Contribution
My Lords, I feel nervous about the introductions that I have had. This is the first time for 10 years that I have spoken in the House of Lords as a Back-Bencher, and it is a delight. I thank the noble Lord, Lord Patel, for that insightful speech and the interest he has had in this subject for many years.
In 2012, along with the late Lord Lawson, the Archbishop of Canterbury and Andrew Turnbull, the then Cabinet Secretary, I represented the House of Lords on the Parliamentary Commission on Banking Standards. That was established by the Prime Minister of the day, David Cameron, now the noble Lord, Lord Cameron, in light of the global financial crash. It was a joint House of Commons/House of Lords committee, not a Select Committee but an independent body reporting to the Prime Minister and the Chancellor with our own staff, outside experts and a very wide remit. It was tasked with providing legislation solutions for banking in the UK, managed by a brilliant House of Commons clerk, Colin Lee. We delivered on its mandate, new legislation was duly implemented and the House of Lords played a huge part.
Quite simply, today I am calling for such a commission for AI to be established along similar lines to the Parliamentary Commission on Banking Standards, commissioned by the Prime Minister. Why? Because the seriousness of the situation confronting our children, society and humanity today is without parallel. We need the authority and the imprimatur of the Prime Minister to foster a national conversation, in the first instance, to demonstrate that government, Parliament, industry experts and civil society are facing up to the real-time problems we have. That is what politics has failed to do to date—we are always behind the curve. We must rid ourselves of that passive approach.
Let me give an example. When Lord Speaker, I invited the world-renowned Stanford University expert in AI and computing, Stuart Russell, to deliver a lecture on defence and security. His concluding remarks were that he was the bearer of bad news: namely, that industry regulation did not exist, and one could start a war from one’s bedroom. Today, the lethality of drones in Ukraine, the Iran war and Gaza illustrate his remarks. That speech by Stuart Russell took place four years ago, in October 2022. His warnings went unheeded. In the intervening period, we have witnessed the transfer of sovereignty from our countries to a small number of private tech companies, and we are at their beck and call. The Musks, the Altmans, the Bezoses, the Amodeis—they are the AI masters, and we are subservient to them in every respect.
What are some practitioners in the AI industry saying today? For example, Brad Smith, the president of Microsoft, says that AI is less regulated than milk or washing machines. Bill Gates says that, left unchecked, the technology could cause a billion deaths, and added that no weapon today is more powerful than the combination of AI and malign actors. Sir Ken McCallum, head of MI6, referred last week to bioweapons and nuclear war threats. So it is crystal clear that a culture of safety does not exist in the AI industry.
If Bill Gates’s chilling comments do not incentivise us all to get round the table, with parliamentarians in the vanguard, nothing will. My challenge is for the parties, Parliament, Mr Speaker and the Lord Speaker, using their authoritative voices, to convince the PM of the need for such a commission. Presently, we are drowning in information but starving in wisdom. Let us foster that campaign to ensure that we acquire wisdom before it is too late.