Contribution
My Lords, I will begin with Amendment 125D, tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Falkner of Margravine. We have already discussed in this Committee the importance of post-legislative scrutiny, so, in the interests of time, if she will forgive me, I will not repeat those points other than to note that the Government have made it clear that they will think carefully about the need for post-legislative scrutiny. I have listened carefully to the points made today regarding whether a longer period might provide a more appropriate timeframe for such a review. That is a helpful contribution to the debate. I am not in a position to commit to a specific time period or method today, but I assure noble Lords that we will actively consider this and work with your Lordships on this ahead of Report.
Turning to the amendments in the name of the noble Lord, Lord Marks, I stress to the Committee that the Government absolutely agree that we should want to implement the measures in the Bill as soon as possible. We have no interest in delay, as I am sure the noble Lord knows. This Bill brings forward significant changes, and it has been a long time coming, including a new duty of candour, an obligation for a clear code of ethical conduct, a major expansion of legal aid, and new guidance to be issued by coroners on the conduct and expectations of public authorities and officials at inquests. While I understand the intention behind the amendments tabled by the noble Lord, Lord Marks, I am not persuaded that bringing the measures into force immediately is necessarily the most effective approach.
All these measures will have implications for a large number of individuals and organisations, and before many of the Bill’s provisions can be properly commenced, important implementation work will need to be undertaken to ensure that those affected clearly understand their new duties and responsibilities. Our intention is that the new offences will be implemented within two months of Royal Assent, as is standard for measures to come into force. I state again that we have no interest in delay, and we will work to bring forward commencement as soon as we can.
The noble Lord’s Amendment 145 would ensure that those provisions to ensure parity of legal aid of inquests came into force on the day the Act was passed. This is the largest expansion of legal aid in a generation, as I think I have said several times now from the Dispatch Box, and I am sure that noble Lords will recognise that significant work is required by the Legal Aid Agency and others to ensure that systems will be ready and legal support will be in place for families to access. Our intention is to bring this into force as soon as possible and we will set out a timeline, but we would want to do that clearly and in an orderly way.
Moreover, as we remain in Committee, the final shape of the Bill is not yet known. Further amendments may be agreed that create additional implementation requirements, including the need for further guidance, codes of practice or operational arrangements—I note the comments of the noble Lady, Baroness Falkner, on that. However, I recognise the importance of ensuring that implementation is not unnecessarily delayed, and I think I have reinforced that point. The Government would be content to set out at the appropriate stage how we intend to approach implementation of the Bill and the steps that would be required before its provisions could be commenced.
Amendment 147A would mean that the offence of misleading the public did not come into force until the Government had laid before Parliament an assessment of the impact of the offence on free and frank public debate where vexatious complaints were made to the police. I acknowledge that the noble and learned Lord, Lord Keen of Elie, has set out his concerns repeatedly, both on this point and on the wider point about the potential costs of this measure to public authorities. I reassure him that the Government have been concerned to avoid the misleading the public offence being used vexatiously or for politically motivated reasons; we do not want the sort of tit-for-tat political arguments that the noble and learned Lord referred to. The tests for the offence, as he noted, have been crafted accordingly. For example, the behaviour must have caused harm or the potential for harm, and it must have departed significantly from what would have been expected of that person in carrying out their functions. However, we will of course keep the impact of the offence under close review from all the points of view that the noble and learned Lord has suggested.
Before I close, I thank everyone for their participation in these sombre and serious Committee debates. There is much more work to be done, and I look forward to working with your Lordships on that. With those reassurances, I therefore respectfully ask the noble Baroness to withdraw her amendment.