B

Baroness Wheatcroft (CB)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 22 October 2026

Debate

AI, Screen Usage and Social Media: Effect on Children

Contribution

My Lords, I am grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Patel, for his comprehensive introduction to this debate and his observation that “screen time” is a phrase that encompasses very many different activities. How many of us, in preparing for this debate, were not helped by AI, either by design or by default? I have no doubt that the resulting speeches will demonstrate that it may be artificial, but it is certainly intelligent. The impact of AI is immense, and its potential to improve human lives is too. I do not believe that children should be prevented from having complete access to it, but they also need to be taught about its potential harms and to be extremely alert to that. Until they are fully prepared to cope with its downsides—my goodness, we have already heard about how deep those downsides are—then children’s access to AI should ideally be limited. The same is true of social media. Although many of us may shun most social media, the family WhatsApp group is now a vital part of life for many of us, and of communication for those whose parents, or grandchildren, may be a long way away. My young granddaughter got to know her American family courtesy of a screen, and it did not do her any harm—the absence of that might well have done—but there is no denying the harm that some social media sites are delivering. The big tech companies could do so much more to stop that. In an ideal world, most people would want to see their children completely protected from such things. I have supported the concept of tight restrictions on young people’s access to social media, but we must be realistic about how effective this can be. Early evidence from Australia is that the ban has had only limited effect. It is, after all, being imposed on a cohort of youngsters who are incredibly tech-savvy, and they are finding ways around the ban. Any effectiveness will depend very heavily on the stance taken by parents, and that, inevitably, will vary. That is not to say that we should not do our best to impose restrictions, but we need to be realistic about the impact they will have. I want to concentrate my remarks on the area in which Government can and should have a real impact, and that is the classroom. The noble Baroness, Lady Barran, explained how schools do not even vet the quality of, and the damage that can be done by, the products they buy. Although it is essential that schools equip our children for this technological age, it means teaching them digital literacy and to be on the alert for the harms that lie in wait for them. But in many schools, it means putting them in front of a screen. In some schools, there are now children who learn all their lessons from a tablet. This is not the way that relationships can be built. Most of us will know of a teacher who had a lasting impact on our lives. Indeed, my speech will be followed by one such teacher, and I am sure he will be remembered by many of his pupils. Screens should be limited in schools. Indeed, perhaps the example of Winchester may be taken note of: the best-achieving school has banned tablets in class.

More from Baroness Wheatcroft (CB)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.