the detail as it is very much as noble Lords would expect. Proposed new subsections (12), (13) and (14) provide accountability and transparency, from both PACA—the authority to be established—and the Secretary of State reporting to Parliament. The NAO is right: as there are many victims and groups from the various disasters and tragedies, we need consistency and expertise for compensation schemes, separate from the Government and those involved in the problems and cover-ups. That is what my amendment seeks to do. My Amendment 123 seeks to provide legal aid for seriously injured survivors participating in inquests or inquiries. I will not repeat everything that has been said so well in earlier groups, except that this group was excluded from that discussion. It is a very particular group. With both the Hillsborough disaster and the Manchester bombings, people who were still recovering from very serious injury were asked to be witnesses at inquests. The very least that a state can do is to say that although these people may have been earning above the threshold in normal times, at this moment they not only have extra costs because of their injuries but may have had to stop work until they recover enough. This is not because they are witnesses in their own cause; they are helping the country to ascertain what happened when other people died. That also helps to make the argument as to why this case should be special. My Amendment 146 is consequential on Amendment 123. I will speak only very briefly to my noble friend Lady Benjamin’s Amendment 121, because I know she will speak to it very powerfully herself in a minute. She and I have talked about the problems that the Windrush scheme faces. In her amendment, she asks for an independent review into what has gone wrong so far. I know, from my brief on the other inquiries, that this is not an unusual ask. However, one of the problems we have is that Government after Government have delayed having that independent review, which has not just made life much harder for the victims when, eventually, the Government have had to have another inquiry and another compensation scheme but cost the country a very large amount of extra money in the intervening, often many, years. I look forward to the Minister’s response and hope that we might be able to meet between Committee and Report. I beg to move.

More from Baroness Brinton (LD)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.