L

Lord Lansley (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 21 October 2026

Debate

Railways Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I thank the Minister for the meeting that we held last week. He has just informed the Committee about the Government’s intentions on some issues that were the subject of our discussion. It is helpful that he set this out in the way he did; it provides a degree of reassurance. I want to explain the purpose of my Amendment 224. Notwithstanding what the Minister said, it is still a relevant question to ask, but the Minister leads me to think that it might be sensible to refer to my stand part notice on Clause 63 on the capacity duty, at this point, so I do not have to repeat it again in the next group. From my point of view, we understand what Clause 59 is intended to do, as the Minister explained. It is intended to back up the establishment of an access and use policy. We have seen a draft of that from Network Rail, which would be the basis on which GBR would, in due course, set out its access and use policy. I think that I tabled Amendment 224 before we saw that draft, but I had a look at the consultation and it does not do precisely what the 2016 regulations do presently. I will just quote from Regulation 5.1 so that this is on the record: “A railway undertaking must be granted, on equitable, non-discriminatory and transparent conditions, access rights to such railway infrastructure as may be necessary for the purpose of operating all types of rail freight, or international passenger, services”. I think that the Committee will be aware that this is a statutory entitlement to access rights granted under the existing 2016 regulations. This takes us to the interaction between Clause 59, which gives the basis for an access and use policy, and Clauses 60 and 63. Clause 60 sets up the infrastructure capacity plan and, by establishing what is the best use of that infrastructure capacity, resolves the conflicts of interest between the relative users of that whole infrastructure. That process dispenses with the statutory entitlement to access rights, because they are intended to be taken into account in the infrastructure capacity plan under Clause 60. From my point of view, in Amendment 224 I am not setting out to create a statutory entitlement. I hope the Minister understands that that is not the purpose. The purpose is to say that, under Clause 59, when the access and use policy establishes what criteria should be applied by Great British Railways, one thing that should be included is the substantive criteria that it should be equitable, non-discriminatory and transparent. Looking at the consultation draft that we have at the moment from Network Rail, I am not sure that it sets out those criteria in the way we would want. This is a probing amendment, of course. The purpose at this stage is to try to see how that will be delivered in the future. Maybe we will return to it on Report, and perhaps the Minister will be able to give us some reassurance that that will be taken on board in the consultation that is yet to conclude. I will make my point about Clause 63 now to save repeating it on the next group. I was always worried about this, and I approached it and saw it as something that allowed GBR, when thinking about its requirement to provide passenger services or to provide future passenger services, to dispense with the need to accommodate other competing uses of the infrastructure capacity. Interestingly, I was looking at it as a bottle half empty, as it were, and the Government are looking at it as a bottle half full. What they mean by it is that Great British Railways is entering into agreements with the Secretary of State and Scottish and Welsh Ministers to provide passenger services, et cetera, and it must fulfil that capacity duty and exercise its decision-making under Clause 60 in order to satisfy those requirements. The point the Minister has just made, to be fair to him, reiterates something in the Explanatory Notes, which make it clear in paragraph 169 that the capacity duty and Clause 63 do not “enable GBR to secure more capacity for its own services than it thinks would equate to best use”. So we should be reassured that it is not a threat to freight. From my point of view, the Minister is reiterating—and I hope reassuring us—what he said about an expectation that the Secretary of State would not support the concept that the capacity duty under Clause 63 should be used for self-preferencing GBR relative to competing uses of the capacity. As he said, the Competition and Markets Authority, or the ORR as a concurrent competition authority, could have a good look at self-preferencing and act against it if it saw it. So that is quite a degree of reassurance. We may return to the question of the extent to which the application of the capacity duty in Clause 63 justifies the disapplication of general duties on such things as the public interest or the effective use of public funds, since there are no circumstances in which those general duties should be disapplied. But, for these purposes, I will not speak again to the Clause 63 stand part notice in the next group. I just wanted to draw attention to the fact that Amendment 224 makes the point that these are important criteria: equitable, non-discriminatory and transparent conditions. They are not reflected in the draft that we have seen now, and they should be carried forward from the 2016 regulations in that way.

More from Lord Lansley (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.